Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering calzones, sides & desserts. Based on 98 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2402 Okoboji Ave, Milford, IA 51351
Phone: (712) 338-9000
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Reviews
Allen Knapp
Wish I could give less. Person answering phones isn’t polite or friendly, when I finally got the food is was barely room temperature. There’s other places in town with cheaper, better food and service.
… more
Chad Sassman
Worst pizza around the lakes picked it up n it was cold and tasted like plastic and refused to do anything about it.. I wouldn’t eat here id it was the last place on earth.. doesn’t even deserve 1 star
… more
D B
Have eaten here in the past multiple times. Thought we would try it once more before we stopped coming. It was about 12:50 pm. No one else eating in the place, & all tables seemed clean. We picked out a table to sit at. Our table had some grease spots , & small food pieces left on it. Though it had been wiped for you could see the wipe pattern in the table. The front doors had finger prints all over them. The candy machines were the same. We were the for about 40 minutes. No one attempted to wash them. The silverware that we pulled out of their cleaned dispenser, 3 forks, one knife. The forks, & knife were washed however the knife still had greasy food stuck on one side. So not properly cleaned. The pizza was good however the dough was on the boarder of not being fully cooked through. The uncleanliness makes one wonder how clean the kitchen is, & might we get sick from that. (Not enough staff) is not an excuse for keeping your business clean. We will not eat here again for this is the third time in a row this has happened, and will have to try a different God Father’s, & hope the management does a better job of cleaning.
… more
KCB
Staff is generally friendly. A bit pricy compared to other pizza places but they do have slightly better pizzas than others in my opinion so it makes sense to be slightly more expensive.
… more
Celest Chaitram
Good pizza, usually has great service, quick delivery and pickup, but tonight my family and I had to deal with a rather rude and bitter woman, who possessed no customer service skills at all. She told us an hour and a half for delivery after we paid, then my boyfriend asked if we can changed to pick up since we’d be in bed well before the pizza arrives, but the unpleasant female insisted that she was still gonna charge us a delivery fee…luckily my bf has a lot of patience and was able to get assistance from a person there who actually does their job.
… more
Kinzi Desbiens
I went in to pick up my carry-out and everyone seemed confused. It was ready but they hesitated to give it to me. The pizza was over priced for the quality I received. However, I did think the golden crust was good.
… more
Patrick Doll
Got a pizza for take out and said no onions. Got home and guess what? Onions.
… more
Eric Christensen
Not real impressed with the pizza I ordered and this isn’t the first time
… more
keith epperson
Tables and floors were filthy. Asked employee for something to clean my table and they handed me a wet rag. So, apparently you bus your own tables. Cashier wasn’t rude but there was no welcome it thank you. The good thing was, it’s Godfathers pizza.
… more
Based of Spades
Ordered a single pizza, was told it would arrive in an hour. I call an hour and a half later and the person told me my pizza hadn’t even left the store yet. Their delivery man is very kind and cordial and the pizza was very good. And that all makes up for the time. Thanks Jeremy
… more
… View more