Casual parlor with hand-tossed New York–style pies & ice cream in many unique flavors, plus a patio. Based on 844 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1600 S Virginia Dare Trail, Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948
Phone: (252) 441-3332
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian Romero
Large Pizza was really good! Crust wasn’t so heavy, sauce tasted tasty and fresh, and the cheese is delicious. We ended our dinner with ice cream and I would come back. I’m very happy with my experience.
… more
Laura Inglis
Great food and ice cream! Reasonable prices, friendly staff. Plenty of outdoor seating for those who want to eat there.
… more
David Williams
The staff and service was very friendly, even at closing time. The place was extremely clean, inside and outside. There were unique ice cream flavors to choose from. I found $15 for a regular size cheeseburger and fries to be expensive. This appears to be owned by the great seafood restaurant, Millers, next door. While the food, burger and fries were good, they certainly didn’t justify the neighboring restaurant pricing.
… more
Jason Cannon
Wow…. Being from Buffalo, NY the home of the world’s best pizza and wings…. I’ve been to many places outside of NYS and none have ever came close to a pie from Buffalo….. But folks, this place is close. You could have given me a pie from this place at home and I would have thought it was from home. We ordered 2 large pies and some fries. Everything was great. The staff was friendly. The ONLY problem we had was, they didn’t know how to cut a pizza in squares!!!! They wouldn’t even try. I was upset for a minute, but the taste of the pizza erased that lol. They also serve ice cream which was good also.
… more
AHM Mustafizur Rahman
Fabulous shrimp po boy and arguably the best ice cream I’ve had on the East side of the United States. Will probably be returning a few times this week during our stay.
… more
Whitney Boone
American Pie in OBX offers good food, with the Mahi Mahi fried basket being a decent choice. The homemade ice cream offers a variety of flavors, but overall, It’s a relaxed and enjoyable spot for a casual dining experience.
… more
Khloe Tucker
Very welcoming staff, place looks very organized! I ordered wings and a cheer wine the kitchen got it out to me very quickly, i opened the box to see steam and extra ranch it looked amazing. After trying one wing, i couldn’t get enough. Everyone needs to go to this place and try their wings at least once in their lifetime!!
… more
Christopher Gould
On vacation from Illinois. Not really a sit down place to eat, they have a few tables outside. We ordered take out pizza. It was good. Better than I get at home for less money. Service was fast 15 to 20 minutes at home it often takes 45+. As for the atmosphere it was fine. I was a tad worried that they told me the pick up window was out when it was about to rain but they let us pick up inside. I would eat there again.
… more
Sam Dove
I forgot to take a picture of it before we started into it but this pizza is amazing. I eat pizza all the time and this is honestly been one of my favorites. The people working were very nice also. I would highly recommend.
… more
Kathryn Parsons
Popped in for ice cream on Saturday evening. The staff members who helped us were so nice and efficient! All 7 orders were scooped and ready quickly. The ice cream here is SO GOOD – I really think it is some of the best I have ever had. We enjoyed sitting at the benches outside. Highly recommend a visit.
… more
… View more