Owner formally from Grimaldis Pizzeria, making world famous pizza. Our Coal oven heats up to 1000°. Hand made dough daily, hand made fresh mozzarella along with our secret sauce makes an Award Winning Pizza. Our pizzas and calzones are baked to perfection in our signature coal burning oven, delivering a tantalizing aroma, unique flavor and crisp crust that is just not possible from gas or wood burning ovens. With over 100 years of pizza making in Coal Brick Ovens, This is how pizza was made in NYC in 1905, Day 1. Come in and Taste the Difference. We are BYOB. We recommend reservations on Friday and Saturday (we fill quickly) Great for Families or a Date Night. Plenty of Parking & a Liquor Store (Trezza) next door.
Based on 357 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
287 NJ-35, Middletown Township, NJ 07701
Phone: (732) 219-8800
Website:
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday |
11:45 AM–9 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jacqueline Aguilar
The best pizza around town! Very mouthwatering and flavorful. Service was prompt and friendly. Not too busy. And the pricing was decent as well. Will come back again! We ordered 2 personal pizzas (pepperoni and Brooklyn bridge) since it was only four of us. We got the calamari for starters. And the chocolate Bomba for dessert. Top notch- highly recommend if you like chocolate and ice cream 🙂
… more
Jennifer
Zoni’s makes very good coal fired pizza. The pizzas are cooked to a perfect temperature. The crust is soft with a slight crisp at its edges. The first time I ordered a half Carrol Gardens half Stefano pie. The second time I ordered a half Pesto half Sofia pie. The Carrol Garden pie was the best out of all four. It was DELICIOUS! It was loaded with tasty vegetables! The Margarita base and the ricotta to the Stefano pie was very good, but I didn’t care for the meatballs. The Pesto and the Sofia pie were also very good. Their pies aren’t greasy at all either. I recommend Zoni’s Coal Fired Pizza in Middletown!
… more
Reema Mehta
We came here before attending a concert at PNC Arts Center. The location is very close if you are looking for a great option for a pre-event meal. We ordered a classic Margherita pizza and the Veggie pizza and both were delicious!! Service was excellent and establishment has subway decor. We will certainly return with the family when we need our brick oven pizza fix! Note, location is BYOB and there is a liquor store next door.
… more
Michael Diovisalvo
I will say if you want a good pizza this is your spot! Definitely high on my list for sure, service met my expectations and the experience was well worth it! Get the Margherita well done and thank me later! Will come back!
… more
Caitlin Gran
My husband and I popped in on a Friday night with our 6 month old. The place was VERY busy, but we lucked out with a table from a canceled reservation. We did BYOB and ordered the arugula salad and large margherita pizza. The pizza was one of the best we’ve had in a long time. This is saying a lot considering we’re locals and have lived in NJ our whole lives. The crust was perfectly chewy and only slightly charred and the sauce was tart and delicious. We highly recommend Zoni’s!
… more
Drew Scalice
I came here for the first time a month or so ago for a high school pasta party and the food was amazing. The next week I came back bought a large vodka pie and ate the whole thing in 30 minutes it was gas. I’m currently sitting in Zoni’s at the pasta party before our state championship game and as expected the food is amazing. Don’t hesitate coming here, I have definitely added this to the list above Pasta Pizza Factory and Naples!
… more
Mark Hoff
Meatballs ok. Warm not hot had better
… more
Barbara Flanagan
Best Margarita Pizza short of one I had in Italy.Manager Robert was great came to table to ask if. We needed anything his wife is also RN I was RN in Coney Island Hospital ER he was from Brooklyn. Made us feel welcome we done in all staff professional
… more
Joe Spin
Had delivery so I can’t speak to Atmosphere or Service…..
… more
Kylie Danielle
Great coal fire pizza spot!
… more
… View more
