Based on 49 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
5 Udall Rd, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone: (631) 587-1172
Website: https://www.italianospizzeriamenu.com/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ana Roman
Good pizza and excellent delivery drivers. However i realized the price increase and due to this, i will buy pizza elsewhere. $18.50 for a regular pie and delivery within 2 miles, and on top of that you have to add tip. On top of that they removed the coupon on the boxes.
… more
PJ McKenna
My wife and I eat at Italianos roughly once a week. The staff is great, the service is excellent, and the food is top notch. It’s a great “feel at home” local Italian joint and we have known the owners of both Italianos and Bonos Pizza for years. Great business people and a great family as well. They are definitely a plus for Suffolk County. I would recommend them to anyone.
… more
ABstvc
1 old fashioned Sicilian pie, 2 eggplant slices and a slice with broccoli and grilled chicken cost $55?! The old fashioned Sicilian pie was piss poor. Large globs of sauce mixed with the bread crumbs to make a mushy sour mess that lacked in onions and was more or less inedible…avoid this 23 dollar pile of disappointment. The eggplant slice was almost as unimpressive. The only decent parts of the overpriced meal were the garlic knots and the broccoli and chicken slice. Is there any decent pizza in West Islip? So far I’ve been continuously disappointed.
… more
Richard Ortiz
I ordered spaghetti and sausages i thought the tomatoe sauce was supposed to look in the traditional red but i was told they added carrots and the sauce looks now orange. It did taste good like tomato sauce adding to the sausages that came with the spaghetti was not sliced and served without any cilantro. The slices were ok the Zeppelins were ok. I spent $25 on two slices two drinks 6 Zeppelins and that spaghetti dinner. To bad i could not take any photos.. Maybe next time… Seems like a good place maybe its just the spaghetti and meatballs that i give it a low number.
… more
Devin Rouff
Love their pizza, garlic knots and wings. Unique crust on the pizza. Everything I’ve tried from here has been very good. Definitely recommend them to anyone looking for a great pizza spot.
… more
Jacqueline Besanceney
Last week my cub scouts had a delicious pizza party at Italianos, and while we basically took over their dining area, we never saw anything but smiles from the wonderful people working there.
… more
Gabrielle Cameron
Great food great atmosphere. Wonderful welcoming family restaurant. Perfect for any occasion or just a family dinner. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone.
… more
Michael Rietta
Excellent food, and service! The weekly specials are great! Can not praise this business enough! Keep it up!
… more
Yvonne Pescitelli
Great take out and outstanding food and service in the dining area. Joe Farese is an amazing waiter. I would highly recommend this restaurant.
… more
Robbie Rob
Really friendly staff. Great pizza. They seem to actually care about their customers.
… more
… View more