Based on 182 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
400 E Valley Rd, El Jebel, CO 81623
Phone: (970) 963-6088
Website: http://www.nyp.pizza/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Carol Ross
Great option for a family with varied dietary restrictions – something delicious for everyone! Vegetarian, gluten free vegetarian, hot wings, plain cheese, pepperoni or Margherita; everything was fabulous. The meatball sub looked amazing too – maybe next time.
… more
beth ellyn rosenthal
I lived in Manhattan for four years, so I know New York pizza intimately. But this pizzeria in this tiny mountain town in Colorado makes as good or better pizza than New York…or anywhere (except maybe Rome.)
… more
Federico Della Rocca
People here are amazing.
… more
Andrew Gilbert
I’ve done pizza for 8y. This was the chewiest crust I have ever eaten, the staff was mad at someone for asking for a free beer when they forgot to make their order completely. The kitchen being behind the bar is so gross. No one wants to see you fry my frozen wings and fries. I would not recommend this place at all.
… more
GREG SALAZAR
Be prepared to wait for your pizza (over 45 minutes) as there were only 3 workers, definitely needed more help, but the atmosphere was great. We ordered 2 cheese, 1 hawaiian and 1 meat. Overall, the pizza was good.
… more
Christopher Devenney
Best crust I’ve had outside of NY/NJ. Can’t get pizza like this is Denver.
… more
Justin Smith
We had pizza, chicken parmesan and sweet bread. The pizza was tasty, but nothing special. We ordered extra cheese and it was a bit dry, but the toppings tasted fresh. The chicken parm was very good. They didn’t have egg plant parmesan, even though it was on the printed menu. The sweet bread was amazing! Soft, fluffy, with a honey/syrup sauce and powered sugar.
… more
Suheyla A
I accidentally thought the door was locked and the young Hispanic girl nearly had a conniption fit! She was SO rude. I was sweet and caring, tired from work. $20 pizza!? Yes that’s normal-ish, but can I be acknowledged? They threw my pizza to the side and said they couldn’t find it. I sat there patiently, on the phone (quietly). Until a young white male said, “oh we were wondering who’s that was”? How ignorant of him. Bad service, unless your drunk and loud.
… more
Susan Weiss
Good ‘za. The lady who took my order was wearing a hat that said, “Make Aspen Weird Again”. My kind of place.
… more
Monika Hooker
Worst pizza place ever. Not only did I wait for an additional 30 minutes on top of the estimated 20 minutes. After waiting they told me the pizza fell apart and they would give me a credit – they never voided the transaction as promised. Charged me for a new order – which took another 30 minutes. The pizza was soggy. Since I waiting for over an hour – seeing the salad prep area was disgusting and dirty, the girl at the front was wiping counters and flinging old food bits into food prep area. Disgusting – will never go there again.
… more
… View more