Mister Sizzle’s Menu – Buffalo, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Buffalo, NY

Industrial-style venue dishing up burgers, sandwiches & milkshakes, plus cocktails. Based on 704 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Mister Sizzle's 14213

Address:
346 Connecticut St, Buffalo, NY 14213

Phone: (716) 919-4949

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–11 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–11 PM
Thursday 11 AM–11 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–11 PM
Monday 11 AM–11 PM

Menu

Standard Burgers (Online)
Butter Burger
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, Butter, American Cheese, Sautéed Onion		 $9.75
Classic
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, American, Onion, Pickle, Ketchup, Mustard

– QUANTITY DISCOUNT AVAILABLE –
(NOTE: Only available on orders placed at mistersizzles.com)

BAG O’ BURGERS SPECIAL:
5 CLASSIC burgers for $35 – Promo Code: BOB5
10 CLASSIC burgers for $65 – Promo Code: BOB10
Order the listed quantity, and then apply the appropriate Promo Code at checkout to get your discount.

NOTE: Only one Promo Code allowed per order. Please enter separate orders if you’d like to use more.

 $8.95
Daddy’s Patty
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, American, Pickle, Lettuce, Onion, Ketchup, Mayo		 $11.50
In A Jiffy
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, Peanut Butter, Grape Jelly, Cream Cheese, Jalapeños		 $9.50
Messy Pressy
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, Gravy, Provolone, Cheese Curds, French Fries		 $12.50
Mister Fun Guy
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, Provolone, Sautéed Mushroom, Onion, Mayo		 $11.50
Piggy Smalls
Burger, American, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Brioche		 $12.50
Saucy Cowboy
Burger, Cheddar, Bacon, Sauteed Onion, Pickle, Cowboy Aioli, Brioche		 $13.00
Screamin’ Mimi 2.0
Burger, Jalapeno, Cream Cheese, Bacon, Pepper Jam, Brioche		 $13.50
Sizzle
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, American, Pickle, Lettuce, Onion, Sizzle Sauce		 $10.50
Sloppy Cow
Burger, Chili, Cheddar, Onion, Brioche		 $13.00
The Double
Brioche Roll, (2) Beef Patty’s, American, Pickle, Sautéed Onion, O.G. Sauce		 $14.50
The Melt
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, Honey Mustard, Sautéed Onion, Pickle, Served on Grilled Cheese		 $13.75
The Royal
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, Fried Capicola, Provolone, Tomato, Onion, Mayo		 $12.50
Vegan Burgers (Online)
Classic (Vegan)
Brioche Roll (V), Impossible Patty, Vegan American, Onion, Pickle, Ketchup, Mustard

– QUANTITY DISCOUNT AVAILABLE –
(NOTE: Only available on orders placed at mistersizzles.com)

BAG O’ BURGERS SPECIAL:
5 CLASSIC (V) burgers for $45 – Promo Code: BOB5V
10 CLASSIC (V) burgers for $85 – Promo Code: BOB10V
Order the listed quantity, and then apply the appropriate Promo Code at checkout to get your discount.

NOTE: Only one Promo Code allowed per order. Please enter separate orders if you’d like to use more.

 $11.75
In A Jiffy (Vegan)
Brioche Roll (V), Impossible Patty, Peanut Butter, Grape Jelly, Jalapeños		 $12.95
Mister Fun Guy (Vegan)
Brioche Roll (V), Impossible Patty, Vegan Cheese, Sautéed Mushrooms, Onion, Vegan Mayo		 $14.95
Plant Eater (Vegan)
Brioche Roll (V), Impossible Patty, Vegan Cheese, BBQ Sauce, Sautéed Mushroom, Onion		 $14.95
Sizzle (Vegan)
Brioche Roll (V), Impossible Patty, Vegan American, Pickle, Lettuce, Onion, Sizzle Sauce		 $13.95
Daddy’s Patty (Vegan)
Brioche Roll, Impossible Patty, Vegan Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle, Ketchup, Vegan Mayo		 $14.95
The Double (Vegan)
Brioche Roll, (2) Impossible Patty’s, Vegan Cheese, Pickle, Sautéed Onion, OG Sauce		 $18.95
Gluten-Free Burgers (Online)
Butter Burger (Gluten-Free)
Gluten-Free Roll, Beef Patty, Butter, American Cheese, Sautéed Onion
**Roll Not Available Vegan		 $12.25
Classic (Gluten-Free)
Gluten-Free Roll, Beef Patty, American Cheese, Onion, Pickle, Ketchup, Mustard

**Roll Not Available Vegan
– QUANTITY DISCOUNT AVAILABLE –
(NOTE: Only available on orders placed at mistersizzles.com)

BAG O’ BURGERS SPECIAL:
5 CLASSIC (GF) burgers for $35 – Promo Code: BOB5
10 CLASSIC (GF) burgers for $65 – Promo Code: BOB10
Order the listed quantity, and then apply the appropriate Promo Code at checkout to get your discount.

NOTE: Only one Promo Code allowed per order. Please enter separate orders if you’d like to use more.

