Monthly Wine Pairing Events, Dueling Pianos, Coffee Company and for October… Haunted Hotel Attraction. Join us in Cassadaga 7 days a week. Sunday Brunch starts at 8am. Karoke Night, LIVE Music , Full Bar and more. Follow us on Social Media and Visit Us Today!
Based on 672 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
355 Cassadaga Rd, Lake Helen, FL 32744
Phone: (386) 218-3806
Website: https://sinatras.us/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–4 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
John James
Such a great time and great food. I dont know what it was but we had never heard so many talented singer’s on karaoke night. Special thanks to Kirby for helping organize our party and Gabby for being so attentive to us. We had a great weekend and will be back for sure!
… more
Rachel Rigdon
Every couple of years, my friends and I make a day trip to Cassadaga. Our trip wouldn’t be complete without Sinatra’s Ristorante. The food is always delicious. Amy went out of her way to make sure my friend enjoyed her birthday brunch. My favorite is the shrimp and grits. The tater tots have this amazing seasoning that you can have added to your sweet potato fries too. The eggs benedict was cooked to perfection!
… more
Greg Thomas
This was my third time eating here and first time reviewing. This is a fun place to go. We went for dueling pianos and dinner. I had the new York strip, green beans and cannoli. The steak was very good, the green beans were a little under cooked. I like them crunchy, but this was pretty raw. Other than that, very good and just a fun place with a lot of history.
… more
Jody G
Very comfortable and relaxing place to dine. I was there for the lunch hour but it gets a little action at night with music and dueling pianos. Service was awesome and prices were very reasonable. I had the meatballs and sausage on ciabatta bread. The bread was good but not impressed with the meatballs.
… more
EJ Niels
Seems a little dated. The rustic hotel is a great theme. The decor is somewhat vintage. I like the piano-bar area that has the pianos, side by side under a glass top for patrons to sit around. The entertainers played piano well, sadly did not sing as well. The food was fresh and home made. The François sauce could definitely use a little tweaking but the marsala was very good. Salad was basic, pasta was done right, soup was very good.
… more
Brittany Gibbons
It’s giving haunted Schitt’s Creek vibes.
… more
Vince Darrigo
Great meatballs (when they’re not sold out!) Only here for brunch coffee today but here are some good food options I would’ve considered and am sitting nearby!
… more
Robert Earl
Historic!! Great piano bar restaurant! Outstanding food and service!! Art deco kind of place…you’ve gotta check it out!!
… more
rebecca woods
Unique restaurant in old hotel with chandeliers, original wood floors, stained glass windows and more. It also has a nice outdoor deck although it was too hot to use it at the time we were here today. The food was great. The sandwiches and fries were really hot and tasty. We can’t wait to come back for brunch and or piano music!
… more
Marilyn Parente
First visit here appetizers were great, I sent my prime rib back it was over cooked and not fresh cut prime rib , do not recommend that. Hubby had shrimp and lobster, the Alfredo sauce was creamy and delicious. Could have been served in a bowl because the sauce was running over the side of the plate. The staff was friendly and respectful. They did offer a free dessert to make up for my prime rib , So over All a great experience, just don’t recommend the prime rib . Live music during dinner was a nice addition.
… more
… View more