Based on 586 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
216 N Seltzer St, Crestline, OH 44827
Phone: (419) 405-4201
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian Dible
Had some people tell me good things about Mi Cerrito, so finally made it in to decide for myself. The restaurant is interesting from the outside, and it’s decorated nicely inside. The tables are spaced out nicely so you are not sitting on top of anyone. The chips and salsa was excellent. Both of our meals were amazing. The prices are fair and reasonable for the portions. Only two small complaints as the take out box was too small, and I wanted a take out menu and they had none.
… more
Tina V
Remarkable casual dining experience. Exceptional service and excellent family atmosphere. Meals did not disappoint. Street parking as expected thanks to previous reviews, stairs though into the restaurant were kind of a surprise. These 3 adult patrons totally will return! Will also be visiting the Delaware location which is a bit closer in the near future.
… more
Cyndi W
Cute little restaurant. Food was good. Service was good. Hair in our salsa was a turn off. Other than that would recommend. Painting on walls was awesome!
… more
D. Bowman
Very nice restaurant. Friendly staff, never had a problem. The best one around. Hospitality is excellent and the food is awesome. Beautiful interior. food and service are tops.
… more
Katarina Jezik
Great experience ! Exceptional service ! Today was my first time here ! Katherine was our server. I was breastfeeding under a cover- completely concealed; but I was left with only one hand to eat. The food had just come to the table and I was struggling to cut my steak with just a fork. I know right? But I could have managed. All moms manage don’t we? Here comes Katherine. “Can I help you with that?” I hesitated. “Yes!” It just slipped out. I don’t regret it. She graciously assisted me and cut up all of the meat on my ThreeAmigos order. (Amazing by the way) I kept thanking her and she told me it’s no problem she’s helped others in the past with casts and braces. I’ve worked in food service and have never helped anyone cut their food. Not sure if I’ve ever noticed someone needed a hand. But Katherine did. She noticed and she wasn’t afraid to ask me if I needed a hand. And she meant it. My first impression of this restaurant will forever be sealed as a fantastic place to eat. Our meal was amazing. Cheese dip and all. My daughter had fried ice cream with honey. This Crestline gem completely stands tall and competes with the best Mexican joints in Ontario and Mansfield. Top quality food. Exceptional service. Fun clean atmosphere. I’ll be back. And in the meantime I’ll continue to spread the word about my amazing experience, and how my waitress Katherine and her exceptional service will go down as a once in a lifetime experience. You just don’t find service like this these days.
… more
Angela McPeak
We were in town for the Shawshank Redemption Race. We stayed just down the road at the Blue Bird Inn. I gotta say, this little town is adorable! We came to this restaurant both nights we were in town. Their air conditioning wasn’t working but, the service was outstanding, the food was top notch and the decor so cute! The margaritas were superb.
… more
Cyndi W
Food was good. Quite little Mexican restaurant. Steet parking.
… more
J Strubhar
Great place to eat with great tasting food. What more could you ask for? Well, how about staff that pay attention to you and treat you like guests. A must recommend stop if you’re in or around Crestline.
… more
Donna Ensman
The guacamole was very good. The food was ok. I felt the enchiladas needed more inside they seemed lacking and I’ve had better. The fajitas were good as were the salmon tacos. The server was attentive and refilled water. What I didn’t understand was that our entrees were brought out at different times. Just was not normal in my opinion. Overall it was ok.
… more
Jane Baldwin
Absolutely fabulous.
… more
… View more