Tomatoes Pizza Pie~ An Original New York Style Hand Tossed Pizza In South Central Utah since 2009. We offer an extensive menu full of authentic New York Style Pizza, Calzone, Italian Pasta Dishes, Panini, Burgers, Cold Sandwiches, Salads, Chicken Wings, Breadsticks, Homemade Desserts and Hand Dipped Ice Cream. Seating indoors or out, we are a Full Service seasonal restaurant ~We Are Not A Fast Food Joint~ All of our dough is proudly made by hand daily. Wait times and availability of certain menu items vary depending on demand at any given time. The owners and staff at Tomatoes look forward to serving you.
Based on 422 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
10 Main St, Marysvale, UT 84750
Phone: (435) 326-4444
Website: http://www.tomatoespizzapie.com/
Hours
| Wednesday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday |
11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday |
12–7 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Joseph Haughey
Took a family of 11 on a Saturday, and they were able to seat us fairly quickly. The food was delicious, and the service was great. We ordered the pepperoni with extra Mozarella, Hawaiian, the Italian, and a custom pizza. Will definitely go back.
… more
Peter Richard
This place was recommended by the owner of the Marysvale hotel. I went for an early dinner. Walking up to the entrance. It appeared most of the staff was taking a break out front. I entered and a person behind the counter asked if I wanted a table and for how many. I said one person. He then placed me at a small round table next to the waiting area , literally next to the waiting area, one of the waiting area chairs was at the table. I ask for a different table near a window. He said this is the only one person table we have. I was one of two customers at the restaurant. He was not going to put me at another table. Very strange. Then he walked out the door to take a break with his coworkers. Despite that situation, the rest of the restaurant staff was pleasant and attentive. The Pizza I ordered was excellent and quick to the table.
… more
Steve Barket
Absolutely fantastic pizza, It’s the best in all of southern Utah! The salad was super fresh and the ice tea is brewed on location!!!
… more
Yin Yong Chee
If you like wings order the butter garlic parmesan! Great flavour and decent pizza
… more
Jc Mickelson
Best cheese bread and marina sauce any where.
… more
Matt Cox
Great Pizza. We were starving after a long day and we were looking forward to pizza. We ordered a Chicken bacon ranch and an Italian pizza. The crust is great. The thickness is perfect, not too thick and not too thin. The chicken basic ranch was really good with strips of bacon and not just bacon bits. The Italian had a great proportion of Italian sausage and veggies. What a great meal in a beautiful town. Highly recommend you give it a try out you are in Marysvale.
… more
Jennifer Norton
Cheesy garlic bread is amazing! BBQ sauce on the wings was very good. They have a nice sweet marinara (not bitter like alot of places) which really gives it a homemade taste. Pizza is excellent as well. Our waiter is super sweet. So glad we stopped and tried this place before driving home.
… more
Matt Hutchinson
The BEST pizza I’ve ever eaten. We live 30 minutes away and make a special trip just for this pizza and the service as well. We always have the best experience and the best pizza. Also, you have to get their cheese sticks. Second to none!!!!
… more
Andrew Netterville
As 1 of 2 weary day hikers and rock hounders on July 8, 2023, I can assure you Tomatoes Pizza Pie is the real deal. Searching for good hot food on a Sunday is hit and miss, but Tomātoes, or is it Tomãtoes Pizza was a bull’s eye. We got a 12″ pizza and I kid you not we were fighting over the last piece. The dough was fresh, not frozen and the toppings were fresh and delicious. The price was low and the service was quick. Give them a try and see for yourself.
… more
Dawn S
While out on a scenic drive around dinner time, we found this lovely little hole in the wall to satisfy our hunger. We got a large three topping and it was amazeballs. The atmosphere was great. They were busy but they took great care of everyone. We will be back!
… more
… View more
