Down-to-earth Italian standby with a traditional menu, plus homemade gelato in many flavors. BYOB. Based on 197 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
1402 S Main St, Phillipsburg, NJ 08865
Phone: (908) 213-1800
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Debbie Gibson
If you haven’t been here you must. go. now! The food is excellent and the service is top notch! This past weekend I had a private birthday party for my daughter with 15 guests. Every one loved their dinner, felt so relaxed and treated like family. Mario and his team (Dustin was our server) are just amazing and this place is now our favorite local Italian restaurant! They food was fresh, delicious and you could taste quality. I cannot say enough good things about our experience, it was a perfect day! Thank you Amici!!
… more
kathe coopersmith
The food is very good and the prices are reasonable. I’ve been once for pizza with a group of three and once for entrees with a group of five. Everyone enjoyed their meals. The chef/owner comes around to the tables to ensure that you’re happy with your meals-nice touch! We will definitely be back!!
… more
Marla Gonzalez
It’s my daughter’s birthday today and with the stay in place order it was hard to decide what to do for her birthday. I called Amici’s and they were patient and pleasant with all my questions. I placed the order online for delivery and was able to tip online. There wasn’t any issues with delivery and the delivery person was pleasant. The food looked delicious in the picture my daughter sent me and she confirmed it was delicious as well. Thank you for allowing me to do something special for my daughter’s birthday.
… more
Blaues Kuchen
We had never been before to this place but we saw the “under new management” sign and we decided to go out for dinner. We ordered the seafood risotto and the Veal Saltimbocca. I have never had such a delicious food! The Veal was A-M-A-Z-I-N-G. The waitress was really nice and who we think was the owner was very friendly and attentive. We had cannolis as a desert…so good! I really recommend trying the white wine there! We loved this place so much that we decided to try their pizzas. We ordered the Grandma Pizza and we had had it every week. Love the sauce, the dough… 5 starts out of 5!!
… more
Drew pellegrino
We had eaten at this restaurant prior to the pandemic and enjoyed our meals; that is why we ordered a family meal from them tonight – we wanted to show our support. We ordered the family meatball parmigiana dinner, which was advertised to feed a family of four. We opened the container and found that the meatballs were small and were CUT IN HALF! There was only enough for each person to have four half meatballs! In addition, the meatballs were the mass produced kind; soft, mealy, tasteless and dry. If you choose pasta to go with them, then that is your side. We chose the fried mozzarella sticks – at least they had flavor. We were very disappointed and called the owner to politely let him know. Although there was no one in the restaurant when we went to pick up the order, when we called after eating, the owner said he was very busy and had to hang up – telling us to write a review on Google, so here it is. For $30, we got fourteen small half meatballs (seven full meatballs) 8 mozzarella sticks, and zeppole! The adults left the table hungry. Very disappointing; the food and the owner’s lack of concern. We tried to patronize a local restaurant, as encouraged during these times, but will not be back to this one. Would have given no stars, but that was not an option.
… more
D. N.
My husband liked the bread very much, ended up eating the entire amount by himself, would have preferred butter instead of margarine but saw other table had oil to dip the bread. Would request that next time. Hubby had meat ravioli, he said delicious. I had the lasagna, was good. The wait staff were very friendly and attentive.
… more
Seth Wernersbach
Got sausage and peppers meal for 4. Gross! Threw away the sausage because it tastes as if it came out of a can. Waste of $30. After reading other reviews I will not call the owner, I will just find somewhere else to go. Zepoles were rather small and tasted like they were made this morning and waited until dinner to be served. The fried ravioli was really good. It sucks cause I really like their pizza but after burning me for $30 plus dollars I just cant go back.
… more
Roseann LaBar
Food is over priced and over rated .
… more
anabela deconza
We got there at 8:20pm for a sit down pizza, realized that they close at 9pm but there was another couple seated. We felt hurried due to the waitress, host and busboy staring at us the whole time we were trying to enjoy out chewy bland pizza over the laughs and shouting from the kitchen. We didn’t finish one slice and asked for boxes and desserts to take home. Busboy kept walking around with his tray in anticipation of us finishing and taking our utensils and plates. When we got home we took a taste of the cheesecake, first of all it looked like shoe leather and tasted awful. Meal came out to 32 +, 40 bucks wasted at least the inexperienced waitress got a nice tip. First visit, last visit.
… more
Robin Bruno
We Celebrate all Family events here !!! Our last Celebration was Mom’s 86th Birthday !!
… more
… View more