Based on 717 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
N84W15841 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051
Phone: (262) 251-6500
Hours
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | 4–8 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Margaret Namio
Great food. Exceptional service. I love that they have fresh mushrooms available for their pizza. (Make sure you request this if you prefer fresh mushrooms over canned). Great Old World decor. Fantastic experience! Very highly recommend. Looking forward to coming back often.
… more
Carmen Morales Rico
I did a take out order which it was ready in 20 min. Staff very friendly and atmosphere seemed very nice. Pizzas were okay there was something….probably hungry IDK… truth is for 58 dollars I was expecting more….I also order meat balls. Also there was sign reading that starting August fish fry Fridays will not longer be all you can eat ☹
… more
Amber Otter-Priem
Family owned and operated; have always loved their pizzas both regular and gluten free, dining in or carry out. Friday we tried two fish fry options; regular cod and a baked cod with lemon butter Angelina sauce carry out. They both had options of French fries or baked potatoes with coleslaw and four slices of Italian bread. The regular fish fry looked a bit odd at first; fish wrapped and deep fried but fish was perfectly cooked and “breading” very light. The baked Angelina cod was a good lemon butter sauce but was swimming in it. Next time I’ll try just the lemon butter but will be back! Very reasonably priced and most affordable in the area and well packaged carry out.
… more
Kathy Pica
Our food was great! Our waitress was very attentive, nice & made our experience great! We love going to Pepinos. Always a great experience.
… more
Rick Abraham
This place is great. We periodically drive up from Lake county Illinois just to eat here. The Pizza is awesome. We went recently to have family style all you can eat fried cod. Comes w potato, bread basket, coleslaw. They also have a great full food menu and full bar for beers on tap, wines and spirits. So there’s really something for everyone.
… more
Christine Miller
Arrived early and got seated right away. They do get very busy. Service was prompt and friendly. Everyone enjoyed their meal. Large portions of pasta.
… more
Doreen Mishler
Been coming here for Friday fish for years. Their Italian bread and tarter sauce are the best I have had anywhere. The mozzarella sticks are absolutely the best. Their pizza is super yummy too. Always great service with a smile. You won’t be disappointed.
… more
Michael Lloyd
The employees here are rude. This must be acceptable behavior by management considering the person on the phone who identified himself as the owner is more worried about being insulting to me than taking the time to listen to the fact that he has a rude employee who is running customers off.
… more
Lana Reinsvold
My favorite Italian restaurant. Their cheese bread and pizza are the best. Bar is very nice, cozy atmosphere.
… more
Jessica F.
Food was great…. Timing not the best however, but everything did come out hot. And staff is super friendly.
… more
… View more