Muscarella’s Pizza- Main St. Williamsville Menu – Williamsville, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Williamsville, NY

Based on 159 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Muscarella's Pizza- Main St. Williamsville 14221

Address:
5526 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221

Phone: (716) 204-9020

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 3–8:45 PM
Wednesday 3–8:45 PM
Thursday 3–8:45 PM
Friday 11 AM–9:45 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9:45 PM
Sunday 11 AM–8:45 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

Picked for You
Chicken Wings
Comes with bleu cheese dressings & carrots. 10 pieces comes with 2 blue cheese, 20 pieces with 3 blue cheese, 30 pieces with 3 blue cheese, 50 pieces with 4 blue cheese dressing.
$19.54
Chicken Fingers
Served with honey dip sauce, includes French fries, bleu cheese, and carrots.
$16.68
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza
$14.94
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza
$8.04
Specialty Pizza
Chicken Finger Pizza
Bleu cheese, mild, medium, BBQ or hot sauce, chicken fingers, mozzarella, and cheddar. (Lettuce & tomato optional).
$13.79
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza
White sauce, mozzarella, Cheddar, and broccoli florets.
$11.49
Steak Pizza
Made either red (with sauce) or white (with oil, pepper & garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot or sweet peppers.
$13.79
Sicilian Pizza
Made with 100% olive oil, fresh tomatoes, onions, Asiago cheese & spices. Anchovies on request.
$11.49
The Works Pizza
Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.
$13.79
The Hawaiian Pizza
Includes cheese, ham & pineapple.
$11.49
The Romano Pizza
Includes Romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.
$12.64
The Hog Pizza
Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage and ham. Choice of personal, small, large, sheet extra large, or colossal.
$13.79
Salads
Antipasto Salad
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, capicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives, green olives, mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni.
$10.34
Julienne Salad
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, turkey, ham & provolone cheese.
$8.04
Tuna Salad
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.
$8.04
Grilled Chicken Salad
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone.
$11.49
Steak Salad
Includes lettuce, tomato, fried onions, mushrooms & cheddar.
$11.49
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing, and grated cheese.
$8.04
Grilled Steak Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing topped with grilled chicken.
$13.79
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing topped with grilled chicken.
$13.79
Chefs Salad
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.
$5.74
Chicken Finger Salad
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & cheddar.
$13.79
Side Orders
Frankie Fries
Bbq dip included. Grilled steak (chopped sirloin) cheddar, and french fries.
$9.19
French Fries
Our delicious French fries are deep-fried ’till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!
$5.74
BBQ French Fries
Includes bleu cheese. BBQ sauced then blackened in oven.
$6.89
Loaded Fries
Includes bacon and cheddar cheese .
$8.04
Sweet Potato Fries With Honey
Sweet potatoes, creamed honey, butter, cinnamon.
$6.89
Waffle Fries $6.89
Onion Rings
Crispy onion slices deep-fried until golden-brown.
$6.89
Fried Cauliflower
Includes bleu cheese.
$7.48
Fried Mushrooms
Includes bleu cheese.
$7.48
Fried Zucchini
Includes marinara sauce.
$7.48
Jalapeno Poppers
Includes bleu cheese.
$6.89
Fried Dough Sticks
A long golden-brown deep-fried strip of dough.
$7.48
Loaded Garlic Bread
Spinach, onions, tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
$5.74
Mozzarella Sticks
Includes marinara sauce.
$8.04
Loaded Waffle French Fries
Steak seasoning, bacon bits, cheddar cheese, waffle cut.
$7.99
Pizza Logs
Includes marinara sauce.
$12.64
Cajun Onion Rings
BBQ sauced then spiced with our cajun rub then blackened in oven
$8.04
Cajun French Fries
BBQ sauced then spiced with our cajun rub then blackened in oven.
$7.48
Garlic Bread With Cheese
A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack.
$4.59
Garlic Bread With Cheese & Tomato
A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack.
$5.16
Breadsticks
Comes with marinara sauce.
$5.16
Breadsticks With Cheese
Comes with marinara sauce.
$7.49
Tator Tots
Comes with ketchup
$6.89
Loaded Tator Tots
Comes with ranch
$9.19
Fish Fry
Only during Lent.
12oz beer battered haddock, french fries, garlic bread and coleslaw
$16.99
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings
Comes with bleu cheese dressings & carrots. 10 pieces comes with 2 blue cheese, 20 pieces with 3 blue cheese, 30 pieces with 3 blue cheese, 50 pieces with 4 blue cheese dressing.
$19.54
Boneless Wings
Comes with bleu cheese dressings & carrots. 10 pieces comes with 2 blue cheese, 20 pieces with 3 blue cheese, 30 pieces with 3 blue cheese, 50 pieces with 4 blue cheese dressing.
$13.79
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers
Served with honey dip sauce, includes French fries, bleu cheese, and carrots.
$16.68
Calzones
Create Your Own Calzone
Includes cheese.
$11.44
Sandwiches
Hamburger Sandwich
The flavors of your favorite burger, in a sandwich.
$4.99
Cheeseburger Sandwich
The flavors of your favorite cheeseburger, in a sandwich.
$5.99
Bacon Cheeseburger Sandwich
The flavors of your favorite bacon cheeseburger in a sandwich.
$6.99
The Super Shroom Sandwich
Includes hamburger, fried onions, fried mushrooms, melted Swiss cheese.
$6.99
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Italian sausage, sauce, olive oil, green peppers, onions, shredded Italian cheese, spices.
$4.99
Italian Stalion Sandwich
Includes Italian sausage patty, fried onions & sweet peppers with melted provolone cheese.
$6.99
Submarines
Assorted Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$8.04
BLT Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$8.04
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$10.34
Capicola Bison Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$6.89
Cheese Baked Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$4.59
Cheeseburger Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$9.19
Chicken Cordon Blue Sub
Sahlen ham, chicken fingers and swiss cheese. Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.
$11.49
Chicken Finger Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$10.34
Grilled Chicken Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$8.04
Grilled Chicken Supreme Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, onions. peppers and cheese. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$9.19
Ham Sahlens Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$6.89
Hamburger Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$8.04
Italian Sausage Patty Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$9.19
Muscarella Melt Sub
Melted cheddar, bbq chicken fingers, bacon, blue cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes. Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.
$11.49
Pizza Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$5.74
Royal Sub
Sausage and cappicola. Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$10.34
Salami Hard Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$6.89
Steak Supreme Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$10.34
Steak & Sausage Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$11.49
Stinger Sub
Lettuce and tomatoes on request. Includes chopped sirloin steak, chicken fingers, choice of flavor, and bacon. Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$12.64
Tuna Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$5.74
Turkey Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$6.89
Turkey Bacon Club Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$8.04
Vegetarian Sub
Includes black olives, green olives, hot peppers, and cheese on request. Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$4.59
Vincenzo Special Sub
Assorted cold cuts and Italian sausage. Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$10.34
Sicilian Pizza Sub
Include lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Onions on request. Choice of white or Wheat Costanzo rolls.
$4.59
Parm Subs
Steak Parm Sub
With sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$9.19
Eggplant Parm Sub
With sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$8.04
Meatball Parm Sub
With sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$8.04
Italian Sausage Parm Sub
With sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$9.19
Chicken Finger Parm Sub
With sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$10.34
Wraps
Grilled Steak Caesar Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$8.61
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$8.04
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$8.61
Supreme Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$8.61
Chicken Finger Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$8.04
Turkey Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$6.89
Assorted Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$7.46
Tuna Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$6.89
Vegetarian Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$5.74
Steak Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$8.04
Ham Wrap
Includes lettuce, tomato, cheese, and onions on request. Choice of condiments.
$6.89
Beverages
Soda
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.
$2.88
Water $2.88

