Based on 101 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 2.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford, NJ 07073
Phone: (551) 248-4961
Website: https://www.bestpizzawilliamsburg.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nancy Wong Shek
Best Pizza in American Dream so far has been delicious compared to the other pizza places I have tried in the mall. There’s options between thin and thick slices. I’m a fan of thin slices, delicious and fresh.
… more
Patrick Lewis (praxmoney7729)
As a Pizza aficionado, I decided to give a plain slice a whirl. Met with Steve at the counter, AWESOME guy. Steve gave me a brief history on the place and informed me how the name came about in addition to where their other locations are. The slice had next to no flop, tangy sauce, and the perfect amount of “char”. Can’t say I’ve had a better slice of pizza that’s ever come out of a mall.
… more
Pratiksha Rathi
The best pizza stays up to its name. It’s delicious.
… more
Eloy Yip
My partner and I decided to stop at this establishment located in Court A, Level 2 of the American Dream mall for lunch. Best Pizza is the first Jersey location for the award-winning shop by pizzaiolo and TV host, Frank Pinello. Everything looked tempting and settled on their vegetarian and grandma squares. Both were reheated and arrived warm. We loved the nice crunchy crusts. Grandma square was doughy, cheesy and topped with very good tomatoes. The vegetarian was loaded with a lot garlic and pepper. This might be called Best Pizza but was only good to fill our stomach as the square was just ok at best whose price was reasonable.
… more
Glenn Edwards
We will never come back. Yesterday, 2/18 after receiving the slices we ordered, I asked the guy for a disposable cup for my daughter. He gave me a used one that still had remnants of liquid in it and just walked away. Maybe it’s because of the large crowd but they are dismissive and don’t care about service at all. The other guy working the register was nice but everyone else there doesn’t care. I don’t recommend wasting your money here at $5 per slice but if you do, you’ll see what I mean. Name should be changed to ‘Just Ok Pizza’.
… more
Chuck Mound
I get it, the rent is super high at American Dream and it gets passed on to the Customer. But what does not get passed on is a good slice of Pizza. I ordered a Grandma Slice and a Soda which was $8. The Sauce on the Slice was cold and minimal. I could say the same about the Cheese. Non existent. The rest was a crust. This may called Best Pizza, but it is the only Pizza at the Mall. Its good to fill your stomach after the Snow, but other than that, its not the Best Pizza. The Server was really nice and thats was got them to 2 stars.
… more
Jun Pogi
Pizza was trash. Worst pizza I have ever tasted. Sauce was super salty, smelled like fish and crust was non existent. I ask for mushroom and the guy was like this is what we have. Like it’s that hard to get a slice of pizza and just put mushroom in it then heat it up. To top it off 5 dollar a slice. Save your time and go somewhere else.
… more
viswesh muralitharan
The place stands up to its name! We loved the taste of all their veggie and cheese pizza. They were sold out pretty soon in the night. Highly recommend!
… more
Daniel Wang
This Best Pizza location is literally the best place to get overpriced garbage pizza with a side of attitude filled slow service. Literally NYC dollar slices taste better than the bland trash they call best pizza. If you’re looking to burn your time and money, then this is the best pizza place for you. Otherwise stay far away and avoid….
… more
Dogg_Cutie Gacha Life
Workers were extremely rude and don’t even acknowledge you. First, should be called worst pizza. Second, extremely overpriced. Third, we asked for extra cheese and no basil on top, just sauce and extra cheese. They couldn’t even do that. It looked like they did extra sauce less cheese and extra basil burnt. Not worth the trip and 1+ hour wait.
… more
… View more