Andy’s Sub Shop Menu – Hornell, NY

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Hornell, NY

Based on 102 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Andy's Sub Shop 14843

Address:
134 Main St, Hornell, NY 14843

Phone: (607) 324-0043

Website: https://cyrusramsey.com/places/andys-sub-shop/

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–7 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–7 PM
Thursday 11 AM–7 PM
Friday 11 AM–7 PM
Saturday 11 AM–3 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 11 AM–7 PM

Photo Gallery

Reviews

CHET LOWE
Andy’s is under new ownership and moved to 100 loader st. I eat there today. The taste of the ham sub took me in time to when I would order all the time when I was younger… Same great taste… It is 100% spot on !! I am truly a big fan….

… more

The Blue Whale
Absolutely delicious! This is a HUGE upgrade from their last location. Andy’s staff are very kind and accommodating. If you wan a real, quality sub, forget Subway or Wegmans. Andy’s Sub Shop is the place to go!

… more

Sharie Nisbet
Unfortunately, I was not impressed with the Andy’s sub I received. The “whole sub” was only 10″ long. It wasn’t even big enough to share with my husband. I basically paid $12 for a half sub! The roll wasn’t very soft at all. I was told the roast beef was med rare, and as you can see it was anything but. There was hardly any meat on it at all also.

… more

Michelle W.
The best subs around….still, after so many years! It’s just the perfect combo- the tasty bread, the delicious meat, and the pepper relish. I was back in town visiting and I’m so glad it’s still the same here. It was a pleasure to chat with Connie!

… more

Dan F
A Hornell legend! Keeping up a great submarine sandwich tradition. Always the standard I judge every other sub “anywhere” against.

… more

Thomas Morey
First time at new location and owner. Great subs and chefs salad. Will be going more.

… more

Dak Lowery
Hornells best sub shop! I love my daily lunch subs. Awesome management and great staff.

… more

Norah Flanagan
My sub is perfect every time!!

… more

Melissa Storm
Andy’s is always a very clean and friendly environment!!! The staff is excellent!! They can take your orders 3 subs at a time and get all 3 correct!! They are fast and efficient. I would, have and will again strongly suggest and recommend Andy’s Sub Shop for excellent food in the Hornell Area!!

… more

Neeko H.
I have not been in this sub shop in about 12-13 years. I went this past weeking as I was passing through Hornell. I saw the hours were a bit weird, but it was open around 4pm. I had to stop with my wife. I ordered a BLT like I always have. It was very good, the roll was so Soft as it always is. The Brownies are to die for!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions