Based on 108 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
416 Sicklerville Rd, Winslow Township, NJ 08081
Phone: (856) 818-9910
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Becky Karmels
Great pizza, cheese steak and wings. Burgers are flavorless though. Delivery is fast, however, they did forget my soda once but delivered it about 1/2 hour later. Placing orders are easy and friendly. Very nice and attentive customer service. All in all… I would recommend!!
… more
Khalida Kapitanova
I love the thin crust! Wonderful cheesesteaks and fries. The salads are huge and delicious. Absolutely love the wings with sweet hot sauce
… more
Shannon Lucca
Ordered food from here. Usually good. This time is was awful. Pizza was not cut right, meat from the wings was dry. Cheese tasted old. Wrong sauce. Ok maybe a bad night. Spent $40+ on the food. Called to request a refund for the food I had to throw away the owner said no and I was wrong. Don’t get me wrong usually the food is good but the fact that the owner told me to BRING IT BACK and was arguing with me about it instead of just apologizing was enough for me. I explained to him we order from there frequently and I’m not trying to scam him just had a bad order this time he didn’t want to hear it. It’s a shame the customer service is awful for if you have a bad order. I don’t usually complain and would have really just accepted an apology would have been enough I even said this to him and he said “my food is always good” .. we all have bad days. Won’t be ordering again simply because of a simple fix.
… more
Nick Foss
Ordered a pizza for delivery and had a slice missing from it We called to let them know and the girl on the phone could care less about us being upset. Also the fries are just thrown in a paper bag with greasy holes is it. Do not order from here.
… more
dia shorty (shorty)
One of our family go to places. Food always fresh, hot, friendly atmosphere and service, very good selection and all delicious, in sure.
… more
Toni Brown-Miller
A good place to eat. I mostly order Stromboli, not sure what happened to my Buffalo Chicken Stromboli this time
… more
Diego Vazquez
I had a great experience with Amatos Pizza today. The lovely lady taking the order took my order, but when delivered it was wrong. We wanted a unique order with Alfredo sauce, and after speaking to the owner he sent us a new order with no charge. He rectified the situation and was very kind on the phone. Thank you so much for the positive experience. And the food was delicious.
… more
STAR LORD
My Brooklyn pizza was amazing! So we’re the Pepperoni Rolls. Next time I just need it cut lol. Will be coming back SOON.
… more
Christina Marie
This place is on a rapid decline. Service has become worse within the last 2 times we’ve ordered. Fries have been so greasy, they go through the bag, pizza has been like card board. The employees who answer the phone, do not care about customer service. When you try to explain a problem, they say they’re getting the manager, then the same girl gets on the phone and just says that she’s sorry but you can go someplace else. So that is what we’re doing. Social media is king these days as far as word of mouth.
… more
Veronica Brown
I have ordered from Amato’s pizza before but today my pizza was burnt black and I will not be going there again.
… more
… View more