Based on 103 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
419 Great East Neck Rd, West Babylon, NY 11704
Phone: (631) 422-3435
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christian R
They charge for PLATES. PLATES!!! Should I continue? I wish I could leave less than one star, but okay. Pizza is subpar, sauce is terrible. No flavor. Cheap ingredients. Look at the sad photo attached. Woman on the phone had the nerve to say “we charge for utensils because everything’s expensive”. I’m sorry, I didn’t know that was my problem. My pops owned 4 restaurants back in his day. Never heard of that before. Don’t go here. CHUCK E cheese blows this pizza away. Take a look at my receipt. I got 3 pies, service charge, and we tipped the driver 20%… They refused a refund and said we get a $2.00 credit for next time.. You can keep it…
… more
Ralph Fraumeni
Heard a strange thing about this location after also hearing it was not very good. I had heard that it has improved but for some reason they are no longer oiling the pans the Albert’s original square pies are baked in. WHAT! I stopped today and had two slices. The sauce and cheese were as good as I remember. The crust was OK but sorely missed the crispiness that is made by oiling the pans. Why would you want to change such an iconic and delicious pizza recipe? Unless I hear differently, I’ll be patronizing Copaigue only from now on. Sorry.
… more
Paul Cooper
Best pizza on the planet! The people who gave it bad reviews wouldn’t know great pizza if they were beaten over the head with it! Alberts, it’s a Copiague thing!
… more
Ray Williams
So the staff was friendly. That’s a start. But the pizza is very subpar. Not bad if you’re just looking for bread with sauce and cheese. But i’m sorry, if you’re looking for good pizza, then drive another two miles to mulberry street. The location was nothing special either. Please spruce up this place. I want to support local, that’s why i tried you in the first place. Alberts Pizza has potential but is not living up to it currently.
… more
James Alcus
The food is always the best, it’s my favorite pizza on LI, that Albert’s style upside down pie cannot be beat. The store manager was also great, I made an assumption which wound up being incorrect and he replaced it for me without hesitation which was not necessary. Great customer service, thank you
… more
Lloyd Haddigan
This guys pizza is just awful. The thinnest pizza ever and the sauce for the pizza is equally bad. The owner is an indian maniac whos either screaming at his customers or his employees constantly over every little thing. The place gets super busy and the counter girls are pretty good but the pizza is awful.
… more
christofer ferrugiari
Do not order from them they don’t care about you. Move on plenty of other pizza places on the island.
… more
Eric Martin
My girlfriends parents catered from here for Christmas. Everything was pretty bad. Most of the mozzarella sticks had no cheese in then and they were overcooked. The penne alla vodka had no flavor. The chicken parm was barely chicken parm. Also flavorless. No breading on the chicken. If you’re going to let quality of your food drop drastically when catering you shouldn’t cater. Don’t cater from here
… more
Joann Carbone
Ordered a pie which I always get from them and ordered an Italian hero. Called Slice to complain about the hero 1 slice of ham, 1 salami and 1 slice of cheese along with tomato and practically a head of lettuce to make up for the lack of meat. They claim this is how they prepare it. For $9.25 they need to add some meat to it. Needless to say I will no longer order anything from them since they refused to credit me for the hero.
… more
Dominique Raccuglia
They charged us for paper plates for this Chuck E. Cheese style pizza smh
… more
… View more