Based on 63 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
Address:
215 W 7th St, Eureka, CA 95501
Phone: (707) 798-2007
Website: https://brettspizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Danny Gatton
Wow! I am very impressed with Brett’s Pizzeria! So many great things to comment on. First, they make three different styles of pizza! California hand tossed, Detroit deep dish and a Chicago deep dish. We had the hand tossed and Detroit tonight (the Chicago style takes longer so I will try that next time). Second it was delicious. Third, the prices are fantastic! Seriously impressed with how much food we got for the money, it is a screaming good deal in today’s overpriced marketplace this stands out to me. The sauce had great flavour and the cheese blend was spot on. The dough is excellent and the pies were cooked perfectly. They have an arcade, pool tables, TV’s for sports games a large dining room and friendly staff. This will be my go to for pizza now in Eureka for sure. It is the old Angelo’s location which is an old school pizzeria building so it is wonderful it is so greatly improved yet continuing a tradition for the location. Bring your appetite and if you like good beer they have that in drives too.
… more
Amy Smith
This place is huge! Bring your next part here, no shortage of group seating. And there’s arcade games and pool. The pizza is AMAZING! We tried the Detroit deep dish pepperoni (large), bread sticks (small) and the Greek salad (small) all amazing and fresh. What a gem this place is!
… more
Fire truck
First the good:
… more
Julie Larsen
Loni (Leilani ) was very pleasant to work with today! Since It was My first time in, She was very helpful to make any recommendations to My order! I will Definitely be coming back here soon! Thank You Leilani, for the Excellent Service & Nice Smile!
… more
polkadotrose
We have been searching for the perfect-for-us local pizza place for years and we’ve finally found it. Brett’s Pizzeria is not only incredibly great pizza with a variety of styles to choose from, but is a great deal for what you get. The Detroit Pizza is a must-have. We want to try their Chicago deep
… more
Cleo Carrino
This is my new favorite pizza! I grew up with homemade Chicago style pizza, so I have a pretty high standard, and I was pleasantly surprised that Brett’s did not disappoint! The crust was crispy yet fluffy, just like my mom used to make in her cast iron skillet! We got a simple pepperoni Chicago style…it was SO GOOD. Also it fed us for days, just like the guy (maybe the owner?) said it would. It takes an hour, but is well worth the wait. We’ve also tried the Detroit style BLT pizza – seriously delicious! I might like the Detroit style even better than the Chicago style. The ingredients seem really high quality, I especially like the sauce (a lot of places seem to pay not enough attention to the sauce), the cheese was really good and used liberally (and less greasy it seemed!) the bacon was thick and the pepperoni was even good quality! I don’t know, it just feels like there’s a lot of care and passion going into the pizzas.
… more
Leah Valdivia
We are there on Easter and really enjoyed the Chicago Style pizza. It was a bit of a wait, but worth it. The restaurant was clean and the staff were friendly. My only critique about the atmosphere is that the interior seems dated and could use a makeover. Don’t let that stop you though; give Brett’s a try!
… more
Debbie Arrington
Brett’s pizza crust….you don’t even need sauce to eat it, it’s that good Inexpensive and delicious, plus they have beers on tap reasonably priced as well.
… more
Robert Miller
Very dissatisfied with their Detroit Style deep dish BBQ chicken. It was EXTREMELY doughy and void of sauce that would have offset the dough. The cheese could have been cut in half and would have been perfect. As it was this was inedible cold and I typically enjoy leftover pizza.
… more
Denzel Simuel
Overall not a bad pizza at all but sadly just found it to be a bit basic in taste. Got the detroit style with pepperoni and extra sauce and still found it lacking in sauce with the pepperoni ratio way off. I feel that when you got one of the only places in town offering this style of pizza you really need to stand out with them. I will be going back to try their deep dish but definitely hope my next detroit style has way more pepp and sauce to offset the amount of bread (which is a proper amount). Them crispy edges and the cook of the pizza is on point though.
… more
… View more