 $11.45
Daddy’s Patty (Gluten-Free)
Gluten Free Roll, Beef Patty, American, Pickle, Lettuce, Onion, Ketchup, Mayo

**Roll Not Available Vegan

 $14.00
In A Jiffy (Gluten-Free)
Gluten-Free Roll, Beef Patty, Peanut Butter, Grape Jelly, Cream Cheese, Jalapeños

**Roll Not Available Vegan

 $12.00
Mister Fun Guy (Gluten-Free)
Gluten-Free Roll, Beef Patty, Provolone, Sautéed Mushroom, Onion, Mayo

**Roll Not Available Vegan

 $14.00
Piggy Smalls (Gluten-Free)
Burger, American, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Gluten-Free Roll		 $15.00
Plant Eater (Gluten Free) $15.00
Saucy Cowboy (Gluten-Free)
Burger, Cheddar, Bacon, Sauteed Onion, Pickle, Cowboy Aioli, Gluten-Free Roll

**Roll Not Available Vegan

 $15.50
Screamin’ Mimi 2.0 (Gluten-Free)
Burger, Jalapeno, Cream Cheese, Bacon, Pepper Jam, Gluten-Free Roll		 $16.00
Sizzle (Gluten-Free)
Gluten-Free Roll, Beef Patty, American, Pickle, Lettuce, Onion, Sizzle Sauce

**Roll Not Available Vegan

 $13.00
Sloppy Cow (Gluten-Free)
Burger, Chili, Cheddar, Onion, Gluten-Free Roll		 $15.50
The Double (Gluten-Free)
Brioche Roll, Beef Patty, American, Pickle, Lettuce, Onion, Sizzle Sauce
**Roll Not Available Vegan		 $17.00
The Melt (Gluten-Free)
Gluten-Free Roll, Beef Patty, Honey Mustard, Sautéed Onion, Pickle, Served on Grilled Cheese
**Roll Not Available Vegan		 $18.75
The Royal (Gluten-Free)
Gluten-Free Roll, Beef Patty, Fried Capicola, Provolone, Tomato, Onion, Mayo

**Roll Not Available Vegan

 $15.00
Fried Chicken (Online)
I Ham Legend
Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Ham, Provolone, Dijon Mustard, Brioche		 $14.50
I Love Honey
Brioche Roll, Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Hot Honey, Sweet Pickles		 $12.50
Melted Hen
Brioche Roll, Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Ranch, Lettuce, Tomato, Between (2) Grilled Cheese.		 $15.75
Queen City
Brioche Roll, Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Queen City Hot Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, Blue Cheese		 $12.75
Seoul Good
Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Spiced Slaw, Korean BBQ, Brioche		 $13.50
Sizzle Stinger
Brioche Roll, Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Burger Patty, Hot Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato, Blue Cheese, Provolone		 $16.00
The Club
Brioche Roll, Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo		 $14.00
Westside Hot Stinger
Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Burger Patty, American, Nashville Hot Sauce, Westside Aioli, Sweet Pickles, Brioche		 $16.00
Westside Hot
Buttermilk Fried Chicken, Nashville Hot Sauce, Westside Aioli, Sweet Pickles, Brioche		 $12.50
Fountain Beverage (Online)
Cherry Soda $3.00
Cola $3.00
Cream Soda $3.00
Diet Cola $3.00
Ginger Ale $3.00
Ice Tea (Sweetened) $3.00
Lemon Lime $3.00
Loganberry $3.00
Orange Soda $3.00
Root Beer $3.00
Sides (Online)
Chicken Nuggets (10 Piece) $7.75
Chicken Nuggets (20 Piece) $13.75
Cup Of Bacon (5pc) $8.00
Grilled Cheese $6.00
Grilled PB & Jelly $6.00
Loaded OG Fries
Fries, Burger, American, Sauteed Onion, OG Sauce		 $14.50
Loaded OG Fries (Vegan)
Fries, Impossible, Vegan Cheese, Sauteed Onion, OG Sauce		 $18.95
Order Of Chili (GF) $5.50
Order Of Fries (V) $5.50
Order Of Poutine
Fries, Brown Gravy, Cheese Curds		 $10.50
Order Of Sweet Potato Fries
Sweet Potato Fries, Cinnamon Sugar, Brown Sugar Dip		 $6.50
Queen City Fries
Nugs, Blue Cheese, Hot Sauce, Fries		 $13.50
Sloppy Cow Fries
Chili, Cheese Sauce, Fries		 $12.00
Milkshakes (Online)
Black & White Milkshake $9.00
Chocolate Cherry Milkshake $9.00
Chocolate Malt Milkshake $9.00
Chocolate Milkshake $9.00
Cinnamon Crunch Milkshake $9.00
Coffee Milkshake $9.00
Cookies & Cream Milkshake
Oreo Shake		 $9.00
Loganberry Milkshake $9.00
Orange Chocolate Milkshake $9.00
Orange Creamsicle Milkshake $9.00
Peanut Butter Banana Milkshake $9.00
Peanut Butter Chocolate Milkshake $9.00
Peanut Butter Vanilla Milkshake $9.00
Strawberry Milkshake $9.00
Vanilla Malt Milkshake $9.00
Vanilla Milkshake $9.00
Dairy-Free Shakes (Online)
Black & White Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Chocolate Cherry Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Chocolate Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Cinnamon Crunch Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Coffee Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Cookies & Cream (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Loganberry Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Orange Chocolate Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Orange Creamsicle Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Peanut Butter Chocolate Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Peanut Butter Vanilla Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Pineapple Coconut Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Strawberry Almond Crisp Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Vanilla Shake (Dairy-Free) $10.25
Standard Floats (Online)
Cherry Float $7.50
Cream Soda Float $7.50
Loganberry Float $7.50
Orange Cream Float $7.50
Root Beer Float $7.50
Strawberry Cream Float $7.50
Vegan Floats (Online)
Cherry Float (Vegan) $7.50
Cream Soda Float (Vegan) $7.50
Loganberry Float (Vegan) $7.50
Orange Cream Float (Vegan) $7.50
Root Beer Float (Vegan) $7.50
Strawberry Cream Float (Vegan) $6.00
Packaged NA Beverages and Mocktails (Online)
A Drink For Augie
Non-alcoholic Drink,
Beet Juice, Pineapple, Honey & Lemon		 $6.00
A-Very Good Drink
Non-Alcoholic Drink,
Grapefruit, Orange & Lime		 $6.00
Litta Cora Cottentail
Non-alcoholic Drink,
Carrot Juice, Ginger Cordial, Ginger Beer & Lemon		 $6.00
Virgin Bloody Mary
Nonalcoholic Drink,
House Made Bloody Mary Mix, Olive & Lime		 $6.00
Virgin Mojito
Non-alcoholic Drink,
Fresh Mint, Simple Syrup, Lime & Soda		 $6.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Matt Matti
All the staff were very nice and accommodating. The food came quickly and was all delicious. I had the sizzle and the meat was delicious and I liked the American cheese. The sweet potato fries with the cinnamon dip were great. I also had the cinnamon milkshake which was delicious as well. Andy was a great bartender and very attentive. I tried their $1 drafts and all the beers were pretty cool, cool having 5 oz $1 drafts. The bar manager was very nice and attentive as well. There’s very few places that you go to where everything goes well and is good, but here it truly was. Good job guys and keep up the great work! Maybe will see you in Canada one day Mr. Sizzle

