Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shop – Castro Valley Menu – Castro Valley, CA

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Castro Valley, CA

Mr. Pickle’s is an innovative, artisan-style sandwich shop, specializing in sandwiches, salads, and catering. We are proud to offer our exclusive meats and bread, along with freshly sliced cheeses and locally sourced produce. We feature a Wholesome choice menu with some vegan and lighter options. Our catering options can be picked up or delivered right to your location. Come on in and try one of our Craveworthy creations today!

Regional chain serving hot & cold specialty sandwiches & salads over the counter. Based on 179 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $

✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Castro Valley 94546

Address:
20674 Rustic Dr, Castro Valley, CA 94546

Phone: (510) 398-8532

Website:

Hours

Friday 10 AM–8 PM
Saturday 10 AM–8 PM
Sunday 10 AM–8 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–8 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–8 PM
Thursday 10 AM–8 PM

Menu

Kids Menu
Kids Turkey Meal
Turkey and your choice of cheese, includes applesauce, and cookie.
$6.99
Kids Ham Meal
Ham and your choice of cheese, includes applesauce, and cookie.
$6.99
Kids Salami Meal
Salami and your choice of cheese, includes applesauce, and cookie.
$6.99
Kids PB&J Meal
Peanut butter and strawberry jelly, includes applesauce, and cookie.
$6.99
Applesauce $1.09
Combos
Regular Fountain & Chips $3.89
Large Fountain & Chips $3.99
Bottled Beverage & Chips $4.99
Classics
Club
Turkey Breast, Ham, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomato, Lettuce, Mayo, on Toasted Multi-Grain
$11.99
BLAT
Bacon, Lettuce, Avocado, Tomato, Mayo on Toasted Multi-Grain
$11.99
BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo on Toasted Multi-Grain
$9.99
Salads
Santa Fe Salad
Chicken Breast, Romaine, Avocado, Red Bell Pepper, Tomato, Jalapeño, Pepper Jack, Tortilla Strips & Baja Sauce
$10.99
Tuna Salad Salad
Albacore Tuna Salad, Romaine, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Pepperoncini, Croutons & Choice of Dressing
$10.99
Chef Salad
Turkey Breast, Smoked Ham, Bacon, Cheddar, Swiss, Tomato, Cucumber, Pepperoncini, Croutons & Choice of Dressing
$10.99
BBQ Tri-Tip Salad
Tri-Tip, Romaine, Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Pepperoncini, Croutons & BBQ Ranch Dressing
$11.99
House Salad
Tomato, Cucumber, Onion, Pepperoncini, Croutons & Choice of Dressing
$7.99
Beverages
Regular Fountain Beverage $2.49
Large Fountain Beverage $2.69
Bottled Soda $2.69
Aquafina Water $2.49
Lipton Pure Leaf $2.99
Sides & Chips
Regular Chips $1.99
Potato Salad $2.99
Macaroni Salad $2.99
3 Chocolate Chip Cookies $1.99
Dressing On The Side $1.29
Chocolate Chip Cookie (1-Dozen) $6.99
Sauces On The Side $1.29
Chocolate Chip Cookie (2-Dozen) $11.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie $0.75
Jumbo Dill Pickle # $1.99
Whole Cold Premium
Big Jake
Turkey Breast, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + “The Works”
$11.99
Listen Linda
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, Avocado, + “The Works”
$12.49
Tom Turkey
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, + “The Works”
$11.99
Big Easy
Chicken Salad, Swiss, Avocado, + “The Works”
$12.49
Italian
Pastrami, Ham, Salami, Provolone, Italian Dressing, + “The Works”
$11.89
Della’s Deli
Turkey Breast, Salami, Ham, Cheddar, + “The Works”
$11.99
The “O.G.” Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, + “The Works”
$11.99
Cali Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, Avocado, Cucumbers, + “The Works”
$12.49
The Hero
Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Ham, Cheddar, + “The Works”
$12.99
Say Cheese
Cheddar, Monterrey Jack, Swiss, Provolone + “The Works”
$7.99
Whole Hot Premium
The Mr. Pickle
Chicken Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado, + “The Works”
$11.99
Fast Eddy
Roast Beef, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + “The Works”
$11.99
Got Beef
Roast Beef, Pastrami, Monterey Jack, + “The Works”
$11.99
Hang Loose
Pastrami, Bacon, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + “The Works”
$12.49
Meatball
Italian Meatballs, Provolone, Marinara Sauce, Garlic Sauce.
$11.99
Santa Maria Tri-Tip
Tri-Tip, BBQ Sauce, + “The Works”
$12.99
Reuben
Pastrami, Swiss, Sauerkraut, Thousand Island on Toasted Marble Rye.
$11.99
Kickin’ Chicken
