Welcome to Classico Tomato Pies !!
Welcome to Classico Tomato Pies What’s the difference between tomato pie and pizza pie? With tomato pies, the cheese comes first, then the filling, then the tomato sauce topping. Pizza pies do it the other way around, says Steve Cabrera, ‘pizza master’ and co-owner with businesspeople Linda and James Pittari of Classico Tomato Pies in West Windsor, New Jersey. All three of us are fulfilling our dream: doing what we love and making others happy.
Based on 322 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
358 Princeton Hightstown Rd, West Windsor Township, NJ 08550
Phone: (609) 750-1234
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: classicotomatopies.net
Reviews
Michael Tunick
Came here for the first time. Ordered curly fries and a pepperoni pizza. The fries were pretty tasty (ate some before taking the picture). The pizza wasn’t really to my taste. Very very thin crust and too much tomato. These are personal preference issues though, not commentary on bad cooking. Preference aside, I didn’t care for it and I think the price was a few dollars too expensive. I don’t plan on coming back.
… more
Jonathan Vinokur
Very good pizza. Full of flavor and fresh ingredients. Pizza goes quick. 2 people can easily finish the pie and it’s the kind of pie that the more you eat, the more you want. Nice and thin, well balanced tomatoe pie. You are not overpowered by the tomato flavor. Nice restaurant, too. Lots of space. Everything looks clean. Locals love it. I suggest coming here and trying this pizza in person. Can’t imagine this pie to travel well since it’s so thin. My wife also got a veggie pie, which she loved. Happy I found this spot. I think anyone who would come to try this place will be happy. The pizza, 7.7 from me. Would have/could have been a solid 7.9 if it was a bit crispier in each bite.
… more
The Local Foodie
Big fan of Classico. If you’re a fan of thin crust pizzas with a slightly charred crust, you’ll love it here. Pizza is perfectly cooked, the entire establishment is clean and enjoyable to dine in, and the waiters are always so friendly and helpful. This is a great local business to support, and their food is fantastic. I suggest dining in to really enjoy that crunchy pizza (because it may get a bit soggy if you do takeout) on the spot.
… more
Patrick Brennan
Popped in for lunch while working near by and was pleasantly surprised. First off the lunch special is 2 slices and a drink for $6 which is fantastic. Not many decent pizza spots still offer a deal like that anymore.
… more
Etya Sivan
AMAZING YUMMY AND GLUTEN FREE!!! My husband comes here for there pepperoni pizza (which he cannot stop talking about) I have food sensitivities which makes it difficult to find a gluten free pizza store. My husband and I walked in and we had a few questions regarding there gluten free crust, they were super friendly and polite- I didn’t feel like my questions were a bother to them they actually wanted to help!!- I ordered there veggie pie with there gluten free crust and IT WAS THE BEST YUMMIEST GLUTEN FREE PIZZA IVE EVER HAD!!!! I want there sauce recipe! Also they provided my own pizza cutter so there is no cross contamination!
… more
Barbara P
Great pizza . Order was placed online . They get a star deducted for the surprise credit card fee I had to pay that was never disclosed online .
… more
David M. Dwight
The Third and Final Location, we were looking for slices and all they had were sausage and plain.
… more
Ehrrikkah Sunshine
Ordered a sicilian pizza without cheese and this was the worst pizza we ever had! There was hardly any sauce!! It was just dough with a thin layer of sauce.
… more
John Miller
Really nice, spacious restaurant and friendly staff but Jeez..burnt dry pizza and inconsistent cheese and tomato spread. Yikes! Could only eat couple of bites and had to throw away the rest. Low quality bottom of the barrel ingredients. These days people don’t have interest in cooking so they eat anything that is offered to them !!
… more
jeff kovatch
Excellent pizza. Very clean dinning room. Excellent staff. The salad was plentiful.
… more
… View more