Stalwart counter serve providing classic pies, stuffed breads & sandwiches in a snug, unfussy space. Based on 517 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
425 Derby Ave, West Haven, CT 06516
Phone: (203) 389-1603
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gabe Cruz
Im not sure why I never tried them before i had them on Saturday, but this place is amazing!!! Not only do they make their own bread fresh daily, but their food quality is top notch!! The staff was super nice and welcoming as me being a first time customer and even offered me one of their signature baked cookies! They were so convinced i would like it that they offered to give it to me for free if i didnt! it was amazing btw. they will see me plenty of more times and their bread is absolutely heavenly and doughy and fresh with their sandwiches! Add this place to your restaurant must gos
… more
Amber the princess 100
I swear this is the best pizza around n the garlic knots or garlic sticks whatever they call them are amazing they were so super duper yummy!! most people take the pizza home so it’s not really a dine in place but you can eat there which we did and the servers were so awesome and nice I would recommend this place to anyone who loves pizza. My kids are so picky we usually have to go to two different pizza places if we want to eat pizza so it’s spectacular to actually go to one place they all like.
… more
Yojoa Home Services
Working around the area decided to stop by here and grab lunch, girl at the counter was nice but with not much experience in the food service industry (not a complaint as we all start somewhere somehow) she forgot a customers pizza sliced in the oven which burnt out, she had to get another one in (I could see the customer frustration at the same time understanding which I give him a thumbs up for it). I purchase 2 pizza slices “by the way really good”, baked ziti “good as well” with chicken parm “never seen chicken parm like this one, slices of dry deep fried chicken”.
… more
Lamaar Wright (Marty)
Michaelangelo’s pizzeria is a safe and clean environment and atmosphere for families and friends,once you walk inside you are greeted with peace and happiness,the cashier’s efficiency and accuracy is precise there’s usually not a long wait picking up or dining in the restroom for female and male is clean and sanitize always the food is clean and the prices are unbeatable!
… more
Matthew Whitbeck
Great service, excellent food. Very impressed with the pizza and subs. Absolutely delicious
… more
Addie Wallace
Always order a fresh pie and you will always be pleased. The sauce and cheese are both very good.
… more
maria
I’m disappointed, I order a chicken parmesan dinner. As soon as I opened it I was like no this is not Italian. It just looked like someone just put some regular sauce on it, I did not see any seasonings on it. Not enough cheese and the chicken was over cooked,very dry.
… more
jennifer U
The pizza is good depending on the day. The subs are really good and the bread is absolutely amazing. The counter staff are amazing!! A few years ago I stopped ordering from here because this one girl was always so nasty!! The sauce is very good, if I’m slow on time I’ll order sauce for Sunday dinner. It is busy so I recommend calling in ahead of time.
… more
B L
My favorite pizza in the world. The best toppings, sauce, and overall crispiness. I love it.
… more
maurice brown
Ordered a half pepperoni bacon half cheese… they tell me 30 mins just to give me an old cheese that they added toppings to and barely cooked. I would order from this place often and the quality is trash now…. This will be the last time I waste my money here. I was going to call back but it’s not even worth it. There a lot better places in New Haven go there
… more
… View more