We do not support 3rd party online ordering. *Order at you’re own risk* Please our website platform to place a web orders, we do not charge a convienence fee. Also, the google menu is out of date, and cannot be edited at this time. Use our official website for up to date prices and menu.
Pizza slices, specialty pies & chicken wings are staples at this no-frills joint that’s open late. Based on 655 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
124 Groton Ave, Cortland, NY 13045
Phone: (607) 753-3655
Website: http://www.pontilloscortland.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Giveita Shank
The wings had great flavor and were very crispy. The buffalo chicken salad was mostly a big bowl of iceberg lettuce, so that was kind of disappointing. Our server Jody was excellent and very helpful even though we arrived somewhat late in the evening. Part of the kitchen closes at 9pm so you can’t order everything till 10pm so make sure you plan accordingly.
… more
Anthony Pace
I ordered takeout 8-25-23. A pontini that was cold and like cardboard. You couldn’t even taste the sauce. The boneless wings were cold as well. They were definitely commercially prepared frozen. They were all breading and hardly no meat. Hardly any sauce on the wings and the blue cheese dipping sauce was nothing but mayonnaise. This is the second subpar meal I’ve had there in a row. They are definitely cutting corners. I gave service average and atmosphere average because I didn’t eat there. It’s too bad because they used to make a decent pizza.
… more
Griffer
Fantastic experience. I haven’t been to this place in over 10 years and it surpassed my memories and expectations. Staff was supper friendly and attentive, always making sure drinks were filled. Food was phenomenal. The wings,pizza,fries and chicken finger sub was amazing. Each item was better then the last I tried. I would recommend to anyone wanting to sit down and have a pizza at your table. Price is fair for what you get and a clean environment. I will definitely stop by every time I return home now.
… more
Brooklynn Williams (Tk)
Food was phenomenal. Quality looked fresh and food was still hot! Pizza tasted great and there wasn’t too much grease. Wings were great as ever. Delivery service was fast. Will definitely order again in the future.
… more
Hailey Sweeney
The food is always good. Pizza and wings are my go to and am rarely disappointed. My family has always enjoyed going to pontilllos for lunch, it’s a quick , delicious meal.
… more
Kelsey Smith
Food was good. Service was poor. We had to go find our waitress to get the check and then she never came back to get our credit card, again we had to go up to front to pay. One of us was never asked if wanted a refill on her drink.
… more
Chris Portzline
My family had pontillos for the first time in… I’m not really sure when. 4 years? 5? It was before their Groton location closed anyway. Ordered 2 large pizzas and 2 orders of wings
… more
Jenn Cameron
Pontillo’s used to be a good place to eat or just stop to get a slice of pizza. For starters their menu has No prices and the attitude you get from workers is unacceptable and expect more attitude if you ask a question. After stopping in to place an order and leaving due to getting attitude we tried going to them one more time. We went in to just get some slices and were given attitude (their phones are more important). Our pizza wasn’t even warmed up completely, the size of the slices were small at best (remember we’ve stopped many times before) and my husband ordered a drink and didn’t receive it. When he asked about it he was told he didn’t order a drink however what we paid it seemed like we paid for a drink as well. We will find some place else to get pizza in Cortland.
… more
Traceen Aukett
Ordered sandwiches to go. Was told 30.min. more like 45 . Said they lost our order. No apology no discount for their screw up. Hope the food is good at least
… more
David Reiss
It was a reminder of the original Pontillo’s in Batavia. Great food and great people.
… more
… View more