Based on 396 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
613 Calumet St, Chilton, WI 53014
Phone: (920) 849-3043
Social Profile: 
Reviews
Karen Lee
We happened to be in the area and looked for a restaurant. We saw they had a pizza buffet which was very good! It had pizza, cheese bread, chicken, meatballs, mashed potatoes, gravy and salad bar. I forgot to get a photo of the food. I would definitely go here again.
… more
Ally Morris
Service is a bit slow but it’s a buffet so that’s not a big deal. Crust on the pizza tastes frozen, but the chicken is pretty good and the beef stew is very much like my grandmother’s so, of course I love it.
… more
Rob L
The buffet was definitely something we didn’t expect. We asked for menus but we were pushed towards it by our server. We didn’t press back. I guess for our first time, it was a chance to sample everything. It didn’t disappoint. My drink was suspect tho. I don’t think the small bar can handle off the wall recipes like an old fashioned. Our server was friendly and stopped at the table plenty times. The atmosphere was an echo. Maybe some sort of sound absorption is needed. If I lived closer I would definitely frequent the pizza. I recommend this place.
… more
Carl Hanson
We love Papa Don’s, unfortunately, we just found out that they are closing Aug. 14th, 2022. Someone else is taking over with a different food venue. We wish it wasn’t so, the food is great, their salad bar is the best. They have very taste soups, 3 different ones available each day. The broasted chicken is very tender. It is a favorite of ours. We will definitely miss them.
… more
Christine Landis
Great food overall! I’m from Ohio going to the IMSA race, decided to order out salad and pizza. Chef salad was huge and the specialty pizza was awesome. Price was very affordable! Highly recommend!
… more
MANDAH CLARK
Never had a complaint before except now. I called for delivery for a reason.. every other time I placed an order for delivery it wasn’t an issue but all of a sudden it’s an issue and too far of a drive.. really….? Then the person on the phone says we’ll u can pick up… Umm no I said delivery for a reason if I wanted to pick up I would of stayed that. Seriously 5 minutes is too far all of a sudden. Smh. Sorry I was being cautious and not trying to get others sick. Definitely lost my business. Really liked it when Lisa Cullen owned it.
… more
Sarah Gracyalny
Well we are loyal customers here! Tasty buffet and they will make any suggestions within reason! Tasty salad bar and soups as well! Great customer service, a game area too! Closed on Mondays found that out after riding my son and I. This evening the power went out and they didn’t make us pay.
… more
Darlene K
Great roasted chicken buffet, reasonable price as well as regular menu. It is closing in late September! A Mexican restaurant slated to take over. So go now!
… more
Rebecca Bader
Very good buffet. Lots to choose from. Their chicken is one of the best I’ve had. The little garlic cheese bread is amazing. They keep it well stocked, have 3 different soups and a full menu. The wait staff is super friendly.
… more
Kevin Ekvall
The staff are really nice and prompt. The assortment on the buffet is pretty good. Only issue I have is the time you have to sit and wait for new pizzas to come out and they do not have most of the time the normal go to pizzas out. Cheese and cheese and sausage should not have to be asked for. The salad bar is good.
… more
… View more