Muddy Waters Oyster Bar Menu – Pittsburgh, PA

Type : Oyster bar restaurant

Location : Pittsburgh, PA

We are open for take out and now dine-in! We have seating both indoor and out, with all tables being first come, first served. Current dinner hours are Tuesday- Sunday 4:30pm-9pm and Friday- Saturday 4:30pm-10pm. Call us at (412)361-0555 or order right from our website for take out off our regular menu or family style dinner. We are also offering cocktails to go! Order online, by phone, or stop by!!!!

Smooth New Orleans–style bar & eatery serving seafood, Cajun plates & innovative cocktails. Based on 965 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Muddy Waters Oyster Bar 15206

Address:
130 S Highland Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15206

Phone: (412) 361-0555

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 4:30–10 PM
Thursday 4:30–10 PM
Friday 4:30–10 PM
Saturday 4:30–10 PM
Sunday 10:30 AM–3 PM, 4:30–9 PM
Monday Closed
Tuesday 4:30–10 PM

Menu

Family Dinner for 2
Family Meal
Pick 1 item from Starters, 1 item from Main Dish and 2 Sides. Bread: Sweet Potato Corn Bread with Apple Butter, Buttermilk Biscuit. Main Dish: Bucket of Fried Chicken Hot, Bucket of Fried Chicken Not Hot, Jambalaya with Chicken and Shrimp, 2 Poboys Both with Fried Oysters, 2 Poboys Both with Fried Shrimp, Seafood Gumbo, Gator and Sausage Gumbo, 2 Poboys (1 with Shrimp 1 with Oysters). Side (2): Cheddar Grits, Collard Greens, Cajun Fries , Wedge Salad, Kale Caesar
$40.00
Sandwich Shop
Alligator Po Boy
Blackened gator, fried green tomato, collard greens slaw, pimento cheese.
$18.00
Louisiana Lobster Roll
Maine lobster & crawfish, garlic butter, lemon, split top roll.
$24.20
Da Lil Chunky Burger
Two patties, fried green tomato, American, Benton’s bacon, sunny side up egg, chili mayo, iceberg, house dill pickles. Choose Burger Cooking Style: Pink, No Pink
$15.40
Classic Po Boy
Choice of fried shrimp or oysters, iceberg, tomato, house dill pickles, chili mayo. Choose Protein: Fried Shrimp, Fried Oyster, Fried Shrimp & Oyster +$2
$17.60
Cajun Style Rueben
Cajun seasoned corned beef, marble rye bread, swiss cheese, collard green sauerkraut, remoulade, house dll pickles
$15.00
Bar Snakes & Small Plates
Sweet Potato Corn Bread
Weather bury Farm Cornmeal, Housemade Local Apple Butter, Hot Honey
$9.00
Catfish Sticks
Abita purple haze beer batter, remoulade.
$8.80
Mac & Cheese
Peppadew, buttered bread crumbs.
$9.90
Hush Puppies
Corn, scallions, dill, remoulade.
$8.80
Fried Green Tomatoes
Pimento cheese, collard greens slaw.
$11.00
Kale Caeser
Collard greens, kale, pickled cranberries, whiskey caeser dressing, herb croutons
$12.00
Gator & Sausage Gumbo
Dark roux, okra, Carolina gold rice.
$9.90
Fried Alligator
Chipotle aioli.
$13.20
Iceberg Wedge
Smoked bleu, bacon, egg, radish, pickled green tomato, buttermilk ranch.
$8.80
Chargrilled Oysters
Garlic butter, parmesan, chili flakes.
$14.30
Fried Brussel Sprouts
Bourbon Glazed, Mustard Aioli
$8.00
Smoked Boudin
Assorted Pickled Items, Creole Mustard Aioli, Cajun Dill Potato Chips
$10.00
Foie Gras Deviled Eggs
Bacon Jam, Smoked Trout Roe, Micro Greens
$11.00
Large Plates
Seafood Gumbo
Gulf shrimp, crawfish, oysters, catfish, andouille, okra, Carolina gold rice.
$26.40
Jambalaya
Chicken, andouille, shrimp, Carolina gold rice, creole tomato broth.
$27.50
Nashville Style Hot Chicken
Anson Mills cheddar grits, Benton’s braised creamed collards, house sweet pickles.
$28.60
Pan Crusted Salmon
Pecan Crusted Salmon, sweet potato puree, braised radicchio, maple balsamic reduction, fennel-pear salad
$25.00
Steak Frites
14 oz New York strip, mushroom bourbon Au Poivre, truffle parmesan fries.
$35.20
Creole Shrimp & Grits
Gulf shrimp, Anson Mills cheddar grits, trinity, tasso ham, shrimp stock, heirloom tomato.
$28.60
Brunch
Bananas Foster French Toast
Maple Bourbn Syrup, Vanilla Whipped Cream, Benton’s Bacon, Candied Peacans
$14.00
Fried Chicken And Biscuits
Sunny Side Up Egg, Country Sausage Gravy, House Pickles
$17.00
Brunch Shrimp Po Boy
Fried Shrimp, Bacon, Egg, Iceberg, Tomato, Pickle, Chili Mayo
$19.50
Brunch Oyster Po Boy
Fried Oysters, Bacon, Egg, Iceberg, Tomato, Pickle, Chili Mayo
$19.50
Country Breakfast
Two Eggs Your Way, Nora Mills Chedder Grits, Choice of Benton’s Bacon, Ham Steak, Andouille Sausage, or Boudin Link, White Toast or Biscuit, Fresh Fruit. Protein: Bacon, Ham, Andouille, Boudin. Eggs: Scrambled, Sunny Side Up, Over Easy, Over Medium, Over Hard, Poached, Egg Whites Only
$15.00
Steak Frites And Eggs
14oz New York Strip, Mushroom Bourbon au Poivre, Truffle Parmesean Fries, Two Eggs Your Way. Eggs: Scrambled, Sunny Side Up, Over Easy, Over Medium, Over Hard, Poached, Egg Whites Only
$37.00
Seafood Gumbo
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp, Crawfish, Catfish, Oysters, Andouille Sausage, Okra, Carolina Gold Rice
$26.00
Birds Nest
Nora Mills Cheddar Grits, Pork Braised Greens, Boudin, Two Poached Eggs, Crispy Potatoes
$19.00
Corned Beef Hash
Potato Hash, Pepper, Onion, Pulled Corned Beef, Two Poached Eggs, Hollandaise
$17.00
Ham Steak And Red Eye Gravy
Two Sunny Side Up Eggs, Biscuit, Nora Mills Cheddar Grits
$16.00
Lobster Eggs Benedict
Biscuit, Poached Eggs, Benton’s Country Ham, Crawfish Hollandaise
$24.00
Creole Shrimp And Grits
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp, Nora Mills Chedder Grits, Two Poached Eggs, Trinity, Tasso Ham, Shrimp Stock, Heirloom Tomato
$28.00
Da Lil Chunky Burger
Two Patties, Fried Green Tomato, American, Benton’s Bacon, Sunny Side Up Egg, Chili Mayo, Iceberg, Pickle. Choose Burger Cooking Style: Pink, No pink
$16.00
Louisiana Lobster Roll
Maine Lobster & Crawfish, Garlic Butter, Lemon, Split Top Roll
$24.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Marcin Krieger
Hands down the shrimp and grits was the best dish among a group of absolutely amazing dishes. The coffee is strong, and made with chicory. This is a place that will require multiple trips to try everything, and/or a larger group who is willing to share. The atmosphere is relaxed, and the Blues tracks roll on.

