Based on 110 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1291 Dolsontown Rd #1, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 956-0223
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
India Scott
Delicious food, clean shop, staff was extremely kind & patient!!! Garlic knot sliders 10/10
… more
Jesse cole
Worst pizza I may have ever had in my life I don’t even think they even use sauce. I have never had a dry slice of pizza in my life until I ate here each bite had to be washed down with a sip of water I peeled the cheese up and discovered absolutely no sauce under it. Ruined my day after paying almost $70 for 2 pies and wings. My family threw it in the trash, we thought of giving it to a homeless man but didn’t want to ruin their day too
… more
Rafael Reyes III
I’ve been ordering here for about a month, and it has become one of our favorites. Great pizza, crunchy bread and crust (it’s not just the water!). When the pie comes out they place garlic butter on it.
… more
Kaitlyn Marchese
Honestly was the worst pizza I’ve eaten in my entire life. Burnt dough & cheese, couldn’t even call it pizza. Paid for extra cheese and got barley any… and the tiny amount of cheese was burnt. There was not even a light coating of sauce! I’m talking zero sauce… I’ve never seen anything quite like it. What a waste of money…
… more
Danielle Gibson
Stopped in today with my dad had a great meal Andolini’s Special salad, slice of pizza and piece of my dad’s chicken parm Stromboli. Food was great
… more
pat owen
Ordered pizza for my crew, I believe the owner answered. Asked ihow I wanted the pizza, in other words, medium, medium well, well done. My choice. On our sausage pie said he had sausage samples from a meat shop and the sausage he usually uses, suggested half and half and let him know which was better. Both were great but the traditional sausage was the bomb, thinly sliced and spread just right. The owner actually followed up with a call to find out later. The pizza there is the best hands down in the area and we will definitely be back for more
… more
Jonny Bats
The worst meatball hero I ever bought I’m 62 years old and Italian. I payed 15 dollars for meatball hero and can of coke the most expensive in the state the chopmeat fell apart before I could taste when I did it was the worst it’s disgrace to the nation please learn how to make meatball
… more
Nicole Hernandez
One of the best pizza I have found in this area. I have not been disappointed once. Customer service has always been on point as well.
… more
Harry Kristensen
Being in NY for a wedding on 11/11/22 stopped in for a snack. Living in Virginia I cannot get good pizza.. Glad I stopped had the best pizza in a very long time. And a great conversation with the owner. ( nice guy). Only wish you would open a place in VA close to me.
… more
Allison Pugliese
Stopped in this evening for the first time. The food was amazing. The sauce is so good I wanted to buy a jar from them. My son who is picky loved the pepperoni pinwheel he has declared it his favorite pizza place. The staff is so nice and personable. Definitely will be back.
… more
… View more