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Hot Sauce, + “The Works”
$11.99
The Ranch
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Ranch Dressing, + “The Works”
$11.99
BBQ Melt
Chicken Breast, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + “The Works”
$11.99
Golden Gate
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Teriyaki Sauce, + “The Works”
$11.99
Hot “T”
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Cranberry Sauce, + “The Works”
$11.99
CJ’s Pastrami
Pastrami, Swiss, Mustard, Pickle.
$11.99
French Dip
Roast Beef, Horseradish Mayo, Garlic Sauce, Au Jus.
$11.99
Baja Cheesesteak
Roast Beef, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Red Bell Peppers, Onion, Pepperoncini.
$11.99
Mrs. Pickle
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado + “The Works”
$11.99
Reggie-Reggie
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce + “The Works”
$11.99
Pickle Burger
Roast Beef, Cheddar, Thousand Island Dressing + “The Works”
$11.99
Spicy Bird
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Jalapenos, Baja Sauce + “The Works”
$11.99
My Deli
My Deli
Select your bread, meat, cheese, + “The Works”
$6.99
1/2 My Deli
Select your bread, meat, cheese, + “The Works”
$4.99
Whole Wholesome Choice
Avocado Sando
One full fresh Avocado, cucumbers, Swiss + “The Works”.
$9.99
Truly Vegan
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Avocado, Red Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini, Mustard & Garlic Sauce
$11.99
Veggie Pestoli
Pesto Aioli, Avocado, Red Bell Pepper, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini & Cheddar
$11.99
Summer Love Wrap
Turkey Breast, Avocado, Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Baja Sauce, + “The Works” on your choice of Wrap
$11.99
Half Hot Premium
The Mr. Pickle
Chicken Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado, + “The Works”
$6.89
Fast Eddy
Roast Beef, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + “The Works”
$6.89
Got Beef
Roast Beef, Pastrami, Monterey Jack, + “The Works”
$6.89
Hang Loose
Pastrami, Bacon, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + “The Works”
$6.89
Meatball
Italian Meatballs, Provolone, Marinara Sauce, Garlic Sauce.
$6.99
Santa Maria Tri-Tip
Tri-Tip, BBQ Sauce, + “The Works”
$6.89
Kickin’ Chicken
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Hot Sauce, + “The Works”
$6.89
The Ranch
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Ranch Dressing, + “The Works”
$6.89
BBQ Melt
Chicken Breast, Cheddar, BBQ Sauce, + “The Works”
$6.89
Golden Gate
Chicken Breast, Monterey Jack, Teriyaki Sauce, + “The Works”
$6.89
Hot “T”
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Cranberry Sauce, + “The Works”
$6.89
CJ’s Pastrami
Pastrami, Swiss, Mustard, Pickle
$6.89
French Dip
Roast Beef, Horseradish Mayo, Garlic Sauce, Au Jus.
$6.89
Baja Cheesesteak
Roast Beef, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce, Red Bell Peppers, Onion, Pepperoncini.
$6.89
Mrs. Pickle
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Monterey Jack, Avocado + “The Works”
$6.89
Reggie-Reggie
Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack, Baja Sauce + “The Works”
$6.89
Pickle Burger
Roast Beef, Cheddar, Thousand Island Dressing + “The Works”
$6.89
Spicy Bird
Turkey Breast, Pepper Jack, Jalapenos, Baja Sauce + “The Works”
$6.89
Half Cold Premium
Big Jake
Turkey Breast, Cream Cheese, Avocado, + “The Works”
$6.89
Listen Linda
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, Avocado, + “The Works”
$6.89
Tom Turkey
Turkey Breast, Bacon, Swiss, + “The Works”
$6.89
Big Easy
Chicken Salad, Swiss, Avocado, + “The Works”
$6.89
Italian
Pastrami, Ham, Salami, Provolone, Italian Dressing, + “The Works”
$6.89
Della’s Deli
Turkey Breast, Salami, Ham, Cheddar, + “The Works”
$6.89
The “O.G.” Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, + “The Works”
$6.89
Cali Tuna
Albacore Tuna Salad, Swiss, Avocado, Cucumbers, + “The Works”
$6.99
The Hero
Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Ham, Cheddar, + “The Works”
$6.99
Half Wholesome Choice
Avocado Sando
One half fresh Avocado, Swiss, cucumbers, + “The Works”.
$5.99
Truly Vegan
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Avocado, Red Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini, Mustard & Garlic Sauce
$6.99
Veggie Pestoli
Pesto Aioli, Avocado, Red Bell Pepper, Cucumber, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Lettuce, Pepperoncini & Cheddar
$6.99