… more

Ulyana K
Great food, decent serving sizes, and okay prices. I want to come back to try the oysters, but I just got a few basic items from this place for a dinner. I tried the hush puppies with remoulade and the beignets with chocolate sauce.

… more

Umi
This was my second time visiting this restaurant and it was a very nice night. The drinks, food and atmosphere was great. My family from Hawaii was in town and they really enjoyed themselves. I went with the chargrilled oysters my first visit. I tried the shrimp and grits this visit and it was the best shrimp and grits I’ve ever had. This will be my new date night spot or where I take my family to eat.

… more

Neashia Johnson
My friends have recommended them for their oysters, so I thought all their seafood would be good. Mid. I might have been spoiled by a recent trip to Baltimore, but you can still taste the freezer burn in their Maine lobster roll. Server was nice, but inattentive. My happy hour drink was fairly strong and made up for the disappointment. I left, still hungry and I’m 100 lbs. I’m literally thinking of other places to go right now to fill the gap… Go somewhere else for a lobster roll.

… more

Kenesha Travis
This is a hidden gem. My husband and I came here for dinner on a Sunday.

… more

Sandra Bertoty
Service was very good. Staff is knowledgeable for first timers with questions. The food was nothing short of amazing. The sandwiches we had were stuffed with meat and they were very good. The oysters were very good. We had the cooked oysters and raw oysters and both were done exceptional. The restaurant is not very large, so they fill up quickly and you could potentially have to wait. But its worth it.

… more

RJ
Cute and cozy place, perfect for a date night. First visit here and liked the vibe. I liked the Chargrilled Oysters and the Jambalaya. The Maryland Crab Dip was the best dish out of the ones we tried. Not authentic NOLA or Cajun food but still good enough, with a modern twist. Only disappointed with the beignets, absolutely no flavor in them. The service, the staff and the ambiance was great. Would definitely visit again to try different seafood items on the menu.

… more

Christin Sciulli
Absolutely fantastic drinks and food. While the fresh oysters are what bring folks in, the chargrilled oysters are even better! Lobster eggs Benedict was amazing, as were the bloody Marys.

… more

Matthew Butch
Have visited here several times for cocktails and eats. Sometimes together, sometimes just for drinks. Always a good experience. Dishes are excellent and the wait staff is always on point. Jazz night is a bonus.

… more

Corey Amaya
Great selection of oysters and other food, service was great as was the overall vibe.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions