Based on 104 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2186 Empire Blvd, Webster, NY 14580
Phone: (585) 787-3333
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dave “Doodles” Newman
Yes, highly recommended. 5 stars for 2 large pizzas and orders of wings. All very good… sauces included. Thick, thin whatever you want. No skimping on the toppings. Done to perfection. I was never a fan of the conveyer belt cooking process, but seems to work for Caraglio’s. 3 stars for service, bc it was about 15 minutes later than expected, said they were busy, I get it…met with a $10 gift card removed the sting. The atmosphere?… Well, it’s a waiting room… gotta try it. Good luck Caraglios… we’ll be back, often. Just at $10/ per… can’t go wrong
… more
Roxanne Hill
Such a good place they are so nice that I called and asked them if my eighty-year-old mother can get a birthday pizza and the guy said sure no problem what would you like on it no sign up just come on in really nice ty great pizza
… more
Antonio Vicente
One of my go too spots great food. Had a way better review written and it deleted it all so just wanna make sure I said do not spend ANY OF YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY AT CORDELLOS WHATS SO EVER. THAT BUSINESS DOES NOT appreciate you or your money. Caragilos on the other hand DOES APPRECIATE you and your business. They are also why better then the other nasty business i mentioned. Caragilos FTW
… more
Travis Cooper
Damn good pizza every time. Love the quick service. Never disappoints.
… more
Darla-Lynn Cira
First time trying their pizza. Went to the Webster location. I have to say it was pretty good. The crust was the bomb and I loved it and kind of pepperoni they use. My only complaint or criticism is I would like a little more sauce and I tend to like a bit sweeter sauce that balances out the saltiness from the cheese and pepperoni. The crust was perfect crispy/chewy! They forgot to prepare my wings but she was very apologetic. Mistakes happen. Would definitely go back.
… more
Joanne G Bauman
Ordered 2 medium pizza, 1 regular with pepperoni, other white spinach, ricotta & wings all DELICIOUS and cooked perfectly
… more
Mark Ostrander
On behalf of the entire staff of Vision Hyundai Webster we appreciate everything you do. We have had many different pizza’s and lunch programs at the dealership. However the pizza’s and service we receive from your employees is the best around and second to none. Keep up the great job and many many thanks to all of you.
… more
Rod Wasicsko
First time and last time! Ordered tonight the Thursday Special with the 2 large subs, 2 chips , 2 cookies and 2 20oz drinks for 22.22. Specifically asked for no lettuce, extra tomatoes and extra mayo on my sub. I even asked the order taker to repeat my order back to me. Tons of spring mix lettuce 4 thin sliced tomatoes on my large sub and hardly any mayo. In addition had literally 4 thin pieces of turkey on the entire thing. Mostly bread. Waste of 20 plus dollars for a package of cookies, chips and soda. Called to inform the manager and best offer to fix the situation was 20% off the next time or to remake it at a future time. Plenty of other places to go.
… more
Kita
Food, 5 stars. Organization, 1 star. I already know they are slow so I waited an hour before going to pickup my order. When I arrived there were about 5 other ppl waiting and only after giving my name did they put my pizza in the oven. Seemed they got backed up at some point and instead of doing the pizzas by order received, they prioritized delivery and pickups were done based on who came in first. The biggest issue was the rest of my food was made when I placed the order. So 15 mins later I walked out with a hot pizza and everything else was cool/room temp and soggy because it had been sitting for 45+ mins.
… more
Danny Unger
I ordered a sheet pizza 4 weeks ago. The pizza had many bubbles. There was probably six or seven pieces that were not edible. The next sheet we ordered was great. Just ordered another sheet pizza today with a free order of wings. The pizza again had so many bubbles and six or seven wasted pieces. I have taken pictures of all of it. Charging $30 a sheet when it’s really a $20 sheet pizza with all the problems.
… more
… View more