Little Sicily Pizza Menu – Surprise, AZ

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Surprise, AZ

Lively BYOB serves thin-crust pies, wings & other eats in a cozy space decorated with memorabilia. Based on 561 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Little Sicily Pizza 85374

Address:
18795 N Reems Rd, Surprise, AZ 85374

Phone: (623) 537-5900

Website:

Hours

Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM

Menu

Appetizers, Salads, & More
House Salad & Breadsticks
Lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, and peperoncini
$13.29
Small House Salad
Add Breadsticks (2) for an additional charge.
$3.39
Chicken Caesar Salad $17.19
Italian Antipasto Salad (Small)
Serves 2-3. salami, provolone, capicola, ham, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, pepperoncini and breadsticks.
$15.99
Italian Antipasto Salad (Large)
Serves 4-5. salami, provolone, capicolla, ham, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, onion, black olives, peperoncini and breadsticks.
$21.79
Homemade Breadsticks (6) $5.19
Fried Mushrooms (10) $8.69
Fried Ravioli (10) $10.09
Garlic Bread $4.39
Garlic Bread With Cheese $4.89
Pizza Bread $4.59
Cheese Sticks (6) $9.79
Onion Rings (8) $6.89
French Fries $3.79
Fried Zucchini (8) $8.39
Chicken Fingers (5) & Fries $13.79
Appetizer Special $14.39
Sandwiches
Combo – Beef & Sausage Sandwich $16.09
Italian Beef Sandwich $13.29
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich With Melted Cheese $13.29
Italian Meatball (3) Sandwich With Melted Cheese $13.29
Italian Sausage Sandwich $13.29
Philly Steak Sandwich
Green pepper, onion, mushroom, and cheese.
$16.09
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich With Melted Cheese $14.89
Veal Parmigiana Sandwich (Patty) $14.89
Italian Sub
Capicolla, ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, Italian dressing.
$14.89
Italian Dinners
Spaghetti Dinner $13.19
Ziti Dinner $15.19
Rigatoni Dinner $15.19
Baked Rigatoni Dinner $15.19
Baked Manicotti Dinner $15.49
Baked Ziti Dinner $15.19
Lasagna With Meat Dinner $16.69
Stuffed Shells Dinner $16.69
Ravioli Dinner
Meat, Cheese, or Mixed
$16.29
Spinach Ravioli Dinner $16.29
Linguine Aglio Dinner $15.19
Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner $16.29
Chicken Parmigiana Dinner $16.29
Veal Parmigiana Dinner $16.69
Stuffed Peppers Dinner $16.69
Jumbo Shrimp Dinner $16.69
Jumbo Chicken Wings
Jumbo Wings (6 Pcs) With Ranch Dressing & Celery $9.19
Jumbo Wings (12 Pcs) With Ranch Dressing & Celery $16.09
Jumbo Wings (24 Pcs) With Ranch Dressing & Celery $28.69
Jumbo Wings (50 Pcs) With Ranch Dressing & Celery $53.99
Calzones
Calzone With Cheese $13.59
Little Sicily Pizza
Little Sicily Pizza (12 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, bell pepper.
$24.89
Little Sicily Pizza (14 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, bell pepper.
$29.49
Little Sicily Pizza (16 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, bell pepper.
$35.49
Little Sicily Pizza (18 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, bell pepper.
$38.89
Veggie Pizza
Veggie Pizza (12 Inch)
Mushroom, onion, bell pepper, black olives, fresh tomato.
$25.29
Veggie Pizza (14 Inch)
Mushroom, onion, bell pepper, black olives, fresh tomato.
$29.89
Veggie Pizza (16 Inch)
Mushroom, onion, bell pepper, black olives, fresh tomato.
$34.79
Veggie Pizza (18 Inch)
Mushroom, onion, bell pepper, black olives, fresh tomato.
$39.09
Meat Lovers Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza (12 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, meatballs, Italian beef.
$27.59
Meat Lovers Pizza (14 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, meatballs, Italian beef.
$30.49
Meat Lovers Pizza (16 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, meatballs, Italian beef.
$36.79
Meat Lovers Pizza (18 Inch)
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, meatballs, Italian beef.
$42.49
Garlic White Pizza
Garlic White Pizza (12 Inch)
Garlic butter, ricotta, fresh tomato, spinach, fresh garlic.
$26.39
Garlic White Pizza (14 Inch)
Garlic butter, ricotta, fresh tomato, spinach, fresh garlic.
$30.99
Garlic White Pizza (16 Inch)
Garlic butter, ricotta, fresh tomato, spinach, fresh garlic.
$35.59
Garlic White Pizza (18 Inch)
Garlic butter, ricotta, fresh tomato, spinach, fresh garlic.
$38.59
Chicago Style Thin Pizza
Chicago Style Cheese Pizza (12 Inch) $16.39
Chicago Style Cheese Pizza (14 Inch) $18.89
Chicago Style Cheese Pizza (16 Inch) $23.59
Chicago Style Cheese Pizza (18 Inch) $25.89
Chicago Style Pizza With One Topping (12 Inch) $17.89
Chicago Style Pizza With One Topping (14 Inch) $21.19
Chicago Style Pizza With One Topping (16 Inch) $25.59
Chicago Style Pizza With One Topping (18 Inch) $29.19
Chicago Style Pizza With Two Toppings (12 Inch) $20.29
Chicago Style Pizza With Two Toppings (14 Inch) $23.49
Chicago Style Pizza With Two Toppings (16 Inch) $28.49
Chicago Style Pizza With Two Toppings (18 Inch) $32.09
Chicago Style Pizza With Three Toppings (12 Inch) $21.39
Chicago Style Pizza With Three Toppings (14 Inch) $25.79
Chicago Style Pizza With Three Toppings (16 Inch) $30.49
Chicago Style Pizza With Three Toppings (18 Inch) $34.39
Chicago Style Pizza With Four Toppings (12 Inch) $23.69
Chicago Style Pizza With Four Toppings (14 Inch) $28.09
Chicago Style Pizza With Four Toppings (16 Inch) $33.09
Chicago Style Pizza With Four Toppings (18 Inch) $36.69
Chicago Pan Pizza
Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza (12 Inch) $22.79
Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza (14 Inch) $25.99
Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza (16 Inch) $30.19
Chicago Pan Pizza With One Topping (12 Inch) $25.09
Chicago Pan Pizza With One Topping (14 Inch) $27.79
Chicago Pan Pizza With One Topping (16 Inch) $32.49
Chicago Pan Pizza With Two Toppings (12 Inch) $27.09
Chicago Pan Pizza With Two Toppings (14 Inch) $30.09
Chicago Pan Pizza With Two Toppings (16 Inch) $34.79
Chicago Pan Pizza With Three Toppings (12 Inch) $29.39
Chicago Pan Pizza With Three Toppings (14 Inch) $32.49
Chicago Pan Pizza With Three Toppings (16 Inch) $37.39
Chicago Pan Pizza With Four Toppings (12 Inch) $31.09
Chicago Pan Pizza With Four Toppings (14 Inch) $35.09
Chicago Pan Pizza With Four Toppings (16 Inch) $39.99
Chicago Stuffed Pizza
Chicago Stuffed Cheese Pizza (12 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$23.89
Chicago Stuffed Cheese Pizza (14 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$27.89
Chicago Stuffed Cheese Pizza (16 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$32.49
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With One Topping (12 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$25.89
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With One Topping (14 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$30.19
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With One Topping (16 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$35.09
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Two Toppings (12 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$28.19
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Two Toppings (14 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$32.49
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Two Toppings (16 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$38.49
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Three Toppings (12 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$31.69
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Three Toppings (14 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$35.09
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Three Toppings (16 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$42.29
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Four Toppings (12 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$33.99
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Four Toppings (14 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$37.39
Chicago Stuffed Pizza With Four Toppings (16 Inch)
Takes at least 1 hour to cook. Delivery time will be longer than usual.
$45.79
Desserts
Tiramisu $6.99
Homemade Cannoli $6.99
Bottled Water $2.89