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jess Linde-Goodfellow
Let me preface this by saying I went to this location on a Sunday night…

… more

Nicholas Gerry
I order here very often. The sandwichs are great. However there seems to be a disconnect between the staff and the doordash menu. If I remove toppings they are almost allways on the sandwich anyway.

… more

Sir Kamryn Lloyd
Very disappointing I ordered a Dellas sandwich on crunch bread which should have consisted of turkey breast,ham and salami however I got turkey, ham and roast beef . My two sandwiches, three chips and two lipton teas came to $30 and some change. Not to mention that the fountain soda machine was out of order and the bottle sodas consisted of slim pickings only 2 kinds of sodas, 3 different kinds of teas and I believe some Gatorade. The staff looked very uncomfortable and was maneuvering as if they was discombobulated. I was really hungry and on my way to track practice and wanted something while on my way. Just spend $12 out of $30 on a sandwich that was made wrong. It would be nice for the staff to actually know what goes on and in the sandwiches that they have specified. I was completely disappointed and my first time going to any of their locations to buy anything

… more

Michelle Peters
Their online site submitted my charge 4 times. My Mr pickle sandwich had no tomato and no avocado.

… more

Christine Barbir
I went to get sandwiches on Tuesday. Right when they opened. Great service, sandwiches were awesome!

… more

Beyond_Reality01
Castro Valley and CV restaurants has really gone downhill since places keep hiring lazy teenagers. They forgot what the works even means at this restaurant, didn’t read the special request note, like dude, get it together. It. Is. A. Sandwich. I don’t expect it to look gorgeous, but I expect to get everything that I paid for. Maybe instead of spending so much time on your extra teenage makeup, you’d spend extra time learning how to do the job you applied for. Like, I bet their boss wouldn’t approve of the sandwiches they make when they’re not there. Y’all need to be more on these kids. You have requirements. Meet them. End of discussion.

… more

Jim Feaster
Great sandwich

… more

Cathy Wise
This is the second time that we have ordered french dips and not gotten any au sjuo sauce!!!!! We visit your restaurant frequently but am getting really tired of this mistake,!!!!!! You would think that the sauce would be put next to the sandwiches when made!!!

… more

Stephen Moore
This is the same kind of place as Subway and Togo’s. I like both those places and go to both, but Mr Pickle’s is significantly better than either one of them. Significantly better. When I finsh eating I think, Damn, that was a good sandwich! Plus they have really nice potato salad and macaroni salad–in addition to every kind of chips known to mankind.

… more

kiyoka owens
It doesn’t matter how many of staff is there. It’s the quality of service

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions