Laid-back pizza chain serving classic & creative NYC-style pies, plus chicken wings & breadsticks. Based on 289 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1513 W McGalliard Rd, Muncie, IN 47304
Phone: (765) 281-1000
Hours
| Sunday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4 PM–3 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Wednesday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Thursday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Friday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–4 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
bill bob
They’re usually very good and very cheap. Love the breadsticks. Have had undercooked pizza so much so I had to cook it for 15 minutes at 365. Like that almost frozen lol. It was a late order so I get it. Still highly recommend.
… more
Crazy Cat Lady
I’ve ordered pizzas and subs several times with fantastic results. Tonight’s order was very disappointing. The ordering and delivery were great. The subs I got were not. The buns were small and tasteless. The fillings were so meager, I have no idea what was there, except for the banana peppers.
… more
emma M
Everyone here is great. I’ve never had a bad order, server, nothing. The food is good and Betty is the absolute best
… more
Cj Conger
They delivered me the wrong order. When I called to tell them, they said I would need to come pick up my order as they can’t redeliver. Terrible customer service. AVOID! Lazy employees!
… more
Kyle Budke
I placed an order online for a veggie revival because it was veggie without olives. The first order was pretty fast and the delivery guy was awesome, howecer they messed up n delivered a normal veggie pizza, no big deal, they replaced it, as long as they got 3/4 of the original one back. The second delivery arrived quickly, and was tge one i originally ordered, but it had a massive amount of olives on it… I can’t eat olives…
… more
justin king
We have always wanted to try Cousin Vinny’s. We gave them a shot a few weeks back and have not been disappointed. We have ordered multiple times over the past few weeks. Every time it has exceeded our expectations. They have truly the best pizza in town and has never been short on toppings. I highly recommend the Family Meal deal! Huge thanks to everyone, we will be back again soon!
… more
Chandler Marshall
Worst pizza place I’ve ever delt with. Pizza is good but waiting over an hour an a half every time I get delivery is ridiculous. 10/10 wouldn’t recommend. Staff is super rude when I called to ask where my order was and I was put on hold then forgotten about. Mad is an understatement.
… more
Jamie Dawn
This is a great place to order late night pizza they were super fast very friendly and helpful the computer was acting out when taking card info and he even gave me $3 off my order for the inconvenience that’s awesome and I ordered my pizza at 230am and it was at my house in less the 15 mins that’s fast and it was hit and delicious great service thank you so much
… more
Nyx Oneiric
We ordered for the first time using the Uber eats app and got 2 pizzas one was mushroom and bacon and the other was half and half with banana mushrooms and spinach on one side and pepperoni on the other. Both my husband and my sister have had food poisoning all night long and both are still feel very sick(it’s the morning of the next day). We reported it to door dash but haven’t received anything back from it yet. For a first experience we would probably not order again.
… more
Sam L
Terrible customer service! I called in an order last night and when I arrived they were experiencing issues with their printer. I was happy to wait as I know how that is. However I was greeted at the counter by a woman who’s words were “I really can’t help you right now, someone else will have to do it”. Well I waited patiently for someone else but after twenty minutes the woman returned to the counter. I was obviously an inconvenience to her. I still put cash in the tip jar again because I know how it is. The woman at the counter made a negative comment about the tip I left saying “I wasn’t tipping her. She doesn’t get that.” and was clearly annoyed by it. She was very inappropriate during my visit. I was never told sorry for any inconvenience or the long wait. On top of the terrible service my food was missing extra cheese that I was charged for.
… more
… View more