Based on 377 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1 Constitution St, Potsdam, NY 13676
Phone: (315) 265-0475
Website: https://www.facebook.com/MamaLuciaPotsdam/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Crystal Bejjani
I had never been to Mama Lucia’s before August 1. Boy oh boy have I ever been missing out!! the atmosphere is awesome, food was excellent. We will definitely frequent this restaurant from now on!
… more
Nate Parks
Honestly, I was expecting better food. It was okay, but not flavor that you would rave about to all your friends. My delmonico steak wasn’t worth $39.99. Helpings were very generous however. Certainly try it. Hopefully your experience will be different. Like I said, it was good, not great.
… more
Kaitlyn K
Honestly I was quite disappointed with the food we received. I thought for the prices it would be good quality Italian food. I had a female hair in my calamari which was soggy. our chicken parmesan came with a tiny thin piece of chicken without any cheese, which makes the dish obviously. If you’re going to charge over $20 for an entree at least make sure it’s well made. $88 total and I wouldn’t recommend this restaurant sadly.
… more
Ed Smith
Food is okay. Definitely better options in town for all of the options they offer.
… more
Sandy Sponzo
Our server, L.J. was phenomenal! Our family enjoyed a wonderful meal from start to finish. The food was well prepared, presented, and delicious! The atmosphere of this establishment is outstanding. It is family friendly, and we felt very welcomed. The restaurant was recommended to us from our server, Lexie (from Maxfields).
… more
Deborah Keesler
A favorite with locals and college crowd. Bustlng Italian restaurant with a friendly atmosphere. Plenty of parking. Ramp and special door for guests that require access without stairs. Plenty of menu choices and so far they have all been fabulous. They are some fun nooks for group seating and tables on an outdoor patio. Reservations are recommended so you don’t miss out on a meal here.
… more
jeremy riedl
Like most of the restaurants in Potsdam this place is owned by Larry. There is little competition so he’s just mailing it in. My wife ordered eggplant parmesan which was very bland. She took the leftovers home and I added some basic seasoning to it: basil, garlic, oregano and reheated it for her and she said it was 100% better. My daughter’s both got pasta dishes. One ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and the other the Alfredo pasta. Both were serviceable and ok, but nothing to write home about. I ordered a wood fired pizza which was supposed to have fresh basil and tomatoes on it. The fresh basil was nowhere to be found and the tomatoes were sparse and clearly the same used for sandwich slices. There was also a copious amount of grease pooling on top due to the cheap cheese they use. It was edible. My wife found a dead fly in the bottom of her soda cup. Like most of Larry’s restaurants there is no air conditioning so expect to be hot if it’s hot out. Sometimes the bathrooms are out of service. The wait staff are good. All in all of you’re looking for overpriced, premade frozen Italian food this is the place for you. Honestly there isn’t a real decent Italian restaurant for 50 miles at least around Potsdam nor is there a decent pizza for about 50 miles.
… more
Patricia Torcello Catalina
Delicious, well prepared Italian cuisine! Friendly and efficient wait staff. Prices are reasonable for the quality and amount of food ordered. Plenty of room for small or large seating. Half price pasta specials on Thursdays! Mangia!
… more
Michelle Boots
It was…..not sure if I would order anything but the pizza again. Dont get me wrong, liked it…but I prefer my pasta cooked a little more then the 3 pasta dishes we had. The chicken riggie pasta tasted basically like it came fresh out of box, sauce on it and served
… more
Megan Prionas
We love this place for quality Italian dishes in a casual atmosphere. Service is always friendly and willing to make adjustments for our toddler. The wood fired oven pizza is an absolute must!
… more
… View more