Based on 101 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
Address:
133 E Racine St, Jefferson, WI 53549
Phone: (920) 541-3040
Website: https://pammys.cloudwaitress.com/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jose Alanis
First time here and it was amazing! I’m not saying it just to say it! The crust was so crispy and fluffy that I almost shed a small tear! And the buffalo was not overpowering on the pizza! And the calzone was the same beautiful crust! But there was one little detail that was left and that was the sauce inside the calzone. But minus that the service was excellent
… more
Allie Against The Machine.
First time here and it was amazing! I’m not saying it just to say it! The crust was so crispy and fluffy that I almost shed a small tear! And the buffalo was not overpowering on the pizza! And the calzone was the same beautiful crust! But there was one little detail that was left and that was the sauce inside the calzone. But minus that the service was excellent
… more
Midwest_Dave
I have been all over Fort, Watertown, Johnson Creek etc etc. NOBODY has pizza that tastes this good…period. Homemade dough-hand tossed. Homemade sauce and sausage. Fresh ingredients and you can tell the difference. Awesome atmosphere inside. Whatever pizza joint is your favorite right now will be replaced with Pammy’s pies 😉
… more
Amber Meyer
After months of wanting to try Pammy’s, my husband and I finally did! We ordered the mozzarella sticks, Buffalo boneless wings, and a New York style pepperoni pizza. Everything was really good and the 2 guys working were super friendly and welcoming. We will definitely be back and we can’t wait to try more food items!
… more
Kitchen Table Travels
Update! We’ve been there a half dozen times now and have never been disappointed! We finally tried a calzone— SO GOOD! The street sticks are great, too. Solid marinara, and the ranch is good, too. I will say, the large “old world” style can be a little soggy in the center— so, the pointy ends when sliced— and I don’t find that to be much of an issue, but others might. When you get toward the crust, it just gets better and better. Pick up times can be a bit long, but just plan accordingly. The first six months are always extra tough to sort out kinks. I’ve been there, and I get it. For good, from scratch, fresh ingredients— I find them priced incredibly well. Good pizza isn’t cheap. You get what you pay for and I’m happy to spend our dollars at Pammy’s.
… more
Jeanna Young
I want someone to look at me the same way I look at pizza. – Anonymous
… more
Molly O’Toole
First time trying this place. 100% hands down the best pizza/calzone I have ever had. I will never order from dominoes or Pizza Hut again. Staff was super friendly. And desert pizzas!! Blueberry cheesecake pizza. Out of this world!! 100/100 recommend. If you haven’t tried them yet you are missing out.
… more
Kerri Burton
Excellent pizza and good service. Even got to talk with Pammy herself. You can tell she loves what she’s doing and really cares about her customers. We’ll definitely be back!
… more
William Manson
We found Pammy’s on a whim just looking to try a new place. It was easy to find and has a pleasant atmosphere. The pizza and cheese sticks were out of this world! We opted to try the Philly cheese steak pizza and we are big fans. The service was off the hook and the hostess and waiter/waitress friendly. Definitely going back to this one again. SUPER NUM-NUM!
… more
Christin Shouse
We’ve gotten pizza, calzones, and desserts from here and they were all very good. I love their pizza crust!
… more
… View more