Previously NY Upper Crust Pizza, under NEW ownership. Introducing Sal’s Pizzeria serving the best Grandma Pie in Southern California. Sal has been making this relatively unknown Grandma Pie since the 1950s and has perfected his recipe. New Yorkers have been eating grandma pie for many years and only have a handful of restaurants serving the grandma pizza. So, we are so excited to bring it to Southern California and to share this epic pizza experience with you!
Based on 106 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
26612 Towne Centre Dr F, Lake Forest, CA 92610
Phone: (949) 951-7400
Website:
Social Profile: ![]()
Hours
| Friday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kurt Hoppe
Disappointing on so many levels.
… more
CA
Planned all day to place an order for pick up for dinner for my family but no one answered the phone Sunday July 30th at 6:07pm. Called many times within a half hour period. No one ever answered. This would have been our first order with you guys apart from slices in the store. Had a few questions too but I guess I’ll never know, no staff answers the phone. Will call another pizza place, you guys obviously are too busy to handle phone orders.
… more
Ron Deo
Pretty good pizza for the location. Ordered whole meat lovers and hawaiian pizzas to go. The staff was friendly when I entered and the pizzas came out fresh when picking them up. Also ordered garlic knots but they were ok as the dough wasn’t as soft as I’d like it to be. Otherwise I’d visit again to try their other pizzas.
… more
ALEEF02
Looks great after the grand opening! Glad to enjoy my time here. The pizza slices are large and delicious. The new soda machine has just about any drink you can think of. The new design really fits all together and is visually pleasing. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone with an appetite!
… more
Quinn
We ordered off of UberEats and so glad we did. Top of the line pie that you do not see often in SoCal! I was not surprised to see them ranked best in OC for pizza. Will be back and a must try for all! Got the Ny style but will try other styles next time. Thank you Sals!
… more
Viktor Uygan
At first it may look like your average pizza joint, but Sal’s Pizzeria is anything but!
… more
Cerin P
The pizza is fantastic and the employees are friendly and welcoming. I like that they heat up the single slices for you. We tried several kinds of their pizza and all were great.
… more
SNAP Architectural Photography
Awesome pizza! Honestly one of the only places that reminds me of a legit New York pizzeria. They have actual white pizza done right! And all the pizzeria extras You could ever want. My new favorite! Hey Sal!!
… more
Josh Marble
The Stromboli was so good and everything else on their menu looks good! If you need carry out and or grab and go dine in and it’s a cool plaza to eat at.
… more
Kim Johnson
We have ordered 4 times and every time the consistency of the food has been great!
… more
… View more
