Your Shelbyville, IN Casey’s at 1806 N Riley Hwy has the best pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We’ve also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you’re stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels – Whatever you need, Casey’s is here to help.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 61 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 2.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
1806 N Riley Hwy, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Phone: (317) 398-7814
Website:
Hours
Sunday |
Open 24 hours |
Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Open 24 hours
Hours might differ
|
Tuesday |
Open 24 hours |
Wednesday |
Open 24 hours |
Thursday |
Open 24 hours |
Friday |
Open 24 hours |
Saturday |
Open 24 hours |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brittany Schumate
Attempted to order our family favorite taco pizza twice. Last night and today. The kid making them last night said he didn’t want to unthaw the sauce so not only did he not make it he didn’t even bother letting us know before pick up that it wasn’t going to be made. He was more concerned with socializing in the front couldn’t be bothered with orders.
… more
Damon Archer
Everytime I pass a Casey’s i have to stop and get a slice of pizza. I picked up 3 slices this time cause I was headed to my mechanic. I asked him if he was hungry and he so no I just ate. I said ok I have 2 extra slices of Casey’s pizza. Lol he said I can’t say no to Casey’s
… more
Mary Beth Paxton
We always look forward to a taco pizza when traveling through from Tennessee. This was by far the worst taco pizza we’ve ever had. We placed the order online and it said it’d be 25 mins. We showed up on time and they hadn’t even started our order, we waited an additional40 mins. There was 4 people back in the kitchen!! One other customer picked up some pizzas. They put the smallest handful of chips on the pizza and then whole tomato slices ♀️. Nobody seemed to know what they were doing.
… more
Kelly Smith
Bathroom had toilet paper on floor. Big drink cooler is the coldest. I love cold drinks.
… more
Jeffrey Baird
We’re truck drivers and have been to 30+ Casey’s throughout the Midwest.After seeing the bad reviews I have not seen any of these issues they were complaining about.
… more
Zane Petersen
C’mon guys! 6 pumps, all with empty windshield wash buckets. One even had a box and garbage shoved in it showing these had not been maintained for some time.
… more
Sierra Waskosky
We stopped there to get something to drink and gas and we get to the register the first time and I was paying for gas I gave him $51 and asked if I wanted my receipt but not my change .28 cents, so we walked away and I was like apparently we don’t ask people if they want their change. So I was filling the gas well it looks like I had to go back in to get my change because it didn’t take it all. so I went back in and asked for my change well you know he hands me $4.15 suppose to be $4.45.. tells me he don’t have the change his manager is going to the bank .. so another 35 cents short.. so there’s 55 cents . SHOULDNT YOU TELL PEOPLE THAT BEFORE
… more
Carl S
I see lots of negative reviews here, but I enjoy their coffee and donuts. It is unfortunate that only one young woman appeared to be working there this morning – if they’re having to stay at the cash register, they’re not able to do other things (like clean restrooms, empty trash bins). I don’t pretend to understand current staffing issues across service businesses, but do appreciate them being there.
… more
Ryan Coons
Caseys pizza is usually really good, but they put WAY too much cheese on the pizza at this location. The truck parking lot and fuel island is very poorly designed. Expect to be stuck here a while if you get parked in, because the trucks pile up pretty fast
… more
Dana Hodgin
I love Casey’s pizza. It is sad someone put pictures up of the bathroom in one of the comments below.The bathroom looks trashed because of customers throwing toilet paper everywhere and someone didn’t flush the toilet? Really?? I’ve seen way worse situations then this! I’m sure they are short staffed like everyone else. Zeez use your own bathroom and you won’t have to worry about it.
… more
… View more