Based on 307 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
211 Milford St # A, Salisbury, MD 21804
Phone: (410) 543-1911
Website: http://nypizzeriasalisbury.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
TAMMY SMITH
Pizza was ok- kinda bland meat lover added bacon (to make for me a true meat lovers). Wings bbq-ok garlic Parmesan better of the two. Onion rings- not a fan at all. Went on a Friday afternoon not busy atmosphere was ok
… more
Christopher Howard
This is one of the better pizza spots in Salisbury. The cheese is stringy and delicious that slides right off the pizza. For some that’s what they are hoping for. The sauce is not over bearing and overall it’s good
… more
Jennifer Bowden
Well. It pains me to report negatively. We loved De Pietro’s. My favorite pizza is New York Pizza. We pretty regularly went there for take out 1 or 1 times a month. About 6 months ago, the pizza we ordered and picked up was awful. The middle of the pizza was not done, so limp that the cheese and toppings just slid off. The outside was overcooked and mostly burnt. So we let 6 months or so go by and thought we would give it another try, since we have missed their pizza terribly and anyone can have a bad day. Sadly, it was the same thing. I have tried to figure out how this happens. My only guess is that something is wrong with their oven. It is cooked so unevenly. How can some be uncooked or undercooked and some be well done or overdone? With what it costs these days to eat out or get carry out, I atleast expect to be able to eat it. Very disappointed and sad that this is not the De Pietros we knew and loved.
… more
Cody Kile
I have tried TONS of places looking for a good NY style pizza on the eastern shore. This place is the best to date. I think many others know about this hidden gem so plan to order ahead of time on busy days. 5 Stars for sure!!
… more
Elizabeth Johnson
They are literally never open when i try to go there i love the food but they don’t update the website and they are losing a ton of business from constantly closing on weekdays. They also rarely answer the phones
… more
testing testing
I was a regular until the owner decided to serve burnt pizza slices and then Frankenstein-ed the replacement slices. He knew the pizza was burnt when he handed me the box, guess he was hoping I wouldn’t find out until I got home. Very unprofessional. They have good pizza but the majority of the negative reviews are because of burnt food.
… more
Peggy Dennison
I was a regular customer until this evening. They served me a box full of burnt fries and messed up my husbands sandwich. When called about it, the girl was argumentative and refused to put the owner on the phone. The service was terrible and the food was disgusting! There are too many other places to spend my money and I would not recommend this place to a dog! Take your money and your patronage elsewhere!
… more
Richard Irons
The best New York style pizza on the Delmarva peninsula. Period. This place is a hidden gem and worth the drive. I cannot recommend it highly enough.
… more
Matt Farris
Solid pizza, nothing was over the top good about it. Did provide charity giving through purchase order.
… more
Charles Larimore
Food was great people were friendly truly great place to go eat hidden gem in Salisbury
… more
… View more