Mystic Lobster Roll Co the 1st Lobster Roll / Bar Concept in Naples.
All of the lobster is directly from Maine, with the most popular items being the Maine and Connecticut Lobster Rolls. Mystic has a variety of specialty rolls which are a huge hit -one of which is the Surf and Turf Roll which is filet mignon and lobster, served cold or warm with the option of butter or mayo.
There are a few things that really set Mystic Lobster Roll Co apart, one of which are are the large pieces of 100% fresh Maine lobster we put into every roll. Mystic also offers chicken and beef sliders, lobster tacos, lobster mac n cheese, lobster bacon bites, and a variety of soups. Mystic has healthy (salads) and gluten free options as well as a kids menu.
Based on 56 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2355 Vanderbilt Beach Rd Bay #148, Naples, FL 34109
Phone: (239) 631-6553
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday |
11:30 AM–7 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11:30 AM–7 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11:30 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday |
11:30 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday |
11:30 AM–7 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael Bussman
I recently had the pleasure of enjoying another delicious lunch at Mystic Lobster Roll Co, located in the beautiful Vanderbilt Shoppes on Vanderbilt Road. This hidden gem captures the fun and vibrant northeastern style with its charming decor that instantly transports you to the coast of Maine. The interior design is a great mix of cozy and warm, creating a friendly and inviting atmosphere.
… more
Bella
Ew. Possibly one of the worst lobster rolls I’ve had. So small. Lobster (a few sad pieces) was kind of dry despite having butter on it?? How does that happen?? I might be willing to try them again in the future but for now I will definitely be going to Lobster Rolls No.1 or Seed to Table. They never disappoint. (edit: I left this review and was called Mike Bishop by the owner? I’m so confused, now I definitely won’t be back!)
… more
Elaine Z
My husband and I ordered a couple different rolls because they looked so interesting and good and they did not disappoint! The added flavors really took the lobster to the next level. My favorite was the Hawaiian roll. The staff was very helpful and friendly too. Will definitely be back!
… more
Mike Hawk
I went about 2 weeks back and couldn’t be bothered to immediately write a review. There are plenty other places in Naples where you will get more “bang for your buck” in terms of lobster rolls. The atmosphere is lacking. The menu is poorly put together. Even the girl working the front seemed to have a superior attitude. The owner/whoever manages the business account loves to say “We won Best Lobster Roll in Naples.” But in reality, votes can be bought on the back end from friends and family. Definitely NOT the Best Lobster Roll in Naples. Sorry, not sorry.
… more
Richard Troyer
I was excited to try this new place and it did not disappoint! I had to try one of their specialty rolls, The King Louis XIII; fresh lobster, fresh mozzarella, razor thin prosciutto and truffle aioli. Along with it I had lobster bisque . So delicious and I can’t wait to get back to try another!
… more
Alix Furey
Lobster is very dry and tasteless. Does not taste fresh at all. It’s as expensive as other nearby places that do serve fresh tasting lobster. We gave it 3 chances and each experience was bad. Would not waste our money again, rather have pizza. Which is also dry and tasteless until you add the toppings!
… more
Celeste Figueroa
In my experience with lobster, flavor wasn’t good. The price was absurd I paid $64 for a pound of Lobster and for this two things I paid $49 with a bottle of lemonade. I don’t know about you. But I think people are abusing with prices. You decided. For high price I don’t recommend this place. Neither for the flavor.
… more
jackie dilling
I tried “Mystic lobster” for the first time yesterday. I ordered the gf lobster roll and absolutely loved every bite! The sandwich was overflowing with excellent lobster and the gf roll was one of the best I’ve ever had! The accompanying cold slaw and pickle were excellent and complimented the meal nicely! Definitely looking forward to my next visit!!
… more
james lorenzo
Good lobster . I would have given 5 stars till I got the bill .. and they added a $10 charge for using a debt card .. before they even knew I was using one … lol … bring cash. …
… more
Vanessa Carrow
So good! Everything was fresh, and tasted amazing! I ordered the Italian Roll! If I visit Naples again, would likely return
… more
… View more
