Local pizzeria chain serving wide range of pizzas (including famed pepperoni), subs, salads & more. Based on 109 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5068 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026
Phone: (614) 756-4111
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rob Howell
Don’t expect good service. The boy at the counter mumbles without any care to put any energy into service. I felt like we where interrupting his time. And I guess they didn’t want to deal with customers since they had the place packed up at 7:30 when there hours are till 10. What a joke
… more
Arielle Goldstein
We had a great experience at Massey’s pizza. We needed a last minute location for over 20 people for a celebration of life, and Eric and Todd were wonderful to work with. Great food and very reasonably priced, even for a crowd. The staff was nice enough to reserve the dining room for us and move tables so we could sit together, everything was set up when we arrived. One of our party had the gluten free cauliflower crust and she really enjoyed it. I highly recommend their cheese pizza, very well seasoned, and my husband loved their pepperoni. We’re looking forward to dining here again, once again, great food, staff, and experience.
… more
Joan May
We have been a Massey pizza fans for a long time. We would often drive out of our way just to get some Massey pizza. We were so excited when they opened up in the Hilliard location. But the experience was less than impressive. The pizza was not the same as in any other locations. I gave them a benefit of a doubt the first couple times that they were newer location and might need some time to get it right. But it’s been months now and it wasn’t getting any better at all. In fact, it’s getting worse. It’s so frustrating and disappointing.
… more
Thomas Wimbish
I grew up getting Massey’s pizza from the Reynoldsburg location, and always liked their pizza. However, the two pizzas I received from this location didn’t look or tasted anywhere close to the pizza I used to get from the Reynoldsburg location. So I’m not sure if there is or should be a difference in taste between locations, but if there is I’ll stick to only getting pizza from the Reynoldsburg location.
… more
Daniel Sizemore
Placed a phone credit card order at the Whitehall store and was charged double and within 5 minutes had two fraudulent charges placed on my card(was alerted by the bank). When I called the store they denied any knowledge and couldn’t even remove the charge for two pizzas when I only ordered one. Next day I called the corporate office and was told they wouldn’t dispute the second charge and would investigate the fraud. I never heard from them again. Skip ahead one year and my grandson who lives with me ordered a pizza from there without me knowing. They at first said they don’t deliver here. Then said payment would have to be in cash. He was ok with that and ordered a pizza that never arrived. Absolutely worst pizza experience ever especially for the high prices they charge. I would give zero stars if that was an option.
… more
Vinnie Gambino
The manager emilly was an absolute pleasure to deal with she makes you feel as if you have known her for a long time. She even bussed my table and brought our food to our table definitely a great addition to the team there at that store
… more
Chuck Holt
To get a five star rating from a self declared “pizza snob” is quite the feat. My wife and I dined in at the Hilliard location Sunday afternoon. We were greeted by Antonio and ordered a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was the best that we have ever eaten! We are still talking about it. Keep up the good work, Antonio!
… more
Ron Edgerley
This is not what a Massey’s Pepperoni Pizza is suppose to look like. This is gas station pizza at best. Nothing like the Westerville, 161, Gahana or Grove city locations. Please fix this Massey’s. The people of Hilliard deserve better. So disappointing.
… more
Patrick McConnell
Ordered a 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 veggie. Looked like they piled some veggies on top of a precooked cheese pizza. Nevermind the pepperoni?? Called to complain once home but was left on hold for 7 minutes.
… more
dale mitchell
I am reviewing the lunch buffet. At $13 it’s a waste of money. The salad on the salad bar is limp, almost like the lettuce has been frozen. There are only two pizzas on the pizza bar and they have been sitting there without a heat source for longer than they should. The pizza is cold. Very disappointed with this experience and will not return
… more
… View more