Classy restaurant housed in a former bank building offers Italian cooking & live piano on Saturdays. Based on 228 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
23 S Market St, Selinsgrove, PA 17870
Phone: (570) 374-0255
Website: https://www.isabellasselinsgrove.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–11 PM |
| Thursday | 4–11 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 4–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kevin Roth
Had been looking for a new upscale fine dining restaurant for a fancy date nite and was surprised to find this. The atmosphere is incredible as the restaurant is housed in an old bank. Cocktails were on point and the Italian food was delicious. We stopped in on Saturday night and got to enjoy live piano. You’re going to pay a little more, but it’s definitely worth it.
… more
Tiffani Esh
The atmosphere is beautiful and i loved the live piano music. We were there for a wedding so I expected it to be a little bit chaotic but I was some what disappointed in the food. Don’t get me wrong it tasted amazing but it wasn’t much to eat. The appetizers were amazing, the salad was good but the entre was the issue. The coating on my chicken was a bit soggy and the crab cake was the size of a golf ball. I only got a tablespoon of vegetables if that.
… more
Xelena D
My boyfriend and I are visiting from out of town. We’ve dined here everyday since we first tried it! All the servers are so polite and informative. The ambience is 10/10 and so unique. The food is AMAZING! And I am incredibly picky.
… more
Saundra Wenrich
Went here for my birthday last month, not knowing what to expect; everything was beyond amazing. Our waitress was wonderful and attentive, the food was absolutely FANTASTIC! Sincerely the best I have had from a restaurant in years! I will be back very soon, and I am very disappointed that I have driven past this place for so long.
… more
Dorthea Morgan
If you’re looking for a local yet luxurious establishment for a great date night, look no further than Isabellas!
… more
Valerie Cleveland
We went for our Anniversary and it was amazing! We did not have a reservation but the Chef and staff were very gracious & accommodating. The food is absolutely phenomenal!..I can not stress that enough! If you want true Italian cuisine, you must go! The atmosphere and staff are wonderful and the restaurant itself is unique and beautiful. We will definitely be going back!
… more
Jennifer Schmidt
Came for Valentine’s Day and food was awesome! Pricing was good for what sized portions we got. Our server Ali was an amazing server! She was knowledgable about the menu items and specials. She always checked on all her tables on the second level and ran up and down stairs multiple times and service was outstanding!!
… more
Lona Cole
Service was excellent, food was great! Beautiful l space, formerly a bank, set up so nicely!
… more
Josh Curley
It’s pretty great that a little town like Selinsgrove has such a delicious, upscale Italian seafood place. The location inside an old bank creates a very cool atmosphere with the teller counter converted into a bar and a large ceiling chandelier. I was seated on the front balcony which must be a pain for waitstaff but the balconies enable the restaurant to seat more people within a pretty small floor plan and offer a neat view to the main floor. The Saturday evening piano player was a neat touch. My server was friendly and attentive. The food was great. I had the spicy seabass on linguini special. I was warned the sauce was a bit spicy – and it was – just the way I like it! Everyone was happy with their dishes – crab cakes, pasta, and a very well made cocktail. The beer selection and dessert menus were pretty limited but the cannolis were great. Will be back again!
… more
Margaret Rickards
We went here with high expectations but Isabella did not impress. The service was slow 45 mins to get my cocktail came after salad was served. The place was busy but on Saturday that should be expected. Reservations should be adusted to good staff vs customer ratio. The rolls it seems were made from pizza crust dough.
… more
… View more