Based on 145 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
906 Mt Kemble Ave, New Vernon, NJ 07976
Phone: (908) 630-0500
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Garrett Gayles
One of my favorite pizza spots, ever! The guys are always welcoming and pleasant, the service is great and the pizza, even better, one sausage slice and one pepperoni is highly recommended I’ll most likely be there again for lunch tomorrow
… more
Chuck Mound
The Outside looks inviting, but the Pizza tells a different story. No washing your hands before you eat here because Bathrooms are not open to paying customers. So that’s my first interaction. I read these reviews expecting a superb slice of Pizza, but got anything but. Only took 2 bites driving down the road to get the taste and the smell of bad cheese. The slice had a funky smell to it. I saved the slice to share the experience with others to make sure it wasn’t just me and they agreed. Not much else to add after that. I won’t be going back.
… more
Katelynn Savas
We love Dominicks Pizza so much! Their pepperoni Stromboli and Buffalo chicken pizza are both so good. You obviously can’t go wrong with a classic pie, too! Don’t sleep on Dominicks, it’s the best!
… more
James Savage
This is our go-to pizza, fast delicious food, Nick is the best with customers, have enjoyed appetizers, pizzas and dinner plates like penne vodka etc for years. Thanks Dominick’s!
… more
Justin Sapir
Stopped by for the first time after driving by a bunch of times. Very nice atmosphere. Staff was great. Got the meatball sub, one of the best I have had. They make their own bread daily. Will be going back. Also, it looks like they have a nice little patio when the weather is nice. A little hidden from the main road so look for their small stand up sign.
… more
Erik Dreff
I keep coming back here. They make a delicious pizza, doesn’t matter the toppings, they are all so good. Perfect crisp crust, chewy bite. They get the order right every time. Strong recommend.
… more
Kelley Rutkowski
Really good pizza. Delicious crust. Also the people in there are super nice. We’re repeat customers and will continue to return.
… more
Andrew Fredericks
Great little pizza place always fresh slices on the counter and friendly faces. Ordered for my family last week and got some delicious pizza, pastas, and salads. Highly recommend I always have a great experience.
… more
Anthony D’Emidio
I’ve only had the pizza here and it is good. Sometimes I stop in just to pick up a couple slices on my way home. I think that one reviewer just got a messed up pie somehow cause everytime I had their pizza it was good. Not the best ever but definitely good! And trust me I know pizza!
… more
Paul Sulse
Very Very good pie, crust not over done and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. I would have given 5 stars, but I asked for no oil and vinegar on my grilled chicken sandwich and what did I get on my sandwich…yup oil and vinegar! Still delicious I have to say…
… more
… View more