Welcome to DiMaggio’s Pizzeria in Hicksville, NY! We take pride in serving the best sesame crust pizza in town. Our crispy golden crust topped with sesame seeds creates a unique and delightful flavor. Even Billy Joel and his mom are fans! But we’re not just about pizza. Our menu features incredible homemade Italian dishes like lasagna, spaghetti Bolognese, and chicken Parmesan. Don’t forget to try our refreshing Italian ice! Made with the finest ingredients, it’s the perfect treat. We use fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes to ensure every dish is of the highest quality. Our friendly staff creates a welcoming atmosphere for you to enjoy your meal. Come and experience DiMaggio’s Pizzeria. Satisfaction guaranteed!
Based on 138 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3 W Village Green, Hicksville, NY 11801
Phone: (516) 796-0611
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kenji Horiuchi
Friendly staff, compensated me fairly when they got the order slightly off. Garlic knots are a bit too doughy to my liking but the sesame pizza crust is different and quite enjoyable. The dough itself is the perfect combination of moist and crunchy; even the crust was finished.
… more
Tomas Gonzalez
If you are in the Hicksville area this is a must stop for a great old school slice with a flair. Located in a unassuming shopping strip mall, this Pizzeria has it all. Once you walk through the doors you will see why this is a LI local Favorite. You will Start humming your favorite Billy Joel song because after all this was his favorite spot as a kid.
… more
Hellmuffin 67
DiMaggio’s has been a long time staple in Hicksville. Even though it’s under new management, they kept the quality of the food the same. Staff is incredibly friendly, like having a family member behind the counter. Food is excellent, pizza is still over the top!! However, if you have food allergies, they use a lot of sesame seeds in the kitchen. That is my only warning. Otherwise, there’s no place else like DiMaggio’s!!! Buon appetito!
… more
ireneb71
Our family’s favorite pizza place!
… more
Irfan Punekar
Excellent New York style pizza with a great selection and some of the best crust I’ve ever had. Tastes like home. Very friendly staff and quick service too.
… more
Dan S.
This had been my go to place since Two Guys retired. We have enjoyed it in the past but I lost track – I believe it’s been sold twice in the lat 6 months. Quality has been going down hill with the new owners. The latest was hardly any cheese on pizza very thin and tough crust and no sesame seed crust!! Specialty items just as unsatisfying!! As someone else said time to move on.
… more
Luann L
New owners – higher prices go without saying but the quality has gone down hill. We always loved their calzones. Tonight they were made by someone new, they were smaller, the dough stretched thinner, much more mozzarella vs the amount of ricotta AND the ricotta tastes different. We’ve been going here for years. I guess it’s time to move on.
… more
Lauren Ritschel-Littell
Killed and institution! My favorite pizza and anyone who came to my house’s favorite pizza and whatever happened there it’s no more! We haven’t been happy with the pizza or service in months! And the pieces, inflation is one thing, they’re insane! We use two brothers now.
… more
Dutch Schultz
Wow!! I haven’t been here in years and I’ll never go back! I ordered an order of Shrimp Fra Diavolo and a side of meatballs. What I received was an order of overcooked meatballs and a plate of pasta and tomato sauce. ZERO SHRIMP!!! $25 completely wasted. Biden inflation is one thing.. This was robbery!
… more
Brian Rooney
Pizzas average. Ordered a half pepperoni Sicilian. I asked for garlic powder, red pepper flakes and grated Parm on the side and who I assume is the owner nearly had a heart attack saying you gotta charge him a dollar each!!! They didn’t charge me but left a bad taste in my mouth. Anyway two brothers pizza is across the street. Cleaner, friendlier, and they don’t stroke out when asking for sides of condiments.
… more
… View more
