Based on 81 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
100 W Main St, Fredonia, NY 14063
Phone: (716) 679-9022
Hours
| Thursday | 2–10 PM |
| Friday | 2–10 PM |
| Saturday | 2–10 PM |
| Sunday | 2–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
2–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 2–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 2–10 PM |
Reviews
Cassandra Holland
Ordered a steak sub with cheese, cooked peppers, onions and mushrooms. Its edible but not great at all. Sub is made with what looks and tastes like a cheap burger patty. Sub is super sloppy and after being told it would take 25 minutes, we showed up to pick up 30 minutes later and the subs weren’t even started yet.
… more
Anita Morales
Service was good, food was ok. They don’t accept anything but cash for payment, so that’s a little inconvenient.
… more
nick kish
Grabbed a slice to go and I gotta say, It tasted like off-brand cleaning products… I’ve had some bad pizza in the past but damn…. Pizza is supposed to be easy lol
… more
Zach Polak
Food is good. Wings are a bit over priced in my opinion at $1 a wing. Pizza was yummy. Just needed a bit more flavor, salt perhaps? Other than that no complaints. I’m sure I will be back.
… more
Marsha Shearer
I’m not taking away stars for a bad order but will advise about it. We have 2 delis and I usually go to the fredonia one because they have better food and service. But we went to order subs and he screwed up big time. I wanted mayo not miracle whip which evidently he doesn’t do real mayo at all. I wanted the sub toasted and he said he toasted it but my fiance sub who’s wasn’t supposed to be toasted was warmer then mine. Then he refused to give me my money back because he didn’t advise us on the phone when we said mayo not miracle whip that he didn’t do or have mayo. So we went to the Dunkirk location and they apologized made me my correct sub and we were on our way. Communication is the key here people. Just tell your customers ahead of time that you don’t have or don’t do that anymore. They may say well no mayo and put it on themselves later or something.. be honest!
… more
Lynn Mackey
Food was good. But the guy who answered the phone was quite a prick… he first talked over me and then hung up on me when trying to pay with my card… so I drove down there since the phone was SUCH an inconvenience to him… now what I don’t get is he told me 45mins for a calzone and when I got there they CLEARLY weren’t busy and it became clear why he was SO rushed on the phone… that TV they have in there was more important… NOT THRILLED… As for the girl in the back… “YOU’RE DOING A GREAT JOB!!, sorry your help SUCKS”
… more
April B.
The guy who worked last night was a dick on the phone. He threw my card down on the counter instead of handing it to me. He was more interested in the TV than anything. The food was disgusting. I will drive to Dunkirk in the future. Better service and food!
… more
Matthew Gordon
Love their sauce. Might be me just reminiscing of pizzas from my youth but Mary’s has always been my favorite pizza. Their subs are solid too. If you’re not scared of heartburn I’d highly suggest ‘suicide’ sub.
… more
Keith Terrill
THIS IS NOTHING LIKE THE ORIGINAL ONE IN DUNKIRK. I was treated like I had the plague, it was dark, nothing hardly in the display, one word answers, and against my better judgement I ordered a half sub that was far too expensive for what little it was. AND THE FLIES WERE EVERYWHERE! CRAWLING ON THE COUNTER, THE PAPER THEY PUT THE SUB ON – HE DID SHAKE THEM OFF FIRST! **** I will NEVER go here again and I recommend NO ONE SHOULD EVER GO HERE — EVER **** !!!!!
… more
Jody Scott
Best pizza in town!!!!
… more
… View more