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

William Meola
First time going here. We had fried mushrooms, which were very good and not to greasy. Medium wing. The wings were so good! Flavor was awesome with the right amount of heat. I got the Chicago deep dish pizza with mushrooms. It was good. The dough was awesome. I personally not a fan of sweet tomatoe sauce, but it was still good. My wife had the chicken parmesan. It was very good. Sauce for that was not as sweet and the chicken was great. Nice and tender. The best part was the owner, George. When he had a minute to spare, he came over and sat with us and chatted. It was nice a personable, which you dont find in many restaurants these days. The waitress was very nice too. A+ for customer service! I highly recommend going in and getting a bite to eat!

… more

Michelle Forney
I came in for a pick up order. All of the staff was friendly and very attentive. They even went out of their way to talk with my daughter and show her one of the pizza dough balls. The eggplant Parmesan sandwich was delicious. We will definitely be back!

… more

MeShell Edwards
Pizza was simply amazing!! Sauce tastes fresh with lots of herbs and slightly sweet ! Dough was cooked perfectly slightly crisp but super soft! Been in Surprise for 2 years and can’t believe we slept on this spot!! Not anymore !! Next evening my son wanted to order from them again!!

… more

Robert Lucio
My family had a great time here. The appetizers were good and the pizza was nothing short of incredible. Just the right amount of toppings and the sauce is really good. The staff is friendly and really made our experience there enjoyable. I will definitely be back. You know it was a good time when your kids are still talking about it the next morning!!

… more

SS
Dough was tasteless cardboard , the Chicago style deep dish was very presentable, but no one in my house ate more than 1 slice. Between delivery and tip, 2 pizzas was $90. Should have gone to Chick-fil-A

… more

Littlepuppysale
Love this place! Excellent customer service! AMAZING FOOD!! Best pizza in all AZ !!! The owner George personally makes sure his customers have a wonderful experience!!! He gave our boys pizza dough to play with while we wait for our food. This is our FAVORITE restaurant!!!

… more

Dolores Damian
Really good pizza! Got the square pizza! Chicago style! They also have deep dish and regular crust pizza.

… more

Dianna Rizzute
BEST Chicago style pizza in AZ! I’m from Chicago and this pizza fills my desperate need for pizza the way I used to have. I’ve always had the Little Sicily and ask for it browned on top, or I call it well-done. Perfect every time!! LOVE THIS PLACE! Far from my home but we always go when we have a doc appt at Del Webb.

… more

Anthony Quirk
Great Pizza Place .

… more

Aehr Enyaf
Stopped here needing somewhere quick and home-cooked to eat. The mom and pop service was so warming and the veggie pizza was hot fresh and delicious! Laila was so kind will come back when in town

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions