What exactly do we mean by family owned and operated? When you order from Patellini’s, you can be pretty certain that one of the family members-make your food. They are experienced masters at creating the finest New York Style Pizza Sarasota has to offer. So give us a call or come check out our restaurant right on Main Street in the heart of downtown Sarasota.
So stop into Patellini’s to grab some quality New York style pizza before you hit St. Armand’s, Siesta Key or maybe go for a stroll downtown. And if pizza’s not your game, we’ve got you covered with our premium traditional Italian pastas, subs, and salads.
Parlor offering pies & pasta at sidewalk tables or in a contemporary interior with flat-screen TVs. Based on 640 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1429 Main St, Sarasota, FL 34236
Phone: (941) 957-6433
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mike Hopkins
We had a craving for a good cheese pizza and we decided to give Patellini’s Pizza a try. It did not disappoint. The New York style cheese pizza was delicious, not greasy at all, and had a nice crisp crust. We also tried a variation of the white pizza and the garlic bread which also came out great. The price was very fair for the size of the pizza. I am glad we decided to give them a try , well worth it. Ordering was easy, delivery was quick, no issues with the order on arrival. Overall a good experience
… more
Kells (BossLady_K)
Now this is really good pizza! The crust was perfect and there was just the right amount of toppings. Haven’t had a pizza this good in years.
… more
D I
We ordered delivery and can report, this is the best pizza we’ve had in Sarasota. The sauce in particular was delicious. The crust could use a bit more crisp, otherwise the pizza is excellent.
… more
Xander Cantrell
Never had NY Style pizza before so I can’t give it the most proper judgement, but the cheese slice was delicious and didn’t break the bank! Got a coke too and they were more then happy to let me get some refills in before I left.
… more
PJ Guthy
Pizza and salad last night during a hurricane. It was our backup plan to sushi which was closed. Grew up in NY, worked in Manhattan for years. Nice people, good service but the pizza is average at best. Kind of dry, not much sauce, little cheese, little substance, short on flavor. If you are looking for NY style pizza that is bold, saucy, cheesy, flavorful, this is not it. Just…average.
… more
Pizarro
I got two slices with barely any sauce. Looked like a rat bit into it. Do not let the Italian name fool you. This is run by a bunch of Indians. This place makes Papa John’s look like a five star gourmet restaurant.
… more
shauna stallings
Day of christmas boat parade, they accommodated my party of 10. Pizza was huge and fantastic. 20 inch is massive! Some crusts were a bit under cooked but over all great.
… more
Jake M
I found this place while walking in downtown one night, and I have no idea why I never came in before!
… more
Sadler L. James
They always run a special, today it was 2 slices cheese pizza and a drink for $7.99 plus tax. I go to the movies at the downfown Regal theater and then stop by for the pizza special. I like the thin crust and put the red pepper flakes on it, with a little Parmigiano cheese. I request an extra crisp crist and they always do it. Good service. The store is always clean and neat.
… more
Ryan Marcus
I was hoping that a pizza place with an Italian name would know a thing or two about pizza, and take pride in their food. I diddn’t think there was anything comparable to chucke.cheese pizza (soft, cardboard, powder, etc). The large pizza I ordered from this place was about as comparable as it gets, although I give the edge to Chuck. Unless you enjoy cold, stale, rubbery pizza – stay away from this place. Gross.
… more
… View more
