Based on 401 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
6225 W 56th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: (317) 552-2141
Website: https://www.ordermanhattanpizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alicia Zabloudil
Two out of the three pizza slices we got were delicious! The third was a little over cooked and dry but not bad. The service was friendly, quick and efficient! The atmosphere has beautiful wall decorations, wood tables and is clean. However, for us, it was a little to quiet. Loved watching the pizzas being made!
… more
J Rock
I’ve traveled the world and had pizza everywhere. I even been to New Jersey and New York and had many options for pizza..this pizza was creative with slices so I tried 3. The worst was the chicken, second pepperoni..the best one was a white slice and I give it 7 out of 10. The bottom crust was little too thin.
… more
Jozef Watson
Excellent pizza, crispy crust on the bottom with great flavor of toppings. Service was fast and friendly and store looked clean and well lit. Garlic knots were good but I don’t know that I would say they are can’t miss, worth trying if you want a side. Would recommend this for your pizza craving.
… more
Leonard Caponegro
This visit was even better than the first because we ate at Manhattan Pizzeria as opposed to eating it at home. What a crispy crust on the outside, and soft and chewy on the inside. Impressive how this tasty crust held up very well to the toppings. A true version of NY Style Thin Crust Pizza. Each pizza had the right amount of sauce, cheese and toppings. The tomato dipping sauce was garlicky, and one can easily, at least I can, get addicted to it. We enjoyed the Cheese, Pepperoni, Buffalo Chicken, Margherita, White and Meat Lover Rollover Pizza slices. Each was delicious, flavorful and could easily be folded in half (as they do in NY). We also ordered and enjoyed the Pepperoni Roll and Garlic Breadsticks. I also has a nice conversation with the owner and found out he is from Long Island. He’s perfected the craft of creating the perfect NY Style Thin Crust Pizza and it shows. The inside looks exactly like the pizzeria I am used to visiting in NJ and NY. Manhattan Pizzeria is the best NY Style Pizzeria in Indianapolis.
… more
Armon
My dad & I always come to Manhattan when we are in the area and they have never disappointed! Authentic NY Style Pizza slices that are large, not super greasy and full of flavor! They also have a large menu that offers Pizza, Pasta, Sides, Subs, Wings, Desserts & Soda/Water!
… more
Keith Holston
Being from New Jersey I’ve been longing for authentic, or close to authentic New Jersey, New York Pizza. Manhattan Pizzeria has fulfilled my void. Very down-to-earth atmosphere and never crowded.
… more
ernesto vazquez
AMAZING! First time trying food from here and it won’t be out last. We enjoyed the pizza here it was amazing. It had so many flavors in one bite. I recommend trying the barbecue chicken pizza it was also very delicious. Not only did it taste good, the size of the pizza is also very big. A family of 8 and in other places we usually buy more boxes and waste more money, yet here with 2 boxes it was enough for us all. This place is a 10/10 and I can’t wait to come back and try something different!
… more
Rachelle Kennedy
They have authentic New York style pizza. It is constantly good every time. I also love the garlic knots. The staff is friendly.
… more
Bradley Sneed
Amazing New York style pizza! The crust is absolutely perfect. While I haven’t tried every flavor, the supreme is top shelf and their Margherita style is outstanding. Any chance I get for pizza, they’re my first call.
… more
I Cash
Pizza made by master’s of their craft. I’ve loved every slice of pizza and everything else I’ve tried since their opening. Authentic pizza by the slice and you are still able to add extra toppings. One of the few places that has all beef meatballs as a topping.
… more
… View more