Based on 464 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2005 N 14th St, Ponca City, OK 74601
Phone: (580) 765-6689
Website: https://www.rustybarrellsupperclub.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: rustybarrellsupperclub.com
Reviews
Pamela S (Pami)
Rusty Barrell Supper Club was such a neat historic restaurant. To gain entrance you have to walk down the alley, go through the orange doors, and ring the bell. Food was fantastic and the atmosphere was so unique with a speakeasy, prohibition vibe. If your ever in the area this is a must!
… more
Brian G
Absolutely unique place! It felt like I was entering a speakeasy when I had to ring the doorbell at the entrance and wait for my entry. The food was absolutely amazing! I had the rib eye and tasted the prime rib both were absolutely incredible! They both were spectacularly cooked exactly how I wanted them. The pot belly pork was super tasty and incredible as well! The salad that was available was also amazing and they had tons of options that I was not prepared to see on a salad bar! In my opinion, this place is better than Oklahoma city’s Cattlemens and that is really saying something as that place is really good also!
… more
Easy E
A in the rough,we were having a pretty rough evening so decided to find something to eat and this one came up..I was a little skeptical since it was 30min. before closing and we all know as a rule for me that’s a no go,but we took a chance anyway and we started with drinks and a salad which it’s nice to have a little variety on your Salad so yes you guessed it they had a salad bar but let me backup a sec..it was in this parking lot which is really the back or the side,but we followed the arrow ,get to the door in the alley and it says ring doorbell right..right..so we did and it was answered and we were greeted..service was great,our steaks were cooked on an open grill in the dining room..very cool,potato was fabulous I had prime rib,take it the cut looked horrible but it was the best I’ve had in a long while, the aujus was perfect and we had ribeye it was very good service food everything was great I would like to see this place when it’s busy so we will come earlier next time..it is a little pricey but they are comparable,cloth napkins and tablecloth
… more
Julie Crowe
Make reservations! I’ve seen groups and couples turned away. Knock on the door to get in. It is a rustic setting. Wine selection is good. Salad bar needs healthier choices, I’m not fond of iceberg lettuce and typical Midwestern salad add-ons like chickpeas, diced ham, and boiled eggs. The steak and prime rib are always perfect. The staff is well trained. I would not consider this an intimate restaurant. The staff calls to each other up and down stairs, but it is a novelty and worth the time and money.
… more
Chad Dugan
Cool, retro places with a unique setting. Center grill was awesome, very cozy and great staff..
… more
MJ Ridenour
I first went to this restaurant May 2022 and went back April 2023. During this last trip we had pork chops and filet mignon. We also had baked potatoes, asparagus, and an endless salad bar. The food was wonderful. The service was great.
… more
David Ryan
Been here a few times on business….just great. Fantastic, friendly staff, solid+ food and just a cool vibe. Met the owner and he is a great person to talk with. The bar portion only serves drinks and APPS and it has a very different feeling then the restaurant…I would recommend grabbing a drink in the bar before dinner.
… more
Christie Allison
We thought we didn’t need a reservation on a Thurs evening – my fault! The restaurant was very busy but we were seated within 15 min. It’s like a speakeasy. Side alley entrance with a doorbell. Bartender was fantastic. Steaks were cooked to perfection. Great service all around.
… more
Cale Grauberger
Rusty Barrell Supper Club is located in Ponca City, Ok. It is a great place to get a awesome dinner. They offer steak, pork chops, prime rib and fish. Your meal includes a salad bar that has a lot to choose from! The atmosphere is pretty cool. You have to enter from the alley and ring the doorbell to get in. They encourage you to have reservations to get in. They also offer a full service bar with wine available as well. I highly recommend stopping in if your in the area and get yourself a big ol juicy steak! Tell them I sent ya!
… more
Asif Kassam
Best steak I’ve had possibly ever!! Loved the atmosphere and loved how attentive and great our waitress was even though we were the last customers if the night. Praying I have to go-to work again in Oklahoma so I can eat here again. My mouth waters thinking about it.
… more
… View more