Based on 102 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
134 Main St, Hornell, NY 14843
Phone: (607) 324-0043
Website: https://cyrusramsey.com/places/andys-sub-shop/
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
CHET LOWE
Andy’s is under new ownership and moved to 100 loader st. I eat there today. The taste of the ham sub took me in time to when I would order all the time when I was younger… Same great taste… It is 100% spot on !! I am truly a big fan….
… more
The Blue Whale
Absolutely delicious! This is a HUGE upgrade from their last location. Andy’s staff are very kind and accommodating. If you wan a real, quality sub, forget Subway or Wegmans. Andy’s Sub Shop is the place to go!
… more
Sharie Nisbet
Unfortunately, I was not impressed with the Andy’s sub I received. The “whole sub” was only 10″ long. It wasn’t even big enough to share with my husband. I basically paid $12 for a half sub! The roll wasn’t very soft at all. I was told the roast beef was med rare, and as you can see it was anything but. There was hardly any meat on it at all also.
… more
Michelle W.
The best subs around….still, after so many years! It’s just the perfect combo- the tasty bread, the delicious meat, and the pepper relish. I was back in town visiting and I’m so glad it’s still the same here. It was a pleasure to chat with Connie!
… more
Dan F
A Hornell legend! Keeping up a great submarine sandwich tradition. Always the standard I judge every other sub “anywhere” against.
… more
Thomas Morey
First time at new location and owner. Great subs and chefs salad. Will be going more.
… more
Dak Lowery
Hornells best sub shop! I love my daily lunch subs. Awesome management and great staff.
… more
Norah Flanagan
My sub is perfect every time!!
… more
Melissa Storm
Andy’s is always a very clean and friendly environment!!! The staff is excellent!! They can take your orders 3 subs at a time and get all 3 correct!! They are fast and efficient. I would, have and will again strongly suggest and recommend Andy’s Sub Shop for excellent food in the Hornell Area!!
… more
Neeko H.
I have not been in this sub shop in about 12-13 years. I went this past weeking as I was passing through Hornell. I saw the hours were a bit weird, but it was open around 4pm. I had to stop with my wife. I ordered a BLT like I always have. It was very good, the roll was so Soft as it always is. The Brownies are to die for!
… more
… View more