Based on 458 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3500 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14226
Phone: (716) 768-2462
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
CJ
If this is how they typically pack their food, I’m surprised they’d get repeat orders. This is THE worst packed food delivery I’ve ever had. Wings and a ton of juice in foil that isn’t even wrapped up. Picture is how it looked when I opened it. The sauce leaked through the box and even through the plastic bag. An absolute mess.
… more
Rohan Kunchakuri
You want tradition? You want a place that makes you sit and wait and force you to have a conversation with one another as your pizza is cooked to perfection? You want a place that makes you feel cozy and not feel stressed about what you have to wear? Gino’s NY Pizza is one of the original pizza places in Buffalo keeping the tradition on what it means to be Italian. This place makes you feel like family. Don’t be afraid to order anything other than pizza because whatever you order will be on point. They offer an awesome range of fresh pizzas, wings and garlic knots and much more. They have amazing combos as well. They have plenty of delicious slice options to choose from. Staff members are always friendly, prices are reasonable and the place is always kept clean. One the best things I like about this place is that the service is super fast. Consistently great pizza with great variety of toppings and styles. I have never had a bad experience with them till now. Would easily give this place 10/10. It’s a fantastic display of classic New York style pizza in its prime. Extremely well executed slices with fine ingredients make this famous pizza destination a must stop.
… more
Matthew Carlacci
Got a Stinger pizza and a taco pizza. Both delicious. Both large slices. Conveniently located. They have a wide selection of pizza by the slice. Small shop to eat at but highly recommended for some traditional and non traditional pizzas
… more
Heather Garvey
Great NO Flop Fold over NY pizza. This is the real deal, great flavor, quality ingredients, and a variety of pizza toppings, calzones, salads, pasta, etc. Gotta try this place. You will not regret it!
… more
Andrea
Unfortunately, I have to edit my initial rating. I ordered a turkey club on 8/11 thru Uber eats and the sub was absolutely terrible. The bread was toasted to a crisp (literally hard) and the bacon (I believe) was old or sat the entire day, very crumbly and greasy. It was a disaster and never should have been served. Very disappointed.
… more
Joella Laramay
Not impressed with the food at all. Got a personal chicken finger pizza and it was undercooked with just cubed chicken and cheese. The blandest buffalo chicken pizza that I’ve ever tasted. I’ve had better from the frozen section at a 7 Eleven.
… more
Christina Danley
Standard somewhat NYStyle pizza. I would recommend this joint to anyone wanting a good standard pizza. We ordered a large extra cheese and boy did they pile on the cheese…it was actually a little too much cheese (is that even possible?) but overall a good pie.
… more
Curt Pasisz
Best NY style pizza I’ve had in Buffalo. Just as good as Joe’s, if not better. Mild wings were very mild, which is just how I like them. The only reason this isn’t five stars is because I didn’t think the antipasto was as good as it could have been. I mean it tasted fine, but I just wasn’t used to the amount of lettuce from other places I get antipasto from. It’s more like a big chef salad. Definitely healthier than other antipasto, just not what I expected. But that’s why I tried it. It had pepperoni in it, and rolled up pieces of lunch meat, but not a lot of it for the price. Usually I can get two large servings out of antipasto. This was finished in one serving. Will definitely be getting the pizza and wing combo again. It’s a few bucks cheaper than Joe’s, too!!
… more
Cara
I ordered a pizza and a calzone at 8:29 pm online, since I couldn’t get anyone to answer the phone after repeated attempts. They said the order would be ready at 8:59. We were there before then and the place was locked up. I tried calling, no answer. I checked my credit card and they charged my card!!!
… more
sue phi
Variety of choices! Plenty of menus on counter at entry point. So many happy customers. So interesting to see the spin time.
… more
… View more