Long-standing family-owned pizzeria serving New York-style pies, pastas & subs, with delivery too. Based on 491 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1090 Montgomery Rd, Altamonte Springs, FL 32714
Phone: (407) 774-4300
Website: https://www.papajoesfl.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Celindabeth Frumento
I visited yesterday and had Gnocchi. It was one of the best Gnoccis I tried.
… more
Benjamin Fordham
Ordered two medium pizzas. The pepperoni one must have been out to sell a slices (for who knows how long) and they just threw some more cheese on it and melted it. Not fresh tasting at all.
… more
Justin James
Real Italian thin crust pizza with a delicious crispy yet fluffy crust… all around very good pizza…. WE WILL RETURN AGAIN SOON…. TY TY TY
… more
Edgar Maisonave Jr
First visit for my wife and I, so naturally, we had to try out their pizza
… more
Jessica Elyea
This is the best pizza/Italian food in Central Florida, possibly the whole state. Not only is the pizza amazing, but so is everything else on the menu. The shrimp always taste so fresh. Dining is definitely the best way to experience the food however, we do get a lot of Togo and it’s still great. Ive called them without notice to feed a family of 40, Togo, on a weekend evening, and they came through. I have family that flys in from North Carolina and this is the first restaurant they want to eat at. Popa Joe has good vino available, get a couple bottles and it’s a fantastic dinner. Love these guys!
… more
Bryanna byes
First time to this location. It was a great atmosphere, fast and friendly service from our waiter Antwon. Antwon was on point from the moment we sat down. He was always a step ahead of what we needed wether it was refills or more napkins. The food was delicious!!!
… more
Kandy Cruz
Shout out to Ms. KIM and the COOKS! For such an amazing service and Delicious, Authentic Food!!!! Ms.Kim was such a pleasure! Funny lady! Her recommendations were on point! Authentic NY style pizza! Ms. Kim had us try their Calamari! OMG! So delicious. Airy crisp, lightly breaded! No fishy scent. And that Marinara sauce!!! Wow! Very refreshing.. not acidic! Thanks Ms. KIM! GREAT COOKS! Thanks guys! Hands down will be a favorite local spot!
… more
Ian H
Great Italian American restaurant. The pizza was delicious and the eggplant parmigiana was exquisite! Friendly service. 5/5!
… more
Bernard Ryan
This is an authentic Italian restaurant with the best shopping places near by and they also serve alcohol. Get the best Stromboli or Super sub (Italian) in Altamonte on the way to the springs or beach.
… more
Danielle Frassetti
A hidden gem!! I am an Italian from New York and my husband grew up around the corner from Papa Joe’s. The first time I visited my in-laws in Florida, my husband suggested we order pizza for dinner- I looked at him like he was crazy…. But this place is incredible! Now every time we visit I insist on ordering from Papa Joe’s. Everything is authentic and delicious, from the pizza to the chicken parm, especially the garlic roll knots! My ultimate favorite, which is why I am writing this review is Papa Joe’s antipasto salad…. I find myself craving it all the time! Delicious! Aside from the tasty food, the people who work there are friendly and welcoming; the restaurant is clean and has a really warm familiar hometown pizzeria ambiance.
… more
… View more