Based on 82 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
3-7 Park Plaza, Glen Head, NY 11545
Phone: (516) 674-9480
Website: https://www.sergiospizzeriarestaurant.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sandeep Divekar
Excellent pizzas- we ordered Grandma’s slice and regular cheese. Delivery was a bit running late (Friday evening). We haven’t been to the store yet, ordered via Slice app.
… more
Mr. Busy
Came here hoping to get a good regular slice and Sergio’s didn’t deliver! They use cheap ingredients sadly.
… more
Joseph Lanzarotta
Pretty good standard NY pizza slice nice little crisp to the slice good amount of cheese sauce was good overall a good slice definitely will try more when I travel back up to glen head rd
… more
Frank Sciacca
I am from Suffolk County and every time I visit my girlfriends parents in Glen Head I always stop at Sergios for a regular slice. We don’t get that good quality and texture back by me. I’m looking forward to ordering from Sergio’s for my daughter’s birthday party.
… more
Jennifer Cboski
It’s been a while since I’ve been in NY but stopped in here for a slice. We all had the chicken Cesar salad pizza and it was delicious!
… more
Aplus Martial Arts
The owner of Sergio’s Pizza is extremally kind and welcoming. There is a reason they have been opened for 30 Years.
… more
Tim Chinenov
I considerably enjoyed Sergio’s Pizza. I think people expect Sergio’s to be another low class average pizza store so they believe it to be overpriced. But the pizza at Sergio’s is top quality and they have a considerably wide variety and unique selection of pizza toppings. I got the buffalo ranch and would say this is probably the best buffalo ranch pizza I’ve ever had. This being said, do expect prices to be on the high end. The buffalo slice rang me $4.50.
… more
Martha Nelson
Great location in Glen Head. Large shopping center parking lot. Sergio’s has store front parking spaces as well, having choices is always nice. Once inside, the choices continue in terms of specialty pizzas, the usual and the unexpected. Presentation of pizzas and dishes delight your eyes and palate. The decorum inside is cozy and deem. But, the smiles, greetings and personalities of the staff is a ten. Fortunately, this is what I remember most, the people. I can count on one hand how many times I’ve patronized the place. Unfortunately, I remembered being enamored by the presentation of the food. But, when I actually ate it. It was a huge let down. I said to myself, I would never return. Locals seem to love this pizza, my friends are local, even walking distance and they love it. Recently, I returned to pick up a plain pie for friends, they requested Sergio’s for convience, we would all be leaving within the hour. After delivering the pizza, everyone was delighted. But, I was not. In fact, I realized it was the bread and the lack of sauce and flavors that was disappointing. But, it was a familiar experience and reminder of why I don’t care for Sergio’s pizza. It’s shocking because the pizza can and should taste so much better than what’s presented. Yet, it’s a ten on presentation, a person is salivating just looking at it. The size and slices of Sergio’s pizza is perfect.
… more
Mitchell Schneider
Really nice little place. Pizza is good, but only if you like the bottom and crust a little doughy. Ask for well done and it will be perfecto. Between Abeetza and Sergios, Glen Head/Greenvale/Sea Cliff/East Hills/The Brookvilles is a very lucky area!
… more
Jonny Gropper
Sergios is excellent! It’s my go to place for pizza. I wish it was a little closer, but it is definitely worth the drive. Whenever somebody comes to town this is where I bring them. 10/10 recommend.
… more
… View more