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Lo Rzoska
This is legit the best pizza I’ve ever had. The cup pepperoni was cooked perfectly. The garlic crust on the pizza is AMAZING. Honey mustard & Italian wings are also excellent. All the food got delivered still hot. I’ll definitely be back.

… more

Lindsay D’Arcy
Found this in our pizza today, and the manager insisted we put it in there because they only have blue bandaid in their store. Refunded our money but stated it was just because we wanted free pizza. Terrible customer service and this is beyond disgusting. The owner just called me back to argue because he’s mad I put a bad review on Facebook. Sorry, getting my money back for this pizza is just not enough, who knows what’s on that bandaid. I understand mistakes happen, but if there was better customer service I never would have badly rated this company.This was the lancaster location. For the record, you can look back on my Google reviews, never have I ever given a bad review….I didn’t lie just to get your 20 dollar pizza for free.

… more

Louise Miller
First time trying this place…. and so happy I did!! The pizza was full of toppings and the wings were still crispy after the drive home(40+ minutes). Definitely a place I will order from again. Thank you for a wonderful experience.

… more

keeysha armstrong
Ordered via UberEATS. I love their broccoli and cheese pizza at least this time it wasn’t burned and dried out. But my turkey sub; again dry as a board and the kicker I ordered a whole sub and was only sent a half I think I’ll revisit lanova on the west side going forward for the broc and cheddar pie and nix ordering anything other than pizza UPON PICKUP. SEEMS YOU HAVE TO INSPECT YOUR FOOD PRIOR TO LEAVING

… more

Walterssrq
We are from out of town and heard we need to try cup and char pepperoni pizza. We found Muscarella’s was closest and boy were we happy. This is the best pizza we have ever had in our lives. Please know that it is worth every penny and adding the garlic Parmasan crust was AMAZING! Thoroughly impressed and sad that we can’t get this where we come from. Muscarella’s is the BOMB!!

… more

Sean L
Ordered a chicken finger pizza, looked very old and reheated, chicken fingers were mostly over cooked breadcrumbs, very bland all around. Would never recommend this place, absolute joke for buffalo pizza.

… more

Drew Derek
Great pizza!!!!!!! Always hits the spot. Never a bad pie!

… more

Kevin Dehn
Amazing pizza. Friendly staff. Great prices, convenient location. Thanks again see you soon

… more

Scott Zak
This is by far the best pizza in Buffalo. Always perfectly consistent week to week. Cup and char pepperoni cooked perfectly. By far the best crust on a pizza I have ever tasted. Don’t sleep on this place, you will not find a better pizza in WNY

… more

Dylan Gefert
Absolutely awesome! Sauce and dough were amazing and the wings were nice and crispy! Worth the price!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions