Real New York Pizza Menu – Orlando, FL

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Orlando, FL

Pizzas, calzones, subs, wings & more offered in a straightforward setting. Based on 394 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Real New York Pizza 32837

Address:
11199 S Orange Blossom Trl, Orlando, FL 32837

Phone: (407) 856-9662

Website:

Hours

Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 12 AM–8 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

SODAS
2 Liter Soda $4.49
Can Soda $1.50
Gatorade $2.25
Malta $1.99
Red Bull $2.99
Snapple $2.25
Soda (20 oz). $2.25
Water $1.00
CREATE YOUR OWN PIZZA
12″ Small Pizza $9.99
14″ Medium Pizza $12.99
16″ Large Pizza $14.99
18″ XLarge Pizza $16.99
20″ Jumbo Pizza $19.99
24″ Large Jumbo Pizza $24.99
28″ XJumbo Pizza $29.99
8″ Mini Pizza $4.99
CALZONES
Large Calzone $16.99
Medium Calzone $12.99
Small Calzone $9.99
STROMBOLI
Large Stromboli $16.99
Medium Stromboli $14.99
Small Stromboli $12.99
GYRO & PATTIES
Breadsticks $4.79
Breadsticks with Cheese $5.99
Garlic Bread 12″ $3.59
Garlic Bread with Cheese $4.79
Garlic Knots & Sauce (3) $2.49
Garlic Knots (12) $4.49
Garlic Knots (3) $1.75
Gyro Classic $8.39
Jamaican Beef Patties $2.49
Jamaican Beef Patties with Cheese $3.49
Jamaican Beef Patties with Cheese & Peppers $3.99
Tequenos W/sauce $6.99
SUBS
Chicken Parmesan Sub $8.39
Meatball Parmesan Sub $8.39
Sausage Parmesan Sub $8.39
Steak & Onion Sub $8.99
PASTA
Baked Ziti $9.99
Fettucine Alfredo $10.79
Fettucine Carbonada Alfredo $12.99
Fettucine Carbonada Alfredo + Chicken $13.99
Fettucine Chicken Alfredo $11.99
Lasagna $9.99
Manicotti $9.99
Side Meatball $3.99
Side Sausage $3.99
Spaghetti with Meatball $9.99
Spaghetti with Sausage $9.99
Stuffed Shells $9.99
SPECIALS
#1. Large Cheese Pizza, 10 Chicken Wings, & 2-Liter Soda $29.99
#2. Large Cheese Pizza, 6 Garlic Knots, & 2-Liter Soda $19.99
#3. (2) Large Cheese Pizzas & 2-Liter Soda $28.99
#4. Extra Large Cheese Pizza, 10 Chicken Wings, 6 Garlic Knots & 2-Liter Soda $33.99
#5. Jumbo Cheese Pizza & 2-Liter Soda $20.99
#6. Extra Jumbo Cheese Pizza, 12 Garlic Knots & 2-Liter Soda $34.99
#7. Large Jumbo Cheese Pizza & 2-Liter Soda $25.99
1 Medium Cheese Pizza & 10 Chicken Wings $19.99
2 Cheese Slices & 20oz Soda $7.24
2 Cheese Slices & Can Soda $6.34
2 Medium Cheese Pizza $19.99
20 Chicken Wings $15.99
Xl Pepperoni Pizza , 2lts Soda $19.99
SLICES
Meat Lovers Slice $4.99
Slice Cheese $2.71
Supreme Slice $5.99
Veggie Slice $4.99
SALADS
Antipasto Salad (Large) $7.95
Antipasto Salad (Small) $5.99
Caesar Salad (Large) $7.95
Caesar Salad (Small) $5.99
Chef Salad (Large) $7.95
Chef Salad (Small) $5.99
Tossed Salad (Large) $5.50
Tossed Salad (Small) $3.50
DESSERTS
Chocolate Cake $3.50
Mini Brownie $3.95
Muffins $2.49
NY Cheesecake $3.50
CHICKEN WINGS
10 Wings $9.99
20 Wings $19.99
30 Wings $29.99
40 Wings $39.99
50 Wings $49.99
Blue Cheese $0.75
Garlic Butter $1.00
Marinara(4oz) $1.00
Ranch $0.75
Catering Pasta
Baked Ziti Full Tray 10 Person $69.00
Chicken Alfredo Full Tray 10 Person $89.00
Chicken Parm Full Tray 10 Person $89.00
Fettucine Alfredo Full Tray 10 Person $59.00
Pasta Marinada Full Tray 10 Person $49.00
Spaghetti Meatballs / Or Sausage Full Tray 10 Person $69.00
Venezuela Food
Cachapas $9.99
Tequenos $6.99
Specialty Pizza
Azteca Pizza $19.99
Cheese Lover’s 16″ $19.99
Chicken Grill 16″ $18.99
Four Cheese 16″ $17.99
Four Stations 16″ $17.99
Latin Lover’s 16″ $17.99
Pizza Star 16″ $17.99
Rustic Pizza 16″ $17.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Justin R
You are a hot mess…. you have no idea what your menu is and could not even take our order. Know your menu and know how your register works.

… more

Max Mancero
Not easy to find pizza that lives up to the name. Enjoyed every slice! Check them out, you won’t be disappointed.

… more

Suzette Gonzalez
Went there for my first time tonight and Holly Molly this is as close to NY as you can get in the Orlando area ! To say this pizza was DELISH is an understatement. I’m definitely going back 🙂

… more

Alberto Ross
The people are so kind. Im a truck driver and they took the time to call me when they didn’t have a certain beverage. And replace it at what I can only imagine a loss to them. Next time I’m in town for the day I know where I’m going to be getting my pizza. Ps the pizza was awesome great taste and huge.

… more

alex muniz
I finally found a place in Orlando that i love as much as the gems i find on outta town trips. This pizza is awesome and ranks on my top 5 pizza places for sure. This is now my go to pizza in Orlando

… more

Brandy Swisher
Took a walk from my hotel today… being from Brooklyn myself I had to stop in and try it… very thin! Delicious! I sat at the counter and listened to the owner interact with the customers.. Mindy is very nice and personable… where else can you get 2 big slices and a soda for $5!

… more

Jest223
Edited: Ordered from Slice and they dropped the price to .75 per topping. I don’t know if they somehow remembered my name but I definitely got pepperoni. A hilarious amount.

… more

Katherine russell
After finally getting down to Orlando for a fu

… more

billy kinsten
Disregard the fake reviews from their family and friends, make no mistake this place is Horrible. 7-11 has better pizza, Heck my kids launchable pack has better pizza. Ingredients not fresh and Pizza was cold, shop looked dirty as well.

… more

Heather Fairfax
Really good pizza. We got the really giant one that was literally too big to fit in our car. Had to put it in the trunk. We wanted it for the novelty of it. It was very good. Perfect balance of crispy crust and toppings. Was in kinda a “hole in the wall” type location. Very friendly staff. Will revisit.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions