We are a family owned pizza shop located in South Amherst and are proud to be the oldest pizza place in Amherst run by its original owners.
Our pizza is crafted from a family recipe, hand-tossed and topped with fresh, whole ingredients.
Our dough and sauce are made fresh, every day.
Customer satisfaction and creating a quality, consistent product is our top priorities!
Try our vegan or gluten-free pies
Spread love.
Based on 112 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
481 West St, Amherst, MA 01002
Phone: (413) 256-6100
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
3–8:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Samist19
Went in to pick up a 12″ specialty Greek pizza. The wait was not long at all, all of the staff were friendly, and the pizza was almost completely eaten by the time my wife and I got home
… more
Camille GC
My partner and I are vegan and we LOVE Sibie’s. They have the best vegan pizza and appetizers in the pioneer valley. The cheez they use on their pizzas is delicious and they have a lot of variety. The toppings and fake meats they use are top quality. As if that wasn’t good enough, their crust also stands out. It tastes great, has a great texture, and is always perfectly cooked. They also email me a 10% coupon every once in a while. We hope they come out with more vegan dishes soon!
… more
alleymcglynn
Fantastic pizza, you can really taste how fresh the ingredients are. Love the homemade sauces too! The crust was so chewy and delicious – the attention to detail and care put into the food outweighs any other option in the area. Highly recommend the Greek and Buffalo chicken pizzas!
… more
Aric Pennington
Ordered a whole pie and large grinder. Clean and fresh pizza. Great flavor. Good crust! Not the greasy kind of pizza and had a lot of toppings. Not too sure what’s up with all these negative reviews. Amherst is full of overly sensitive people. The buff chicken grinder was wicked good. Even the coleslaw was good. Finely shredded and had a great texture to it. Nice people. Only thing guys, the prices on the google menu are outdated and off by a few bucks.
… more
Domonic Mei
Been ordering here over a year now, and every single time it has been top notch. All the subs I’ve had have been exactly to my specifications. The pizza’s are always delivered hot and fresh. And the wings. Ohh boy the 1 M sauce is exactly what you’re looking for if you’re a spice aficionado. Give them a try, you won’t be disappointed.
… more
Cameron
Fantastic and very fair priced subs. The ham and cheese as well as the vegan meatball sub were both excellent. Will most certainly come back here next time I’m in the area!
… more
Eric Jacobsen
Ive ordered from here numerous times, delivered to my work (golden nozzle). Never have I ever had a bad bite! This place is amazing! Their pizzas are outstanding..just LOVE the spinach crust! Grinders are top notch also.. Delivery is always fast! Thank you Sibies for being so delicious!
… more
Brendan K
Food is great for the price. Delivery is always quick. Excellent customer service. The one time they messed up my order they immediately offered to send a replacement pizza, though I asked for a credit instead. Why waste a perfectly good pizza?
… more
George Leigh
My all time favorite pizza. Gluten free & vegan options.
… more
Michelle Kellogg
Food is great. The person who answers the phone is great. The delivery service is terrible!!!! First, I was told about 45 minutes for the food. I waited over an hour. Okay, I can overlook that. What I cannot overlook is the fact that when I called, the person answering the phone said he called and texted and left the food outside. The food was outside but HE NEVER CALLED OR TEXTED!!! He Lied To me!!! One thing I cannot stand is a liar! you only get two stars from me and that’s only because the food is good but definitely not worth the wait or the terrible service!!!
… more
… View more