… more

Liz Marshall Metcalfe
When we started planning our daughter’s 1st birthday party, we knew we wanted something that we (adults) would love and remember forever- because it was fun and delicious. We went with Mister Sizzle’s, and it was the right decision, 100%. The catering manager was incredibly responsive and helpful– and most importantly, the food was a HUGE hit at our party. We ordered sliders (the Classic, the Sizzle, and vegan Classic) and fries– and our guests loved them and kept coming back for seconds and thirds! Everything stayed warm for an extended period of time in the packaging and reheated well too, if you’re worried about having leftovers. I’m a huge fan. 🙂 Thanks, Mister Sizzle’s (and Noelle)!

… more

Aliya D
We got The Double, W.S Hot Stinger, and a chocolate shake. The food was delicious! Staff were kind as well. The atmosphere was great!

… more

Bryan Stranahan
I was so happy to find delicious vegan food in Buffalo while I was on vacation. The vegan Daddy’s Patty, vegan Loaded OG fires, and strawberry almond shake were so delicious. The staff at Mister Sizzle’s was warm and welcoming. Definitely recommend Mister Sizzle’s.

… more

Jeff Walent
Chicken, burgers, milk shakes, bar. Asked for chili in The Melt. So….2 grilled cheese sandwich’s for the bun, burger cooked to perfection, pickles and sautéed onions. Add well seasoned chili. Definitely a knife and fork. Extremely friendly staff that obviously enjoy their job.

… more

Joe Zaleski
Excellent sandwiches, great vibe, well designed space and options out the wazoo!

… more

Rodney Lover
Glad we chose this stop on our way through the city. Close off highway. Delicious burgers and fries in a cool old building. Quick service too.

… more

Conor White
Good burgers and fries. Their specialty is smash-burgers, and they are served on beautiful buns. Service is also fairly quick for how busy they normally are. I enjoy this place, but do not always want to spend 18 dollars on a burger and fires.

… more

T Stevens
Slammin good, stinger burger, poutine fries, were the best, great atmosphere not only for date night, but for families. Service was excellent.

… more

Michael Miller
This place was bustling on a Saturday afternoon. Definitely a family place at that time – no one even at the bar and lots of kids enjoying themselves. The food is plentiful and of the burger or chicken family; but I choose from the brunch menu and had a very nice breakfast sandwich made with a perfect fried egg (for me at least, over hard) and some kind of combo sausage and bacon pattie – quite good. Surely a place to return to regularly.

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Manna @ Northland Menu – Buffalo, NY
  2. Winfield’s Pub LLC Menu – Buffalo, NY
  3. Shys Original Steak House Menu – Buffalo, NY
  4. Las Puertas Buffalo Menu – Buffalo, NY

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch