Since 1985
Casey’s Pizza started out with his grandfather Anthony Tolerico. The “Casey’s” name came from his love of baseball and his favorite player Casey Stengel. Casey Stengel played for the Boston Braves but was most noted for managing the Yankees in the early 50’s and later when the Yankees expanded to the New York Mets. Everyone started calling him Casey and the nickname stuck.
The first Casey’s pizza opened up at Universal shopping plaza in Penn Hills in 1968, a few years later they moved to the Ritzland shopping center. They would make fresh dough every morning and grate fresh cheese everyday and that practice is still done to this day. Casey opened up 5 more locations throughout the years before settling down in Turtle Creek, Pa.
Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods. Based on 328 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
922 Penn Ave, Turtle Creek, PA 15145
Phone: (412) 829-2277
Website: https://caseyspizzatc.com/
Hours
| Wednesday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday |
12–9:30 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christian Adams
Woow good pizza. This place is the pizza you get if you really are all about the cheese on a pizza. That’s the best part and they make it the best part. The other parts are a hot crispy tangy sweet saucey luxury delivery service for all that good stuff on top.
… more
linda divirgilio
Ordered a pizza on Friday at 6pm. Told delivery would take an hour. Waited for an hour and 20 minutes and from them! tried calling but line was busy. Never received the pizza or a call back, nothing. Last time I will ever order from them!!
… more
ric williams
No complaints about the food, but the ladies working there seemed as if they were irritated with me ,for coming to pick up my order , in which they didn’t even have finished on time.. maybe next time they’ll be in better spirits….
… more
Catherine McCutcheon
We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a large mushroom pizza. The pepperoni one was delicious, the mushroom one was horrible. The dough was not done. We also ordered two dinners that were supposed to come with garlic bread. Only one dinner had bread.
… more
Angel Troutman
I don’t recommend this place I called & ordered a steak calzone & in the middle of my order he hung up on me. That’s rude & bad business. So think twice before ordering from this place. They need to work on their customer service.
… more
Jenn
Haven’t ordered from here in 4 years because my pizzas were burnt last time. Decided to try them out again. Food delivery was on time and the taste was good but the crust of the pizza was so thin. It was like chewing on globs of cheese. It wasn’t very enjoyable. The other pizza was burnt. Hoagie was okay.
… more
KayKay
Burnt pizza. They knew they shouldn’t have sold this. Didn’t find out until I drove home.
… more
jordan holland
I wish I could rate this lower. This was a great evening just throwing away $40. Wasting an hour of my time to get sub par food. And now, at 7pm. I still have to make a dinner since the food was so bad. Never again. The pizza was burnt on the top and the bottom was so thin so that was wonderful. Then the wings were never mixed with the sauce so half of them were burnt and half didn’t have any sauce. Then the hoagie was easily the best part and I think the only issue was that there was no dressing. But a hoagie with no sauce isn’t worth $40. So now, at 7:30 I have to decide whether I drive the 15 mins back waste more time to ask for a refund. Which who knows if I will even get the $ for it. I am shocked at how bad it’s gotten because a year or so ago it was actually worth going to. So frustrating when families don’t have money to just throw away right now. This was a great way to spend my weekend ! Just upset about a meal that should’ve never been this bad. I mean do they not realize that they sent me home with burned food? Like it’s just the lack of standard for me.
… more
Mike E
Got a Rigatoni dinner with garlic toast. Wow! I’ve eaten about 1/2 of the abundance of food provided in the dinner. Rigatoni is very good with plenty of sauce. The photo shows the half I’m still working on. Highly recommend! PS – There is enough food in one dinner for 2 people in my opinion. I have leftovers from the dinner I was eating… I’m not one to have leftovers. lol
… more
Katie Lynn
I love Casey’s!!! They have the best hoagies and white pizza around! You won’t be sorry.
… more
… View more
