Amato’s Pizza is a BYOB restaurant open for lunch and dinner. We serve a full Italian menu featuring all types of Pizza, Hot and Cold Sandwiches, Antipasto, Soup, Pasta, Chicken, Veal, and Seafood Dishes. Dine in, pick up or order delivery!
Let us cook for your next special occasion. We Provide Catering For All Occasions.
For a Delicious Italian Meal, Stop By Today.
Based on 127 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
55 Mill St Suite 2, Newton, NJ 07860
Phone: (973) 383-2727
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sarah Hobaugh
This was the first time ordering from them. They were the cheapest by a few bucks. Glad we ordered. The pizza is good, eggplant parm is great and the french fries were well seasoned. We will def be going back!
… more
Dennis Sivulich
Getting good Italian food in Sussex county is a challenge. Just had their Pizza nothing exciting but ok. The restaurant is eat in or take out. Nice seating clean an updated. Folks are friendly. Parking can be an issue. Worth trying if your looking for a perfect pizza. Then you decide. Just remember it’s Sussex not Brooklyn.
… more
Melanie Torres
Yes!!!! The food hubby and I ordered was AMAZING! We ordered a Large Cheese Pie and Penne with Vodka sauce and grilled chicken. The pizza was DELICIOUS! sauce, cheese, dough – PERFECT. Penne was cooked perfectly and the sauce was the best I’ve had I’m Newton thus far! And that grilled chicken was thin (perfectly) and seasoned INCREDIBLY!!! We will be back and HIGHLY recommend! BTW this is our 3 pizza place we’ve tried and love them too but this place!
… more
gundy Gunderman
If I could give zero stars I would but there’s no option for it. Was charged an open food and credit card fee. Didn’t eat there got take out. No clue what and open food fee is. Ordered a calzone and it was smaller than my wife’s panini! Calzone was listed as having mozzarella and ricotta cheese, I ordered it with ham in it. No ricotta just about a pound of mozzarella and a couple pieces or deli ham thrown in the top of the bread(whole pieces not even cut up!) sauce that comes with it was bitter and burnt. Wife’s panini (Brooklyn Panini) did Not even more than a table spoon of the “ balsamic glaze” on it if you can call it that. A couple thin pieces of grilled (frozen then thawed out of bag) chicken and WAY TO MUCH “roasted” peppers. And it’s supposed to come with fries she maybe got 10 soggy shoe string fries. Worst pizza shop in THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY! Will not be getting food from there ever again!
… more
Harmony Wilkins
delicious my brother came back with a ton of food for $16!! Will definitely be our go to. You must try Amatos
… more
Cerberus
Very friendly staff with great food. If you have a chance, order a rice ball. Reminds me of the ones my grandma made by hand.
… more
Chuck Mound
On the Pizza Hunt for the Pizza Hunters App. Regular Slice had a lot of cheese and and not much sauce. The crust was ok. Not my favorite slice in Sussex County. The service was good and people were nice..Parking was not a pleasant experience.
… more
Michele Antoch
AMATOS PIZZA is my new favorite restaurant! The new owners are friendly and courteous.The menu is large with plenty of choices for everyone. Whether you want a sit down lunch/dinner or a take-out meal, Amatos doesn’t disappoint! ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… more
Sara Cote
I give them five stars they have awesome costumer service and the food is always delicious . I order from them a sub and they called to let me know they didn’t have pickles and if I wanted something else I that show they really take pride in there customers
… more
Googel Chairmen
Wow this is messed up. Don’t be fooled by the rating on this place, people. This new owner and staff just replaced their name over top of Authentic Pizza & Pasta’s review page. All these five star reviews are coming from authentic, not whatever the hell this is. Furthermore, it’s bad enough that they have culturally appropriated the food for profit, but they couldn’t even make their own page? This is false advertising and they should start their own page, because they haven’t even opened for business yet to the public, so there’s no way they can have all these ratings. But considering the reputation that Frank’s has, I probably would use another pizzeria’s pictures as well. I’m just saying
… more
… View more