Based on 73 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4136 Library Rd, Castle Shannon, PA 15234
Phone: (412) 507-5400
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–7:30 PM |
| Monday | 3–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jared Moore
This place is amazing. Not sure who runs it but the guy that was in there made me feel like I was at a BBQ at his house, and they are doing an excellent job. GET THE MEATBALL HOAGIE ITS AMAZING. I’ve never seen anything like it. They have a decent lunch special to. Thanks for coming to Castle Shannon
… more
Thomas Fuchs
Soggy pizza, only way it was edible was to throw it under broiler to cook it through. I picked it up as they where boxing it up and I literally live behind the place, so it didn’t have time to steam or soften in the box. It was almost like it was made yesterday and then they just threw some toppings on it and popped it in the microwave for 30 seconds. No way it could have come out of the oven like that. I’ve had pizza that serves cold toppings and cheese but this isn’t that. People here where nice and the order was made quick, but I can’t recommend the pizza. 12 cuts with 2 toppings for over $30 (with tip) and it was undercooked, not worth it at all. Hard pass on this place until the recipe is adjusted. This is a picture after I had to cook the pizza through. 2 stars for the employees and the convenience. Fix the pizza and I’ll be back.
… more
James Wilhelm
This pizza is a real treat. That sauce, cheese and square pizza with a crunch is definitely habit forming in a great sense. Jim Wilhelm
… more
M. P.
Not my fave. Nothing exactly “wrong” with it, just REALLY not my style. I’d say it was priced fairly, but I’d like to take the crust, or the sauce, and go a different direction to make some sort of appetizer out of it.
… more
Patricia Smith
The one star I am giving is entirely for friendliness of the staff and cleanliness of the shop. Both on the phone and while picking up.
… more
Bob B
I like the thinner crust, sauce was decent, but man, they sure skimp on the cheese. Fortunately I ordered 1 serving of extra cheese on the side so I was able to use it on the 4 slices. You also can only get 1 topping per slice which I find very odd. Be nice to get extra cheese with a topping. I will try again because I might get a different person making the pizza and hopefully they use a little more cheese.
… more
Ed Belveny
The food left alot to be desired. The taste was very basic and bland. Most certainly not worth the money. My family and I will not be going back. The service and hospitality were great, which makes reviews like this difficult.
… more
Pizza Guru
Been coming to this location since they opened. If you like thin and crispy crust then this should be your place. Pizza is always on point and the staff has never let me down. Two thumbs up
… more
Beverly Childers
I was so disappointed I was looking forward to having a square pizza, but the cheese was good. The toppings were good. The sauce was good, but the crust was hard as a rock absolutely inedible. In fact, I scraped off the top . I’m not a picky person, but this was a shame. I am very disappointed.
… more
Michael Zinger
$31 Fpr a large one topping and half a hoagie. The pizza is ok. It is very crispy. The hoagie was good. I can’t give 5 stars because the value wasn’t there and I’m not a fan of crispy pizza. I usually save some for the next day. But, I didn’t do that. I won’t be back. Considering a pizza shop very close to them has a carry out special 1 large for $9.99. I’ll spend $10 on good pizza but, I won’t spend over $20 for a crispy square pizza.
… more
… View more